Just looking at the cream colored tiles.

Are the cabinets going to be the wood color? Or the white? The wood color cabinets look really nice with the countertop, but the white doesn't. You need beige or warm white, not the stark cool white, which doesn't work with your lovely wood cabinets or countertops at all. If all the cabinets are going to be painted that white color, then I think you'll need a new countertop as well as new backsplash.

I like the cream one under the dark tile. Very pretty. Edited to add: It looks cream on my screen and matching to the lightest color in the granite. I agree about the white cabinet as housegal stated. I'd paint it cream.

Simplest: match the tile exactly to the lightest background shade in the granite. On my screen, none of your choices are even close to that shade, which seems to be a golden color. When you have more samples for the next round, test the colors in natural daylight, artificial lights on during the day, and nighttime lighting.

One of your problems is that you have very white cabinets mixed in with the wood. Those white cabinets don't harmonize with the granite and should've been painted the lightest shade of background from the granite.

The white cabinets will be repainted. Backsplash first. I think the pictures don’t really show the creaminess of the tiles. It’s so hard!!!

I am going to say none of the above, not so much because of color, but rather the details.

The tiles that are already there go better with the countertops than any of your samples. Is there a reason you're changing the backsplash. Are all the cabinets to be painted? Please provide more details about what plans you have in mind and show the entire kitchen. You've only provided a small view of poorly lit photos.

We might recommend trying to match the backsplash to the lightest color in the countertop, or one of the lightest colors in the countertop. Notice in this design of ours included here, the backsplash matches the countertop perfectly.

Contemporary Kitchen & Bath · More Info

I agree with the above. It will be a lot if looking, but you will find a light white that will match the counter.