skip to main content

Woodworking Design Dilemma Bathrooms

Walnut Vanity - Finishes

Jessica Cardenas

2 years ago

Hello, I am remodeling a bathroom and having a custom vanity made. My carpenter is asking if I want a sealer added (of course I do) but I am hesitant to have him add it or do it myself (meaning my contractor husband).

My husband and I have zero experience working with walnut and we don't want to ruin it. I think it is beautiful as is and I absolutely love seeing the grain and the contrast between the light and darker colors in the walnut. I know that once we add the finish, the wood will darken and I am okay with that but I do tend to favor the light and dark contrast and am not so concerned with with blending the two colors in. I have read a lot of blog posts and watched videos and much of what I read or see talk about blending the sapwood and heartwood whereas, I like the contrast.

Based on my research so far, I am leaning towards using a waterlox but I still have no experience with what brand, how many coats, etc. I called the lumber yard where we purchased the wood and the owner suggested I use a sealer (clear) to protect it and then a satin (clear) finish but didn't specify what brands, sanding in between, etc.

Any help would be greatly appreciated. The simpler the process the better. We'd prefer a matte finish and are going for a more modern/industrial look. The vanity will be used in our bathroom so it needs to be protected from water.

Thank you!

This is my vanity in progress. The last picture is what the person building it offered to put on it.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (13)

suezbell
2 years ago
There are oils intended for boat hulls that might be worth considering. If you decide to take on this project yourself, no matter what you try, do some tests on a part of the unit that will be less visible and let it dry before you decide to do the entire piece.
suezbell
2 years ago
Ask the builder of the unit to show you a scrap piece on which he has put the finishing product he suggests you use.
Related Discussions
Finished Kitchen - Creamy with Walnut
Q
Comments (76)
I love your kitchen! The small prep area behind those really neat barn doors is very interesting. I would think it would be a very practical way to keep your main kitchen looking tidy when a lot of guests are over. The refrigerator doors over by the breakfast area are a cool idea too. The soft warm colors are lovely and will be easy to live with for years. Congratulations on a well thought out gorgeous space! Enjoy!
...See More
Walnut Island top used as cutting board - photos & finish details
Q
Comments (60)
len, you’re welcome. You won’t regret it. I hope you intend to cut right on the island, not just have a beautiful wooden island that you’re paranoid about getting marked up. We passed the 10 year anniversary this past June and while I’ve toyed with sanding it down a bit as mentioned above, I think we’re going to give it a few more years. Of course a few weeks after we hit 10 years we got a really bad stain from where I left the metal disc from a food mill sitting on the counter overnight. I don’t understand why a wet piece of metal leaves a dark black stain in the wood. There’s some sort of reaction between the wood and the metal when it’s wet. It’s not a rust stain. The marks are black. I’m sure it will sand out if I bother but… who cares? It’s a kitchen, not a museum.
...See More
Finished kitchen: Ikea, walnut, marble and glossy white
Q
Comments (77)
Hi cv2014, I still love the look of our Semihandmade walnut, to me it's very warm. We briefly looked into having Semihandmade make panels for the side and the back of the island, but we wanted a more substantial edge and it just seemed like we'd have better luck getting it to all work out if we hired a finish carpenter to do the job. We're very happy with how it turned out. You can go to almost any good lumber store and purchase a full sheet of walnut veneer for not a lot of $$s. Depending on where it's used, it could be ok if it doesn't match perfectly with the Semihandmade walnut. The corner cabinet has a filler piece, I think it was around 4 inches, that gives enough clearance so that the cabinet door can open without worrying about having it hit the door to the right. In my case I think I was also concerned about clearance so it wouldn't hit the oven handle as well. That was solved by making the pull-out next to the over slightly wider than originally planned. These are the older Ikea cabinet style, so I'm not sure if the new style has the same kind of corner cabinet or not. Good luck with your planning!
...See More
How to finish white oak floors with walnut cabinets
Q
Comments (30)
There is only one genuine Black Walnut. Its grown here in the United States. Lots of companies will import lesser quality species from other countries and generically call it "walnut" Sam Gentry cabinets are genuine Black Walnut.
...See More
Jessica Cardenas
Original Author
2 years ago
Great advice. Asking him now!
PRO
Beth H. :
2 years ago
last modified: 2 years ago
exactly. have him do a sample for you.

The sanding sealer is just going to lock up the grain. YOu can still use a top coat on top of that.

I've worked with a lot of walnut and have used a satin and semi gloss finish. looks beautiful with the sealer applied.

satin water base^

semi gloss oil base:

I refinished this walnut mcm piece and used general finishes Urethane
Jessica Cardenas
Original Author
2 years ago
So once he uses the sanding sealer to lock the grain, then I would need to apply a sealer on top of that? Loving the first picture with the Satin water base. I like the less shiny finish. Would the satin water base be okay to use for a bathroom vanity?
PRO
Beth H. :
2 years ago
last modified: 2 years ago
You could use the satin finish in the bottom one. the urethane wipe on. easy to apply w/a rag. (or have him do it)

I used that one on my walnut block bar top. forgot about this one! I just refinished it a few months ago and used that satin one pictured above. wipe on.

(the scratches are from the cats claws!)

I did a few coats, fine sanding in between. (you can wet sand w/a 600 grit)

the Deft sealer is also nice, but it is a water base brush on. I like the GF one because it's easier to apply w/the rag. no brush marks. and oil tends to hold up a bit better.
suezbell
2 years ago
Beth H. : Each of those is beautifully done.
Nancy in Mich
2 years ago
We used Waterlox on ours.
Jessica Cardenas
Original Author
2 years ago
Love! Any particular brand? How many coats and did you sand in between?
Jessica Cardenas
Original Author
2 years ago
Most likely we will do waterlox too! Most of my research has led me in that direction. The only thing is, I would prefer a more matte finish.
kathylawyer
2 years ago
I am using Rubio oil based stains on my Walnut, fairly new brand.....
Nancy in Mich
2 years ago
I do have one spot, smaller than my pinky fingernail, where something “ate” through the Waterlox and I see bare wood. Since we don’t use harsh cleansers, chemicals, or solvents like fingernail polish remover, we don’t know what caused it. I don’t know if any of your other choices would be more resistant. I think I could possibly aim a drip of Waterlox onto my spot and make it look better. I hear it smells pretty bad, though, so I have not tried it.
Jessica Cardenas
Original Author
2 years ago
I am now thinking tung oil. I've reasearched quite extensively and seen a ton of videos. Once I decide what to do, I'll update here as well as post pictures.

Related Stories

BATHROOM MAKEOVERS Room of the Day: Walnut Vanity Warms Up a Master Bathroom

By Becky Harris

Marblelike tile, a floating vanity and a soaking tub elevate the simple design of this white bath

SHOP HOUZZ Up to 65% Off Vanity Lighting by Finish

Choose from chrome, brass, black and other finishes to find just the right vanity light for your space

0

SHOP HOUZZ Trade Pricing: Bestselling Double-Sink Vanities by Finish

Shop these light, dark and wood-toned vanities

0

SHOP HOUZZ Trade Pricing: Bestselling Single-Sink Vanities by Finish

Find the perfect single-sink vanity for your client’s bath or powder room

0

SHOP HOUZZ Up to 75% Off Vanity Lighting and Hardware by Finish

Fixtures in finishes from glam to industrial to unify your bathroom's design

0

SHOP HOUZZ Hardware and Vanity Lighting by Finish

Up to 65% off fixtures in a variety of materials and finishes

0

BATHROOM VANITIES All the Details on 3 Farmhouse-Style Vanities

By Becky Harris

Experts reveal dimensions, finishes, paint colors, hardware, faucets and more

BATHROOM DESIGN Bathroom of the Week: A Stylish Mix of Walnut and White

By Becky Harris

This 60-square-foot room mixes marble veining and warm wood, as well as brushed brass and matte black metal finishes

MATERIALS Woodipedia: Walnut Wows in Traditional and Modern Settings

By Marci Crestani

With its rich color and lustrous polished finish, walnut is a favorite wood for all kinds of millwork

WHITE KITCHENS Walnut Brings Its Natural Beauty to a ‘Clean, Honest’ Kitchen

By Erin Carlyle

A mix of wood, white and other finishes gives this kitchen its inviting, collected feel

Sponsored

More Discussions

Repair Marvin Window Sash

20

stain grade vs finger joint handrails?

2

Wine Cellar Construction

1

how far should you set back bookcases from the mantel wall?

1

General Contractor questions

4