I like the door choice, with a side light.

I'd paint it a yellow/orange kind of school bus yellow, would look great with your siding

and fresh with some color in those pots.

I find that door a little too modern/office for your home.

I couldn't find the exact slate color, but here is a dark door.

Here is how the MCM door looks. I actually really like it, but I think you would need to add more modern accessories to go with it -- updated porch light, planters and new, modern house numbers (in place of the name placard).

Or how about a similar style door that's a touch less modern, like this one. I could see this working in a white that matches your window trim, and paint the garage as well.

Or in dark charcoal (almost black), but I like the white better.

I agree with @P Banos. Even three lights across the top in a shorter configuration would be OK - it's the half circle look of the current door light that needs to be updated. Unless you've decorated very modern inside, then the one you chose would work.

Now that I see that style in photos I don't think it looks right either. Hmm. I am wondering about a reddish orange flat panel instead? I like the idea of something modern but not exactly that modern if that makes sense. The one with the tiny windows on top is ok I guess? Maybe it's the black that isn't doing it for me. Thank you for all your input! I am going to keep looking and update with other ideas!

Could you paint the current door in the red/orange to see the pop it will give?

Those doors are nice but don’t work with your house for me. IDK…maybe a door like kandrewspa suggested with a shorter configuration across the top. Or, just a single rectangular window across the top that mimics the rectangles in your windows, especially the basement and second story windows.

I came up with these two ideas... the second photo of course would only have 1 sidelight but I like the simplicity and it's not traditional but not really modern either? The color wouldn't be exactly that one - but maybe something in that color family. It's too bright for me. Thoughts?

I think the last door style in orange. A rich orange door or a soft tangerine.

^^ yes, darker/muted orange, not red. overall, a red door would be too much like flag colors, something I don't really love for a house.