either floor works. If you are certain about the raised panel on the perimeter....I'd just say that is quite traditional so I'd pick the right floor in the picture. the grayed out, more rustic looking floor would be a more casual style overall..altho floors recede and you could pull it off esp w slightly rustic hardware..or at least not formal hardware. Just depends on what you want to do with that cabinet ..I do think it is traditional.

I like the stain color and either floor choice, maybe the left the best. why does it have to be LVP?

Not too sure about the ornate panel choice.

I agree that either will work. For me a wood floor whether it is LV or hardwood is a nuetral.

Oops the door panel was just to represent the divinity maple classic finish. The door style is a five piece stacked shaker. (29/18 stack). The only reason for the luxury vinyl plank is the price. We are intending to put it through the house (2400 sq ft). I am open to any other options. Any suggestions would be welcome

Would you mind sharing the type and color of LVP on the right? I'm having a hard time finding a color that matches white cabinets and cherry furniture

Provenza moda living rock candy

2400 sq feet? wow, that's a good amount of flooring.

I did almost 900 sq feet w/french oak flooring.

some of the good quality LVP is just as expensive as doing an engineered hardwood. (the latter being better for resale).

have you looked at engineered or compared prices between the two options?

will you have any spaces that have tile?

I like the wood to the right ...

white shaker cabs? take the floor on the left. Have you seen/walked on large areas of good quality LVP. I think its a wonderful option. Its not the only option . thats a good natural looking piece . You are going to basically have a white kitchen....That floor leaves room for something w backsplash and hardware, in a statement /feature sense.

Any ideas on backsplash and hardware?

Beth H, I love your flooring! Is engineered hardwood good with pets and a good choice with the dry climate of Arizona?

I think the warmth of your island stain goes better with the tone of the floor on the right. Because the counter will not be touching it and will be on the same plane it can go with either floor. The one on the left has more gray tones, cool tones, and IMO doesn't play as well with the island stain. If you prefer a more rustic look maybe look for one without grey.

Both are great combinations! When I try to visualize your kitchen choices I feel with the floor on the right you'll have a warm, rich and luxury kitchen while the left floor will give a more minimalistic, Scandinavian vibe. It's just what you prefer.

Personally, I like the right one best.

The countertop and flooring on the left are cool tones. Island stain and flooring on the right look warm. I would choose everything in the same range rather than a mix.

Kathy, I love my engineered floors. I do have have cats who run across it w/their claws, repeatedly barf (I swear, they vomit every day!) , I've spilled large amounts of water, even had paint splatters while painting, and it all comes up without any issues. no scratches or damage. It was a glue down on a cement slab. It's easy to clean , although it's my least favorite chore. vacuuming is a breeze.

Im in so cal and we get very dry, arid weather like you do. No issues with it. Before that flooring I had an engineered mahogany that we lived w/for 15 years. no issue w/that one either.

So, go to a flooring store and look around at what's avail. They have some beautiful French Oak style engineered choices on the market now. (gorgeous herringbone layouts too. I did a herringbone in acacia in my bedroom w/solid hardwood, and wished they'd have had the french oak selections at that time)

they didn't have this style avail at the time I did my room.

You could opt to do the LVP upstairs, or in some selective rooms if you like.

I just think the engineered flooring looks better, lasts longer and is more valuable when it comes time to sell.

My floors were Calif. Classics, Mediterranean collection

but Provenza has some very similar selections

depending on the style of the home, you could do a porcelain tile (they do have the wood-look tiles, but you'd have to choose carefully. some are too fake looking)

This one is actually a laminate. looks good in the pics, don't know what it's like in person. You can see how they have it paired w/the regular flooring

https://www.mannington.com/Residential/Laminate/Restoration-Collection/Palace-Chevron/28400C

maybe you want porcelain tile in the laundry or mudroom areas,,,baths, entryway,,etc.

this is a nice porcelain tile that could be used anywhere in the house. 24x24 size, super thin grout lines, easy care. (Cavatina Corda at Tilebar)

The tiles have the benefit of staying cool in the summertime.

Thanks for your comments Beth. I am going to look into the french oak hardwood option this week. Your thoughts are truly appreciated.

Beth, what do you think about these hardwoods? The one on the right is Grand Pacific morning break (a white oak) and the one on the left is California classic Mediterranean French oak called Cannes.

those are both nice! which color is that on the Mediterranean? I have Granville in the living area, and another color (starts w/an F) on my bathroom ceiling!

It’s called Cannes. Which one do you think would work better with my cabinets and island choices.

they're both very close.

can you take a pic w/your choices?

You have white and soft grays, so either one is going to work.

what about the rest of your furniture? These choices appear to be a tad warmer, unless it's the yellow light in the photo

which one do you like?

both of these are Cannes

Kerrew! this is the one I have in my bathroom.

this is the granville. it's a tad less yellow

did you see the sample of this one too? or are you drawn to the warmer, darker tones in Cannes?

If you like something darker w/no yellow, try this one:

that collection has about 15 diff shades.

The one on the left is my choice. well done it will all be beautiful together. Can't wait to see it!

I do like Rochelle, Granville and Cannes. I am going to try to get a sample of both Granville and Rochelle. I didn’t see either one of those today at my flooring place. I am re doing the whole home so the furniture is going away. They are warmer in tone

The one flooring on the right has more variation in the boards than the Mediterranean cc floor which I am not too sure about. I don’t like when you see large differences between the floor boards as a whole. The Mediterranean one has less variation

Beth, you are right. Nothing compares to engineered hardwood.

kathy, this is the Kerrew I mentioned in my bathroom. There is a lot of variation, not in color, but in the wood itself

That's just how the Mediterranean collection is

Back to the Granville. Honestly, depending on lighting w/these photos, it looks diff.

This is natural light in this shot w/no other lighting.

This is a good representation of how it really looks.

I picked this one over the Kerrew because it's more neutral toned.

At my flooring place, the Mediterranean collection is on the far right. you can see some of the other colors.

I love my floors. every day I walk on them it just makes me happy.

I love Kerrew also. I want to see that one too

From left to right, Rochelle , Kerrew and Granville from the Mediterranean collection California classics with the morning light shining though the living room. I am lost now. I love them all (leaning towards Granville). Any thoughts?

lol. well you know how I feel about Granville!

Rochelle is a tad darker, kerrew slightly warmer toned. They all look very similar and will all look nice in your home. (BTW, what is the sq ft price they quoted you?)

Hi beth.
What colour is your wall paint.. and what colour is your kitchen cabinet.
Thanks..

Cabs are Simply White, and that back corner wall is BM Light Pewter