I’d do a designer glass, kinda how your tree is reflecting in the glass now, spraying up like a fan design. As far as the color I’d try to match the windows

Lots of colors going on. White siding, pink brick, shutters appear to be a wood.
White trim. Black door. I’d consider painting the frames of window frames and getting rid of the shutters. The brick can be stained (not painted) if you want to change the color. But I’d go with a dark/light theme. Using the link brick as the lighter contrast

I know you didn’t ask. But remove the shutters.

It’ll change the whole appearance of the home.

—-

And can you whitewash the brick?

....

Sorry! I just think the current door isn’t a problem. And those other two things would be more of a priority for me.

——

I love wood doors. But if nothing changes on the exterior of the home I think black works best.

It's good to say why you are doing something -- helps keep things on track.

Is there a problem with the current door such that it requires replacement?

Taken in isolation, I like the color of the existing door, but when looking at the entire house, I see that all your windows and trim are white, which suggest that the door, or at least its trim should also be white.

This thread was in the Related Discussions panel on the right and might give you some ideas.

https://www.houzz.com/discussions/5276808/help-with-new-front-entry-door

Thank you for your input.

Yes, we need to change the front door because the bottom sill and lower side jambs have water damage and is starting to leak during heavy rain storms. The current door is a very dark green, which is what the old shutters were. I was trying to avoid matching to the shutters again and go with something more neutral.

I never thought about removing the shutters, that might be a good idea for a different look. I might have some issues with the siding having faded over the years since the front gets direct sun half the day.

Some other ideas to think of though, thanks for your input.

Remove shutters, increase size of lanterns to be 1/3 of the door's height, find a Romabio stain to change the brick color. Then pick the door/storm colors.

If you don't remove the shutters, paint them black and then a black door would coordinate. I don't think you want to introduce another color or stain to what you have already.

100% agree with decoenthusiaste. I came here to sidetrack you by making the same suggestions.

See this thread for the OP's journey. Small changes make a huge difference.

https://www.houzz.com/discussions/6037906/exterior-redesign#27194220

No Shutters

Painted no shutters

I’d stain the brick using NewLook concrete stain. Then I’d tear off all the vinyl siding and replace with hardie plank.

Thank you everyone for your input. You have given a lot of good ideas and much more to think about than I even considered. You have definitely made me think out of the box and I appreciate your time.