Light gray with green undertone for the body would look great with your orange toned roof- with a crisp white for the trim.

Teakwood chairs

Thank you all so much! We agree and will keep the fence color the same. If any of you are willing, can you answer some follow-up questions regarding the siding? I have a few concerns about going with a dark charcoal gray. I Though I think it's a beautiful color, is it not a very trendy color, thus at risk of going out of style soon? I did some research, and it seems a lot of people like SW Peppercorn, which is lovely. I'm concerned the neighbors would object because all the houses on our street our very pale beige-like colors. Would ours stand out too much against the light colored homes? I see all of you suggested the charcoal because it's in the paver, so that makes a lot of sense. Is there any other color I can pull from the pavers that would work? I'm very bad with seeing colors clearly, so I appreciate the help.

Don't install the shutters. You have big, beautiful windows. Don't ruin the look with the wrong sized shutters. Your windows are too large for properly sized shutters. You simply don't have the wall room next to your big windows unless you put in the ugly undersized shutters which would ruin your home's appearance. Here is a brief article to show you why: https://www.lifeofanarchitect.com/residential-architecture-101-shutters/ As to the black gutters and downspouts: where are you putting them? The black downspouts will highlight that area no matter which color you chose to paint the body of the house. Is that the intent? Or is the intent to have black gutters and all the downspouts painted the same color as the body? Please clarify. Work on your hardscaping (walkway at the entrances is too narrow) and landscaping to truly finish your home. Landscaping can make or break your home's appearance and would be far better than the shutters IMO.