skip to main content

Flooring Design Dilemma Kitchens

Need help picking tile for kitchen floor!

2 years ago

last modified: 2 years ago

Hello! We recently moved into a new home and will be remodeling the kitchen in the Spring. The kitchen, mudroom and powder room all share the same tile and while we would like to keep these areas tiled, we are looking to change them. Here are the pictures of the spaces. I do not have a picture of the powder room (off of the mudroom) but it's pretty basic and has the same tile floor.

The house is a cape cod style house with traditional elements and architecture. The idea for the kitchen is English inspired with modern functionality. I would love to use natural stone floors (i.e. limestone, travertine or slate), but between our budget and the upkeep that's required to maintain natural stone, we've decided to go with a porcelain tile that looks like stone. I'm usually the kind of person who doesn't like things trying to pretend like they're something else, but in this case, I'm totally OK going in the porcelain tile route. We've chosen the tile we like and have narrowed it down to two colors. Important to note is that we will be re-finishing the floors and both stair cases in a medium brown stain that isn't red like what you see above.

Here are pictures of the tiles with sample of our kitchen finishes. The white-ish tile at the top of each picture is Cle zellige tile in weathered white. That's what we will be using for our backsplash and hood. The sample on the left is what our island will be - it will be black stained white oak with beadboard panels. And the sample on the right will be the permiter cabinet color which is Benjamin Moore Creamy White.

The first of the tile is a black/dark grey color that looks like slate. I am drawn to this because I love a moody kitchen. I think this tile would add some drama and make a statement. I worry that this tile can make my kitchen look too dark.

The second tile is a beige color that looks like travertine. I feel like this is a pretty choice, but is it too "safe"?

Please help me make a decision! Thank you

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

Carrie B
2 years ago
Can you post a photo of your proposed new layout?
herbflavor
2 years ago
last modified: 2 years ago
if the kitchen functions I think I'd leave the cabs as is. they are expensive goods and look in good shape. I would spend on hardwood flooring. You will save by simply doing that. use paint to rid the gray hall color. it should be fresher there with the wide space and potential for some decor/aesthetics .
Related Discussions
Need Help with picking tile for floor
Q
Comments (1)
Sorry I really can't add anything of value but I had to comment on that fabulous kitchen floor you shared above. I hope someone can chime in with some knowledge but for now I will just admire........
...See More
I need help picking flooring for livingroom/kitchen..go dark or light
Q
Comments (4)
If you are in the fortunate situation that it's one selection for the whole area just get what you like. When the 2 areas end up not matching, that is what makes the space look smaller...the discrepancy/ contrasts. Just get what you like.
...See More
Need help picking a floor tile!
Q
Comments (5)
I agree with above. I found a 4 inch matte black hex at overstock and wayfair for a great price. Nice silver grey grout.
...See More
Tetris shaped kitchen - need flooring help. Tile look but not tile
Q
Comments (0)
I have the strangest shaped kitchen layout, literally looks like a tetris piece. Full kitchen reno is still a few years away and will totally change the layout. But, we are redoing the floors (hardwood) in the rest of the house. Currently the whole first floor is awful tile over the hardwood (UGH), except this area. This is tile over subfloor. We are doing the demo just once, so this area will just be subfloor. We were thinking that we would put laminate or LVP in this area that looks like tile. Looking for suggestions. It's probably less than 100 sq ft. Full kitchen reno is years away, so want something that's not just a cheap short term fix. Laying new tile is not an option - it's really hard on my feet. Can you share pictures of either laminate or LVP that looks like tile? Thanks
...See More
G Marlow
Original Author
2 years ago
last modified: 2 years ago
@Carrie B Here you go. We are swapping the location of the stove and the sink, so that the stove will now be along a permiter wall and the sink will be in the island. We decided to do that so we can fit a hood for ventilation - something that the house curently lacks. The fridge will also move; from the left side of the back permiter wall to the right side. The desk along the wall that you see in one of my original photos will not be staying. An undercounter beverage/wine fridge will take it's place along with cabinet to it's right - sorry, I don't have the elevations for that wall. The only cabinets that will be staying are the floor to ceiling cabinets that you see on either side of the doorway to the mudroom.
G Marlow
Original Author
2 years ago
last modified: 2 years ago
@herbflavor Thank you for your comment! I have also considered hardwood floors in the kitchen, but I am loving the idea of tile in here to give the space a European vibe, if that makes sense. We have radiant heat on our first floor so I love the feel of the heat underfoot on the tile...just a personal preference.

The floor to ceiling inset cabinetry flanking the doorway to the mudroom is original and in wonderful shape so we will be keeping those. They will be painted to match the new cabinetry. Unfortunately the island, desk and the cabinetry on the opposite wall are in terrible shape and will be replaced. We are flip flopping the location of the stove and sink and the fridge will also move so we need new cabinetry anyway.

The entire first floor including the mud room hall will be getting new paint (Benjamin Moore Swiss Coffee or White Dove) so the rooms will lighten up considerably. We are also adding vertical paneling under the shaker peg rail in the mudroom to add some architectural detail.
decordummy_gw
2 years ago
last modified: 2 years ago
I think I like the first one (that looks like slate).

Do you envision something like these colours?

I think your first pic could look nice in both the kitchen and mud room.
G Marlow
Original Author
2 years ago
@decordummy_gw Thanks for sharing your thoughts!

I do envision the first one. I noticed I was pinning a lot of pictures on Pinterest with dark/light grey slate-like floors. This picture is a major inspiration.

Related Stories

KITCHEN OF THE WEEK Kitchen of the Week: Graphic Floor Tiles Accent a White Kitchen

By Jeannie Matteucci

Walls come down to open up the room and create better traffic flow

REMODELING GUIDES Tile Floors Help a Hot Home Chill Out

By Laura Gaskill

Replace your hot-weather woes with a cool feel for toes when you treat your floors to deliciously refreshing tile

KITCHEN OF THE WEEK Kitchen of the Week: Ikea-Hack Cabinets and Fun Floor Tile

By Marianne Lipanovich

A designer turns an uninspiring kitchen into an inviting and functional contemporary space

KITCHEN BACKSPLASHES This Kitchen’s Geometric Blue Tile Steals the Show

By Karen Egly-Thompson

An Asian-inspired island, newly stained floors and white cabinets complete the look

KITCHEN DESIGN Kitchen Workbook: Tools to Pick Kitchen Stools

By Lisa Frederick

There's more to choosing a kitchen stool than you may think. These guidelines help remove the guesswork when you're picking a perch

KITCHEN DESIGN Kitchen of the Week: Tile Sets the Tone in a Modern Farmhouse Kitchen

By Carol Crotta

A boldly graphic wall and soft blue cabinets create a colorful focal point in this spacious new Washington, D.C.-area kitchen

KITCHEN DESIGN Patterned Tile Showcases an Open Kitchen’s New Minibar

By Allison McLeay

A couple’s kitchen update puts the focus on entertaining by inviting guests in for a drink

KITCHEN DESIGN Kitchen Flooring 101: Find Your Material Match

By Lisa Frederick

From cork to concrete, our guide will help you pick the perfect surface for your kitchen floor

KITCHEN DESIGN Subway Tile Picks Up Gray Grout

By Living Small: City & Small Space Consulting

Heading into darker territory, subway tile offers a graphic new look for kitchens, bathrooms and more

KITCHEN DESIGN How to Pick a Kitchen Backsplash That Wows

By Vanessa Brunner

Design your ideal backsplash with help from these Houzz guides and inspiring ideas for every kitchen style

Sponsored

EK Interior Design

5 Reviews

TIMELESS INTERIOR DESIGN FOR ENDLESS MEMORIES

More Discussions

HELP! Keep early 2000’s oak trim, replace flooring and countertops

12

Too much gray for the bathroom?

25

bathroom floor options

11

What color stain should I go with?

3

concrete floor coating recommendations

3