Houzz Logo Print

Help me choose between Fantasy Brown Marble and Astoria Granite!

Wendy A
last year
last modified: last year

I've fallen hard for Fantasy Brown! I know it is in the marble family and therefore requires more care so I've been searching for granite that gives me the same feeling as FB. The only one that I've liked in pictures is Astoria granite. I've seen 2 FB slabs in person but I haven't seen Astoria yet. I'm also considering leathered for FB but I haven't felt it yet.

Here are live inventory pics and one that I took today with my cabinet door sample.

Which would you choose? Should I go with the swirly or lined Fantasy Brown? Polished or Leathered?

New Kitchen Details:

  • White Cabinets (see pic #6 for cabinet door sample)
  • Oak wood floors (haven't picked the stain color yet)
  • Stainless steel appliances
  • I prefer more brown/beige than grays in the stone

Comments (9)

Sport Court of Washington, DC
Average rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars18 Reviews
Award-Winning Sport Court Specialist, Serving Virginia for 30+ Years