I might consider another sofa with its back to the window wall, and the pair of red chairs opposite to form a U shape furniture placement so that it is easy to walk in and sit down on any piece of furniture....also consider a larger area rug, such that all the front legs of all your furniture be placed on the edges of the rug with a cocktail table centered on the sofa that is placed on the wall.

This is an inspiration picture similar to your room, although this has two cocktail tables, but the two sofa two chair idea was an option I would consider....love the room's calm design, small stacking art, gallery wall of three dimensional items, mismatched lamps and end tables, muted pillows and even different sofas....the only paired items in the room are the cocktail tables the chairs and the curtains, but those touches add structure...matched but mismatched. Interesting.

Beverly Hills Family Dwelling · More Info

I like the sofa color, I would get similar to that, a nice neutral sofa looks like it works well. I really like your red chairs.

Unless you need the seating, I don't think you need any other furniture after you get rid of the cream and orange chairs.

I like your big squash colored chair — looks very inviting and comfy! — so I would keep it and then add another interesting, comfy chair in some nice color and get a much larger rug that pulled together all the colors in an interesting way —- and I would get a much bigger lamp, plus the right pillows and art. (I think all these rugs come in big sizes, not sure)

Weave & Wander Calendra Tufted Suzani Wool Rug, Beige/Green, 8'x11' · More Info

Novica Fertile Lands Wool Dhurrie Rug, 4'x6' · More Info

Baluchi Raqeeb Ivory/Rust Rug, 6'1x9'1" · More Info

Casa Overscale Traditional Beige and Orange Rug, 7'10"x10'10" · More Info

Or I might ditch the 3 chairs and keep the 2 reds and then get 2 of any of these (except the blue, which I would only keep if I was keeping the orange-y chair)

Mercana Shirley Gray Seat With Wood Frame Accent Chair 67122 · More Info

Harvey Modern Full Grain Italian Leather Accent Chair, Chocolate Brown · More Info

Nest 34" Fabric Chair, Steel Grey · More Info

Stanley Chair, Dark Gray · More Info

Madison Park Addy Hardwood Chair In Blue Finish FPF18-0472 · More Info

But I would still get a bigger rug to define the space and bring everything into the center and a bigger lamp and figure out what art I wanted over the sofa. It could be something as simple as black and white line drawings framed in black.

In general I think the sofa is too close to the wall and everything should come forward a bit to ”float” the conversation area more in space. Instead of a corner table + lamp, might be nice to try a floor lamp that arcs into the space.

@Tara Thank you, you are correct, however, I do need the seating.

@User A new area rug is the plan, thank you, i also love your other chair ideas. The big cream chair needs recovering, its 20 yrs old but excellent quality.

I really like your assortment of chairs. I am not really clear on which ones you are planning to keep; but I would definitely keep the sofa, the two red chairs, and I love the orange printed barrel chair; so I would for sure keep that one, too . And I’d maybe bring in one barrel chair like this:

If the dimensions are good, this might be a nice choice. Complements printed barrel chair and is a nod to sofa.

Or, I also really love this one, in faux leather.

So many ways you can go.

You have beautiful pieces, such nice taste. And so much fun!

My only problem with the big cream chair is that it seems too big for this arrangement. But definitely worth recovering for another location. I like that you have arranged a conversation area that is not textbook lined up either facing the fireplace or facing the window but instead is just obviously a welcoming space for people to enjoy. All the seating looks comfortable and not predictable — like each has a bit of history — so it is nice to have that instead of the same stuff everybody else is buying off the shelf.

But I don’t think you should feel very constrained about what new chair you bring in except that it should have some personality like your other seating.

Here are a few that I think would work and add something extra.

Modern Contemporary Urban Design Living Lounge Room Armchair, Beige, Fabric · More Info

Eiffel Dowel Leg Fabric Patchwork Shell With Arms Dining Chair Designer Multi · More Info

Anya Boho Chic Wingback Accent Arm Chair, Floral & Leopard, Satin Teal & Purple Velvet · More Info

Something else that might work for your space is to take the 2 red chairs and place them directly facing the sofa, side by side with no table in between, and then get 2 fairly compact swivel chairs for either side of the coffee table. With swivels, people would have the option of looking out the window or enjoying the fireplace

Soma Velvet Swivel Armchair, Gray · More Info

Thank you for all the wonderful suggestions. I added more pics of the area, which is opem concept.

@freedomplace1, thank you for the complement, the barrel chair is 60.$ find at Restore, which I bought with intent to recover it. Might change my mind, however.

@ital, the big cream chair is sooo comfy, but you are correct it is rather big.

@ashtonchic, love the suggestions, especially the cream chair.

@decoenthusiaste, the current rug is a hand me down, temporary find. Next up a larger one as per your suggestion.