Sorry but neither.

The round one seems like a better scale, but the finish is not right for the room.

The rectangular one is over scaled and too orange.

The round one looks better in scale, for sure. Its finish looks a tad too pale on my monitor but it might hit the right note in real life. It's a quibble either way (but I'm no pro). I think your place looks fabulous in that first pic. Trust your eye!

I need to see the whole space but at first glance not the rectangle

I like the round one in your space-----and I love your rug.

Round but a different colour

The round one for sure!

Round is much better, not 100% on the color of it, but it's hard to tell on a monitor. I have things in my house that in pictures don't look quite right but look good in person.

Could you give me info on your beautiful rug. I am looking for something similar?

The round one.

The round one looks great and its color is just fine. I think that was a very good choice.

What IdaClaire said. Love the way you've styled it.

Lovely room. That orange wood on the second coffee table is not good.

Round is much better, looks fine in the room.

Team Round!

I like the round and the color! Keep it! Big no to the orange thing

I love the round table there, it fits so nice into your room. I think the pale wood on the blue rug is really nice and goes well with the white tv console. The color looks modern and fresh.
This is why I am genuinely perplexed why some commenters said the color was wrong. How is it wrong? What are they seeing in the room that I'm not seeing/noticing? Hopefully someone will come along and improve my eye for this and let me know their thoughts on how it's wrong!

Round and agree with Amy Lynn. I like the pale wood.

I vote the round. I like how the lightness of the finish looks with the wood ceiling and other wood features. Very pretty.

(ETA: I like the other table a lot, it’s very cool, just not for this room.)

"This is why I am genuinely perplexed why some commenters said the color was wrong. How is it wrong? What are they seeing in the room that I'm not seeing/noticing? Hopefully someone will come along and improve my eye for this and let me know their thoughts on how it's wrong!"

Amy Lynn, I'm among those who thought the round table's colour wasn't "the best". "Wrong" is too strong a word for me though - as I said in my comment, it's a matter of what I'm seeing on my monitor. When I saw the pic, the round table stuck out for me and I think it's because its colour doesn't relate to anything else I see in the picture. On my monitor, the round table has a pale pink tinge which my eye isn't picking up elsewhere in the pic (esp. in the other woods I see). But as I said, it's a quibble and I'm no Pro. Not certain what I'd offer as an alternate either. Wasn't keen on Beverly's suggestions. Maybe simply adding a picture with a frame in a similar finish as the round table on the wall next to the TV? A blue and blush throw pillow on the couch? See what I mean? It's a quibble. :) Not sure "tweaks" are worth the effort.

As for the rectangular table, for me it's the size that doesn't work. The orange wood works for me because orange is the complementary colour to blue and my eye picks up a fair amount of orange in the wood ceiling and floor. And there's a blue and orange pillow on the sofa. But I'm "assessing" all this based on pixels on my monitor. The feel of a room can be so much different in reality!

In both pics (which have different lighting, btw), the room is gorgeous and it's obvious to me the OP has a good eye.

I like the style of the table, all you have to do is add an item to the top of the table that works with the wooden ceiling tone. Here are some ideas, I feel a rectangle tray would look great. https://www.wayfair.com/decor-pillows/sb2/ottoman-coffee-table-wood-decorative-trays-c547730-a73687~271417-a73689~271436.html?refid=GX434403196467.~b&position=&network=g&pcrid=434403196467&device=c&targetid=dsa-303264160494&channel=GoogleIntent&gclid=EAIaIQobChMI_su6rbnG7gIV6MuGCh1DpQBKEAAYASAAEgI31vD_BwE

We all have different tastes and there is no "perfect room" that all will agree upon. And, the quest for perfection in our own homes can be exhausting, sometimes finding something we like is fine enough.

On this board, there's a lot of indecision and I often wish posters would just do something!

Love the round but I'm partial to glass tops as they're airy and allow you to see all colours below.

@tartenmeup thank you for the explanation, I appreciate the response. I can see what you are saying. I now notice that the floor and the ceiling are on the oranger side compared to the table. I still like the color of the table with the other pieces in the room. I like how the coaster holder on the table and the little planter on the console bring in more of the table tone. Speaking from someone who has a very orange red oak floor from the 90s, I have struggled to not have that dictate my other wood tones. I hate the color of my floors and can't wait until the day we can invest in refinishing. Meanwhile, I block them out as much as possible, maybe I've extended that to other people's homes! 😀

Amy Lynn, I also have very orange oak floors! From the late 60s in my case. They were refinished by previous owners in the early 2000s and perhaps the wrong finish was applied and yellowed too much? Who knows. Anyway, at this point, after living in the house for over 15 years, I don't care. They've become neutral to me. :P Totally inoffensive. In fact, dare I say I'm almost appreciating the orange tone these days? It's warmth, you know? I no longer consider them "ugly" or allow them boss me around. :D

The round table and its color make me like it even though right now there are few details in the room that exactly color match it. Our homes are not created in a day. Eventually you'll happen upon the perfect "blond" cushion that will happily wave to the table.