The proportion feels off with the couch, in my opinion. Also Also, it wants something else that richer blue to tie it in.

It repeats the squarish shape of the sofa but it is up on legs, and so it needs to sit entirely on the rug. If you don't need it to swivel, consider removing the mechanism and getting some legs like those on the sofa attached to it. Maybe you have one too many blues in the room. Changing ihe wall color would be easy. Its obvious that the house is from a different era/style period than the furniture. Maybe you should upgrade the lighting fixtures to the same style note as furnishings.

First off, this room is so so pretty!!!
I loveee the paint color and the detail molding.
I love the rug too!!!
....
Here’s what I’d do:
First of all pull out the couch a bit.

I would want the rug out to include the fireplace.

I also think a higher coffee table would bring the room together.

Sorry for rambling. And ignore any comments you don’t want to hear:) I know you didn’t ask....
Anyways. The chair - I like it. I think the style works nicely. But maybe in a cream color? Something lighter? A tad smaller? I’m picturing a canvas material cream chair.

@BlueberryBundtcake - 6a/5b MA I agree that it needs a darker blue to tie to but im also worried that the room is too blue already. I also agree the porportion is off. All my other furniture is so low.

@decoenthusiaste Thanks for the feedback. I think id rather take the chair back than modify it. I prefer to mix styles tbh.

@HU-187528210 not rambling. :) Thank you! Im thinking a white, cream, or shade of brown leather might look better

I want to curl up in that chair with a book & small afgan / blanket. i lthink throw pillows with both blue colors in them on sofa will help. how about a table & light for chair? I’d also like a larger area rug with blues & creams in pattern as predominant colors. The room needs some pattern for texture. I also agree with others that the light fixture (& medallion) should be changed to s style more transitional or not so ornate.

ETA - seems im echoing everything @Sabrina Alfin Interiors said!

The room is lovely, I love the architectural details. ❣️Your decorating style looks a bit “mid century modern”. How about replacing that chair with a few smaller mid century modern style chairs in a cream or light sage.

Your room is lovely by the way.

Good suggestions @maureen. Do you think that orange would go well with the room. Perhaps a little more muted in color? Here is another perspective. I was thinking of hanging gold framed mirrors on each side of sofa and I need a piece above the tv

The chair back is too tall and the overall shape too bulky for the sofa. Whatever chair you next try, put it on the corner of the rug facing toward the sofa, conversationally, not lined up at the end of the coffee table

If the chair is incredibly comfortable and you wish you could keep it, might work better if you had a throw on it, possibly something patterend in gray and orange

Tabitha Throw Blanket, Orange and Blue · More Info

(I happen to like this pillow so just tossing it in here, unrelated to your question)

Pillow Perfect Checker Board Throw Pillow, Gray Orange Cream, 16.5" · More Info

This is one of my favorite chairs if you start looking for a replacement

Rhodes Mid-Century Modern Tufted Arm Chair, Antique Gold · More Info

I want to vote nix on the mirrors for the window wall. You don’t need anything behind the plant, so just leave it be and consider what to put on the other side of the sofa, and over the TV (if anything)

To my eye you’ve got 4 historic eras going on in that room and they can all live together vert happily (and already are, in fact) but for your next choices I think you should pick one, and not add anymore.

You have Italian Renaissance elements. You have checkerboard/chess elements/patterns. You have some modern pieces. You have what appears to be an American West painting.

For the wall at the far end of the sofa, I would pick an artwork that comes from one of those above 4 categories. Which thing that is already in the room do you love most?

For over the TV, I think maybe a longish picture ledge where you can prop up black and white photos (family or otherwise), or some artworks, but nothing flashy (framed and matted in the muted pastels of the walls) and again the content should be an echo of one of the following: Renaissance, checkerboard/chess, modernism or American West.

One more and I’ll be quiet

I agree the chandelier might be too old fashioned although removing or changing the silk hats might be enough of a change. A new contemporary fixture might be perfect, but since I noticed you have artglass in the foyer, I thought this might be appealing in your room, but maybe you don’t want any more grids

Meyda Tiffany 18649 28"W Terra Verde 6 Lt Chandelier · More Info

Oh oh — breaking my promise

I don’t think your mantle needs anything except that copper-colored piece. In fact, looking for new chairs that have a copper tone in some respect would be great

I really like this chair and think it works with the eclectic style of room.

https://franceandson.com/products/dash-chair

Be careful regarding gold framed mirrors; aim for a more modern design so they don’t feel ornate.

Posting for a friend

If you want to continue with emphasizing the live edge coffee table, the painting you have, the wood elements of the media unit, then 2 of these chairs facing the sofa could be nice

New Pacific Direct Florence 20.5" Fabric Accent Chair in Havana Cream/Brown · More Info

( You need to center the rug on the fireplace, pull more of it out from under the sofa)

and a new light fixture, more woody and western

Six Light Rustic Iron/burnished Wood Up Chandelier · More Info

Luxury French Country Corinthian Wood Chandelier, UQL2150, Porto Collection · More Info

4-Light Brushed Nickel and Wood Finish Chandelier With Seedy Glass · More Info

60W Arezzo Wood Chandelier · More Info

I love Design Within Reach furniture. This chair is less bulky but is a full recliner!

I don't mind that the chair back is tall but it's the seat height compared to the sofa that is bothering me. It could be that it is just the photo angle, but I'd want the seat heights to be similar to each other. Good luck with your room it is lovely.

@User Thank you for the suggestions. I moved the rug out a little and it does look better. I can't completely center it as I would need a bigger rug. I really like that throw you posted. I also like the first lighting fixture and chair from your friend. Ultimately I think I really just need to decide on the right color for this chair as it will set the color scheme for the room. I'm thinking I can either go in neutral with a white sand or cream, go with the hints of green from the trim, or lean into the orange/red/brown tones from the wood with a leather, brown, or more pale red/orange chair.

New Pacific Direct Florence 20.5" Fabric Accent Chair in Havana Cream/Brown · More Info

Would you find it appealing if you filled the wall behind the TV, only between the millwork frame, with a mural or a surprising wallpaper?

Mythic Seafoam Floral Wallpaper Bolt · More Info

Luminary Blue Ogee Wallpaper Bolt · More Info

Nara Sage Toile Wallpaper, Green, Bolt · More Info

Chesapeake by Brewster 3118-12603 Birch & Sparrow Pioneer Sage Birch Tree · More Info

"Half Dome" Wall Mural, 53"x38" · More Info

Irises Painted Wall Mural, 80" x 53" · More Info

Since you bought it, make the best of it. Buy a throw same colour as long sofa and hand it over the chair and place the chair on the rug rather than off it.

Hang rather- sorry on iPad so can’t edit for some reason !