Can you post pictures of your two choices on the sample boards? Are you going to be changing the color of the house also, or just the roof?

have no idea what those roof colors look like, so post a pic.

Nevermind, I did the work and looked them up.

this is burnt sienna. It's very varigated and is going to compete w/your driveway pattern.

Weathered wood on the left. works w/your house color, clashes w/your driveway.

Because of your driveway, it would be best if you got one solid color roof tile.

can you do a clay tile?

Do you have plans on painting the stucco in the future?

Much better colors to work w/your driveway.

because of that driveway color, your stucco, or at the minimum your garage doors, should have a diff color.

your driveway pavers are somewhat driving the color bus. you'll have to pick roof tiles that word w/those, as well as the stucco color.

I actually like this combo. Timberline Wheat, with better colors for the house.

My bad , the gaf shingle is called driftwood.   It's the first on the left.   I saw a model house in south Florida using the attached color on their models and was thinking of using those colors.  .   All feedback appreciated

Get a sample of the roofing shingle, and put it by the driveway. Get a couple of samples of some of the different ones. Thats the only way, you are going to pick the right one for your house. Your driveway is beautiful.