Help! Leveling subfloor for LVP install

2 years ago

We are creating an in-law suite in our basement and ripped out all the carpet. The in-law kitchen cabinets have been installed. I purchased 1500 sq feet of Provenza LVP in sweet talker which was supposed to be installed this past Monday. After hemming and hawing for an hour, the flooring installer told me that the basement concrete slab is not level enough to do the LVP install. Initially they said they could easily level a couple areas. They've since backed off and told me to get a concrete company to do it. We had someone out and they've quoted me $3k to apply self-leveling concrete to the areas, nearly doubling our labor cost on flooring. The concrete guy says it still won't be perfectly level. Currently, or slab a couple drops of up to 1/2 inch, most are < 1/4".

Is this step necessary? Or even worth it?

Has anyone had to apply self-leveling concrete prior to laying LVP?

My big concern is we are going to shell out another $3k for something that won't make much of a difference. If I hadn't already spent a small fortune on LVP (which i can't send back), I'd be thinking about tile and carpet at this point. We picked LVP because I thought it would be the best option with a slab.

Would love advice from someone who's been through a similar scenario. Thanks!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

Valinta
2 years ago
This does not address your question, but I am posing another - Does the basement have ground level access for an inlaw suite so there is egress and typical stairs are not necessary? I am asking from perspective of already dealing with aging relatives.
Melissa R
2 years ago
last modified: 2 years ago
you could try and DIY it. You can buy bags of self-leveler, mix to the consistency of melted ice cream, and pour. It finds it's own level. My hubs and I did it in our 1800sf house. You probably wouldn't have to do the whole floor just the really bad areas

Have your floor guy mark his areas of concern for you. If he won't, it's easy enough to do with a long level. Just run it along the floor, find the dips, outline with spray paint, mix, and pour.

Custom Building Products LevelQuik RS 50 lbs. Self-Leveling Underlayment-LQ50 - The Home Depot

You could also sell your flooring to someone and get carpet.

Or, try and contact the manufacturer and ask how much flex is in their flooring.
Related Discussions
Floating floor installation over tongue and groove subfloor help
Q
Comments (3)
A cementious floor filler made for the purpose is what you want to use. These are portland cement based products and are user friendly. They contain binders to help the product adhere to the substrate, so usually no primer is needed to install them. PlaniPatch by Mapei is a good choice and there are others made by Ardex, Laticrete and many more. These are essentially like self leveling underlayments, but they won't flow and level on their own. You need to mix them with water at the prescribed rate (drill with mixing paddle) and then place the product by working it with trowels and a straight edge board to screed the product where you want it to fill in the depressions. You don't have to complete the 'lift' in one application...these products usually stick to themselves very well, so you can build up and screed the product until you get it flat with the surrounding areas. By screeding I mean what you see concrete people do when they place a load of concrete and then work it with straight edges and trowels to get it to the desired level. The 48" spans worry me a bit, but as long as you don't have a lot of flex and bounce, it should work. Some floor people fill depressions with almost anything they can get their hands on...roofing felt, sheet flooring, almost any mass you can put in there to get the area flat. I don't do that, but I know others do. And I once filled in depressions in a concrete floor with cleaned and dry play sand, although I would not recommend that for the novice...and most manufacturers would not approve of that method (very difficult to get the sand to stay where you place it). That's all I have time for right now.
...See More
Subfloor & Underlay for Luxury Vinyl (LVP) on Concrete Basement Floor
Q
Comments (3)
Sorry but vinyl doesn't like very many of these subfloor gimmicks. The dimpled subfloor underlayments (like platon) isn't allowed under vinyl....you need to add a sheet of plywood over top = loss of ceiling height. DriCore would work except you will lose more than 1/2" because of it. Underpad under vinyl is very rare and very expensive. If you want vinyl in your basement, you are pretty much down to "bare concrete". If you can find some mass loaded vinyl underlay (1.2mm thick) specifically made for (and allowed by the manufacturer of) vinyl floors, then you can have underpad. A high-end laminate with cork underlay and a vapour barrier would be a better option if you want warmth underfoot without the loss of ceiling height.
...See More
Seeking advice regarding laying Smartcore Ultra LVP on not-level floor
Q
Comments (8)
The problem with a slope is it is rarely on the same PLANE. There are several floors that I know of that can handle a slight slope....but they cannot handle humps and bumps AS WELL as a slope. It is intensely rare to find a perfectly FLAT floor with a slope that is PERFECT. What happens? The click edges break with the stress. The little bumps and waves in a floor with a slope can and will stress the click system to the point of breaking. And it will happen over time. As it is walked on, the planks flex. As they flex, they cause stress fractures in the click system. Eventually the edges break and you get a floor that begins to gap. Once it starts, it is almost impossible to stop. While you wait for the vinyl edges to break, you will also get this lovely 'slappy' sound under your feet. The flex in a vinyl floor can be SO big it will visibly move every time you step on it. Again, this is more pronounced on a sloped floor that isn't flat. This is where laminate and vinyl are different. Laminate is very thick and very sturdy. Vinyl is thin and often quite easy to damage without proper training/preparation. In fact, the amount of swearing going on while a vinyl click together floor is being installed is IMPRESSIVE! And I grew up with 'angry Irish'. It takes a lot for me to call swearing "impressive". Vinyl planks are often very thin (4-5mm thick). That means the click egdes are VERY THIN (2mm deep...if you are lucky). That means there isn't much "grab". The tensile strength of the click system is very weak. A shift (when you step on it) up and down and a little side to side will rip the planks apart. Even if the edges remain intact (not broken), they simply do not have the strength to stay locked together. So imagine purchasing 1000sf for $4/sf = $4000. And imagine you then take 3 days to install it. Now imagine it fails within 6 months to 1 year. Will you feel the money you saved on the cost of subfloor prep ($2 - $4/sf) was worth it? Once you fix the basement subfloor (one time cost of $2-$4/sf depending on how bad it is) you can have ANY floor you want in there. You never have to fight with it again. I know that's not what you wanted to hear. Anytime there is a sloped floor (those basement drains are fun aren't they?), it is always best to remedy them before putting in flooring. The only floors that are OK with this type of floor = carpet and sheet vinyl/lino. Every other floor needs that basement slab to be fixed.
...See More
Subfloor question for SuperCore LVP...please help
Q
Comments (5)
What SJM said you have to prep the floor properly. If you look at DriCore installation specs, it tells you that "Any dips or low spots in the concrete surface greater than 1/4" should be troweled level with a Portland cement compound or leveled with a self-leveling compound to ensure an accurate installation." The same goes for LVP flooring "A. The surface of the subfloor must be flat. The flatness requirement is defined as follows: the maximum difference between two high points and the intermediate low point is 1/4" in a 10' radius. Surface flatness must also not vary more than 1/16" when measured with a 3' straight edge. Additionally, the subfloor must not slope more than 1" in 6'. B. High areas can be sanded, ground down, or floated over with an approved self-leveling compound. Fill excessive voids or low areas using a non-gypsum, cementitious-based leveling compound. Allow the leveling compound to dry thoroughly before beginning the LifeProof Vinyl Plank installation. Follow the manufacturer’s instructions to be sure it is appropriate for the application. Good luck
...See More
PRO
HALLETT & Co.
2 years ago
Sounds like a perfectly reasonable amount based on how out of level your slab is. Read the spec on your floors, they require the slab to be within certain tolerances.
millworkman
2 years ago
"Read the spec on your floors, they require the slab to be within certain tolerances."

Or when it the click locks break, the floor moves and the boards start to pop up there is no warranty.
SJ McCarthy
2 years ago
I'm going to say that you have ONE HECK of a decent flooring installer working for you!!!! No. I'm not kidding. I would say 95% - 99% of the time a flooring 'dude' (or some guy who swings a hammer who told you s/he could install flooring) just throws it down and runs for the hills.

You have an honest person working for you. The quote he gave included a LITTLE bit of levelling. Your concrete is NOT good enough to have 'spot' patching done.

I've always suggested to my customers to budget $2 - $5/sf for CONCRETE slabs. Your quote for concrete work = $2/sf. That's RIGHT ON TARGET.

Good to know that you have TWO honest performers here. Yes, concrete is a B!TCH to deal with. Yes vinyl needs FLAT...but then again so does laminate, hardwood, tile, etc. The ONLY things that do NOT need flat = sheet vinyl, sheet linoleum and carpet. Yep. The things that role out and that can wrap around a telephone pole.

So...you have THOUSANDS of dollars worth of flooring (I'm guessing around $4500 - $6000). That is MORE expensive to waste than it is to install. Right now you have a wonky concrete subfloor. That is normal and to be expected in a basement.

You will only pay for this leveling ONCE. After that you will have a great surface to work with for the next 60 years. The concrete slab guys will get you a much better surface. The INSTALLER will then do the 'few' patches he has quoted for you. The two put together will create the 'acceptable surface' you need to put down ANYTHING OTHER THAN carpet.
PRO
Craftsman Creations
2 years ago
That needs grinding of the high dpots first. Then filling the low spots. Its cheaper to fo it right from the beginning rather than have all the flooring fail and then have to level, and buy new flooring too.
PRO
G & S Floor Service
2 years ago
Follow manufacturer's guidelines as suggested.

Help! Leveling subfloor for LVP install

Comments (7)

Valinta

Melissa R

Related Discussions

HALLETT & Co.

millworkman

SJ McCarthy

Craftsman Creations

G & S Floor Service

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US