Bad Return Air Duct in Basement

2 years ago

last modified: 2 years ago

Hello Guys,

I need some guidance.

I have an 1800 sqft house in Canada. I just moved in, it's a 19-year-old semi-detach.

In the basement I have 2 vents 1 for Supply Air(in the living room) and 1 for Return Air(in the bedroom), I removed the vent cover for cleaning and found the following:

The boot duct was not connected to the cover. there was around a 3-5 inch difference.
I removed the boot duct as it was kinda broken. and found the air duct had 20 inches of top part cut off.

now what's happening is, because this return air duct is wide open between the drywall(basement ceiling) and floor(living room 1st floor). This space also leads to the Furness room(basement), which has 2 doors(1 in the basement bedroom, second in the basement living room), so basically, all the air from the Furness room and basement bedroom are sucked back in from this duct.

1 more imp thing is there is no return vent in the first floor/living room. I have 3 return vents on the top floor though(1 in the hallway and 2 in rooms).

I have few questions:

Should I seal this opening and make a vent out of it. if vent then how big of boot I needed, 4/5/6 inches?
is it a good idea to have a return vent in the basement bedroom and a Supply in the Basement Living room? or no return vent in the basement will work? I will be renting the basement out, so it's separate from other parts of the house.

in your opinion is this a bad design? Please advise what should I do.

let me know if something is not clear and I will update you with more details.

Thanks

Featured Answer

PRO

Charles Ross Homes

2 years ago

High-efficiency furnaces have a dedicated, ducted supply of outside air for combustion air and a dedicated exhaust. Your Lennox furnace has a lifetime warranty on the heat exchanger, so a corroded-through heat exchanger is not likely. Bottom line: it's possible, but not probable that your heat exchanger has failed; accordingly, the likelihood of combustion gases entering your home is minimal.

Proper HVAC creates balanced flows of supply and return air. The supply and return ducts should be continuous with the goal of providing the same amounts of supply and return air.

Comments (8)

vinamra bhatnagar
Original Author
2 years ago
Hi Austin, it's a natural gas furnace. What are my options here. Patch the duct and put a boot to it? Or close it all together. But if I close it, it will increase the pressure in return duct, if this is true, do I need another vent in other part of home like living room to reduce the pressure?

Thanks
PRO
Austin Air Companie
2 years ago
last modified: 2 years ago
I will be renting the basement out, so it's separate from other parts of the house.

Based on what you say above... you need professional help. Canada isn't really known for "mild" winters.

Rental Real Estate is a long term game. The number one killer in a real estate portfollio is "liability".

If you weren't renting this out, the people you endanger are your own. CO is a colorless, odorless gas that can kill you. Not to scare you, these are facts.

Do yourself a favor and get professional help in your area. That furnace needs "combustion" air to work safely. If you plan to be a successful rental real estate tycoon, that is your way forward.
Related Discussions
replacing a return air duct
Q
Comments (2)
you need to go back to the main trunk line. air travels the path of least resistance. if you tap off of another return line and one is shorter than the other the air will mostly be drawn from that one. not to mention you are restricted by the size of the return run you are taking it from. it will work better coming off of main trunk line.
...See More
Calculating return air grille sizes and duct work
Q
Comments (1)
First, I figured you would not answer any questions and about 8 years ago I did have a blower test and ESP test done and the manual J performed and none of them would show me the results except to say, I needed a 4.5 ton unit which is on the fence, right? And all said they would have used the same duct work and the blower test was 34 out of like 50 (whatever that value is, I just don't remember). He said not bad and usually sees a lot worse, but could be better and they wanted to gut my duct system and go to all metal duct and both companies pricing was about $6,000 to $7,000 again, about 8 years ago. I had other estimates too, but I don't trust most A/C companies around here as I used to do the repair business years ago and it was mainly window units back then and I know how this business overall operates and you and others online are the exception rather than the rule in residential work. Which is great, but surely you know how bad it is? It is way too competitive and other things I know, I'll just say is very embarrassing to say the least. So, as I do the manual J and D calculations myself I am coming up with between 4 and 4.5 ton system, which you are right, so I see it is going to be oversized. But, I will say we had upper 80 degree days last week and the humiditiy was in the mid 40 percent range in my home as did my 4 ton unit performed and was still comfortable. But, I understand the tighter I make the system, doing as designed will bring the temperature down more quickly and will not be able to control the humidity as well and may become more uncomfortable and cycle more often making it less efficient. Your link is what has made me do what I am doing so far and I thank you for sharing some of your knowledge to the public, I wished I had seen it before I made this move. I know this is not a good excuse, but we had two 14,000 btu portable units in the house this summer and still couldn't keep the temperatue in the house from climbing to 80 degrees during peak outdoor temperature and the central system still would run until midnight before it would shut down briefly. I understand between the leaks and being undersized on return I was losing ground from day one as we bought this model home new. It just seems these portable units would have helped a little bit in keeping the temperature reasonable in our home. I even had a third unit ready to install, but we sweated it out through the end of the cooling season and so, how many would it have taken, 5, 6, or 7 units? Thanks.
...See More
cold air return vent in basement
Q
Comments (3)
You'll hear a lot of debate about this one - some will say you can't do it without calculating a Manual J etc but the reality is there's a lot of boilerplate hvac systems, at least where I am in Canada. I have two returns in the upper floor of my house only a couple of metres apart, and none in the finished basement and none in any of the bedrooms, which I've been told is an 'impossibility' - well here in Canada, it's not and the system works well enough - the master bedroom is a bit cooler with the door closed, but it's above a poorly insulated garage. I see a lot of basements with the return in the ceiling. Warm air does rise, though, and in the summer you might want some of that cooler air in the basement circulating upstairs, so I'm planning to do exactly what you mentioned, put the return near the floor, backing onto the furnace room. If there was some sort of big issue with changed airflow, you could probably block off an equivalent of the downstairs return vent in the upper return, to equalise the air flow, but to this layperson, the SUPPLY of cold air is not as much of an issue if you're not getting cavitation (a vacuum effect because the pump isn't able to suck in as much air as it's trying to deliver.) Take some temperature readings over a few hours in different spots in the house, and make note whether the furnace is running a lot more than it was previously. The 'duct work' typically is either the space between floor joists or a boxed duct around the same size, or, running down the wall, typical stud wall spacing, 16." That's what I see here in British Columbia, again, I'm not an HVAC tech. Don't go excessively large. If you go through the furnace room wall you won't need much in the way of ducting and if you need to you can use thermopan (silver faced cardboard) instead of drywall or OSB to form the 'duct' from the floor up to the return (make sure you cut into the return, not the warm air section and make triple sure you're not going to damage any wires, gas lines, a/c lines etc. As for the return, the standard size grille is about the width of the space between studs I guess so around 16?" If you need to tweak it, you can block sections of it or the upstairs one inside under the grille if you need to. If you're careful, you're not going to damage anything irrevocably.
...See More
Return Air Duct placement 2 story great room DESIGN DILEMMA!
Q
Comments (22)
Iowa, you must have a basement and returns could be "easier" to relocate. Hopefully, those are just returning the CFM required for that room and not the entire house. Be aware that with 18' walls there will be blocking somewhere above those vents or something framing in from whatever's on the other side of that wall which might prevent you from raising the vents up higher (at least easily). A well-advised HVAC designer (not equipment tech) can review the size of both stud space openings through the floor for each vent and possibly find another location/combine a couple if you can meet the CFM flow. The location to the left of FP is too close to the floor register IMO anyway.
...See More
mike_home
2 years ago
I want to confirm the return vent in the basement is a separate room. Is this correct? Is your furnace the high efficiency type where the combustion air is going from the outside through a PVC pipe? Is there a nearby hot water heater near the furnace? You want to make sure there is no back draft of air occurring. If there is a concern, then the return in the basement could probably be eliminated. You have to determine if there is enough return air coming from the one on the second floor. What is the size of your furnace?

I am not following the issue with the vent connections. If you are going to have returns and supplies there should be not gap between the drywall and the duct. A return in the first floor would be good to have, but in your house the three on the second floor may be sufficient.
vinamra bhatnagar
Original Author
2 years ago
Thanks, Mike,

Yes, it's kind of a separate room, drywall on all 4 sides with 2 doors and a vent for inverse pressure(that's what one HVAC guy said)(it's just an opening on the furnace room and living room.

Yes, the furnace is high efficiency type. (Lennox EL196E)

Yes, there is a hot water tank next to it.

Yes, there is a Rubatex insul Tube 180 3/4. I think this is where it's getting air for combustion.

Not sure how to measure the size of the furnace.

I have closed the front opening in the duct. I have left the top opening, now I think the air will be sucked in from there. the area between the duct and wood you see in the image(i think its called joist) is leading to the furnace room,

My concern is, this big of an opening is sucking all the air and the vents on the 2nd floor is not able to suck or are low on return air. if there is low suction on the 2nd floor then no return vent on the 1st floor can cause issues???
mike_home
2 years ago
I am not following what is in the photo. Does the duct in the photo connect back to the furnace return in another room? Why is preventing you from closing the top that is exposed to the joists and drywall and pull air through a vent in the basement?

When the furnace is running, can you feel air being pulled into the second floor return?
vinamra bhatnagar
Original Author
2 years ago
I am unable to close that because it's a furnessed basement and I need to demo quite some drywalls in order to reach to that top opening.

Yes I can feel the air sucked into the second floor return. I did the paper test and it stuck on the vent. But not sure if the suction was enough or this basement opening is sucking every thing.
PRO
CoolAir Inc.
2 years ago
You need a professional contractor to repair this. Delaying will be more problematic.

Bad Return Air Duct in Basement

Charles Ross Homes

Comments (8)

vinamra bhatnagar
Original Author

Austin Air Companie

Related Discussions

mike_home

vinamra bhatnagar
Original Author

mike_home

vinamra bhatnagar
Original Author

CoolAir Inc.

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Bad Return Air Duct in Basement

Charles Ross Homes

Comments (8)

vinamra bhatnagarOriginal Author

Austin Air Companie

Related Discussions

mike_home

vinamra bhatnagarOriginal Author

mike_home

vinamra bhatnagarOriginal Author

CoolAir Inc.

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

vinamra bhatnagar
Original Author

vinamra bhatnagar
Original Author

vinamra bhatnagar
Original Author