The first one looks too low in the seat and too high in the arms for me. It looks uncomfortable.

I like the 2nd one better. I don't like the style with the arms the same height as the back--either the arms are too high or the back too low for comfort (though they look pretty).

I like the last one :)

If that pic shows its true condition, I would snap it up

Second. looks very real-deal. is more inviting, or seems more inviting on the pics at least. one wants to sit there with a book

Definitely the second one! First choice - new one - has a feminine look to it with its flared arms and dainty legs. The second one looks solid, comfortable & much more inviting to sit in/ on.

Second as seating looks more comfortable and prefer three cushions, bonus being used.

The second one (used one), no contest. It’s perfect for what you described. :)

Check the legs on the last sofa. Left leg looks bent.

I like the last sofa :-)

Last one.

Thank you everyone for your very helpful comments. The second one it is!! This message board has been very helpful. I appreciate all of your design skills.

Glad you settled on the second one; it's absolutely lovely. I encourage you to share photos of the room once complete! Sounds like it's going to be very pretty -- at least if that beautiful sofa is any indication.

Last one.

Third photo.

Cordovan color is preferable to bright red.

When in doubt ask RL 😉

S M, you didn’t ask Houzzers about color - you asked about which of the two red sofas had the better style for an Equestrian - English suggestive theme for your office. You didn’t say your decor would be firmly into that theme. I agreed with all of the other responders on the second sofa over the new one but I didn’t for a moment question your choice of red color. But, I now want to say that do like the red color. I also assume the cheery red color will be the best for all of the other furnishings you have or will acquire for your newly decorated office. I’m sure RL would have agreed it’s a good thing to do things with a flair and a twist on the usual and ordinary!

Second one. 3 cushions.

Not sure if you were going with a traditional room, but thought you might be interested in an updated version, which can still have an equestrian look. Suggest a rich, dark historical paint color (see Newburg green below), a distressed rug, rich wood tones, equestrian related items, and of course a bookcase(s).

Thank you, everyone!! Unfortunately the seller decided not to sell the red sofa we all liked the best. so the search continues. Your help is greatly appreciated!!

That’s a big disappointment! So, Shop on and remain calm! Something else will come up that maybe you’ll like even better!