These are pendleton wool, what do you think, I don't think they are so yellow either.

Somthing substantial in tone and fabric to work with the hair calf rug, the rugged dining table and the "a bit too pale for the room, wing chairs.

https://www.etsy.com/listing/937612154/set-of-2-kilim-pattern-woven-fabric?ga_order=most_relevant&ga_search_type=all&ga_view_type=gallery&ga_search_query=kilim+throw+pillows&ref=sr_gallery-1-18&organic_search_click=1

Judianna those are similar to what I currently have!

'nother option

I love your room!

I love your room too. Did you previously have 24” pillows on these chairs? Just thinking that seems big?

I like the black in the pillows with your dining chairs. I also think a 20" square would be a better size for your chairs. Maybe a black/beige windowpane check? Those can be found pretty easily online I think. Wonderful room!

This is what I currently have and the pillows are down squashy. Unfortunately they are getting very faded as the low e windows are ineffective.

I still like the plaid, I think they would be a nice look for Nov-Feb but I get it, they don't "go" that well.

I know I don't follow decorating rules much which is why I love input from all of you here. Trying to avoid major mistakes, and I've made some!

I'm fond of kidney pillows for chairs like that. You get the splash of color but can comfortably sit in the chair with the pillow.

You really have a blank slate. I'd be looking for a traditional fabric that is multicolor. That is wide open; do you have a favorite look or favorite room?

I'd also consider a throw on one chair.

Lastly, as someone with chairs in my DR, I bet they are rarely used. Since there are only 2, you would pretty much only use them if only 2 were dining, but then it's unlikely you'd be in the DR. Sometime we use them if we are entertaining and they are like overflow, but rarely, So I think it's fine to make them large if you like. OTOH I like the lumbar shape.

PS I think Scully and Scully is a good place to look, they have a ton of traditional pillows, in sets. https://www.scullyandscully.com/home-decor/home-decor-accessories/pillows/#

I really love your current pillows.

I also like the idea of a bee pattern for whimsy.

Horchow

This is Sunbrella fabric (you mentioned fading issues):

https://authenteak.com/elaine-smith-22-x-22-honey-bee-sunbrella-outdoor-pillow/

https://authenteak.com/elaine-smith-20-x-12-tropical-bee-capri-sunbrella-outdoor-lumbar-pillow/

Not necessarily these, but just the idea. Etsy probably has good selection. Saw these doing a quick search:

Etsy

Etsy

Maybe because they’re used everywhere here (Texas), but to me, cowhides are pretty much neutral in decor, especially the color of yours. I wouldn’t worry at all about ’working’ with it … it’s just not a factor.

Yes, definately a kidney chair for each chair, like 2 katz suggested above.

I really like the pillows you have there already, but not for where you have them. In my opinion, they look huge and out of place. I'd suggest lumbar pillows, as have others. And, I know you didn't ask, so I apologize in advance, but I think that the cushions on your dining chairs are also too large (for my taste, which isn't necessarily yours). Would you consider something smaller?

I put on my body armor before posting here so I can take all comments.

The chairs are not used for dining ever, I have 6 dining room chairs in storage I can pull out when I need them, which is about once or twice a year. I can put 10 around the table.

I often sit in the chairs with coffee with a friend and the pillows are very comfortable.- all down, they flatten to nearly nothing.

However, I am not petite, I'm 5' 10" - down from 6' :-(

I am so grateful for all comments, I love having a different perspective.

Jinx, I LOVE bee things, my fav glasses are La Rochere bee. Have a bunch.

I have different, bigger but similar rug now.

I’ve always been in love with your dining room. :)

(Well, all of your house!)

IMO, pillows would add some visual interest - especially if they're a complimentary color. The room is kind of monochromatic as it is.

Wondering how fancy round pillows might look...

I'll add a throw ( everywhere lol) in the cooler months, it's so hot now.

Considering this, I have loved this pattern since it came out. 22" square

I love those too, but I think you should have pattern.

MTN, I think I agree. Those are not returnable either so I would have to be convinced but I do love the color. I ordered the black plaid ones from Etsy those are returnable but I would like to check them out even if no one else likes them.

I did look on Scully and Scully but didn't see anything large enough.

I really do want a square so that you can see it from the kitchen area, a lumbar size would be lost.

This source makes them in all different sizes: https://dekowepillows.com/collections/new-products

Love your room! What seat cushions do you have on your black chairs? Lumbar pillows would look great on the upholstered chairs, maybe a coordinating/complementary fabric?

Arapaho, the cushions on the black chairs are unused pillows from a sofa that I nap on with dogs so don't need back cushions. The covers are removable so I could plump them up a bit. They're also down so I fluff a lot too. I spend hours at table so they help tremendously.

I don't like cushions that tie.

Found these linen florals before I saw you saying you want squares. Sharing anyway because I think the prints and colors are so pretty...

Of everything I've seen, this is proby my fav visually, although it's too small and too expensive.