I don't have feedback but I love the photo of the round table and chairs. My own opinion is that all the other chairs are too open in the back and legs and all you see are vertical lines and space. The last photo of the round table gives off a more comfortable room.

Thanks for the feedback.I plan on purchasing the round table and I actually love the chairs in the photo with the table, but I have children so I’m try to avoid upholster. Unless, theres some way to protect them from food and drinks.

Did you make a decision on the chairs @Ashton Kellar I'm also considering the westan chairs. I have the toscana extending table in seadrift and kids. The table has been great with kids as it has a rustic finish already.

I’m considering these chairs too, and have tried them out in the store (very comfy), but am concerned that they don’t look they would hold up to a lot of wear and tear as you lean back.

What did you decide on the chairs @Ashton Kellar? I recently ordered Cline dining chairs but they are so uncomfortable I need to return them. I'm now looking at the Shay or Westan dining chairs in black and wondering if they would be more comfortable than the Cline. So hard to order online and then wait forever for them to get here (I waited 3 months for my Clines only to be disappointed :( ; I wish I could see these chairs in person before ordering!