The warmer color looks nicer. Not a pro :)

I would choose Amazing Gray. It looks great with the flooring and will look better with green than a cooler gray. Amazing gray still looks gray, not beige.

I think you need to go with your instinct and not overthink this. Which color seems more harmonious and appealing to you?

@Carolae, thank you.

My problem is that Amazing Gray looks more harmonious, but less appealing. I think I don't really like it, even though it "fits"

I think the mindful gray is nicer. You’re right, even though it flows the amazing Grey is less appealing to me.

If you don’t really like it, don’t use it! Mindful Gray also looks lovely. I really think either one will work. I was just telling you my preference.

It’s so easy to second guess one’s choices. My flooring is red oak stained with Early American, which many on Houzz would dislike as too orange, and my living room is painted Seattle Gray, which is a cool gray blue that appears lavender at times. I kept looking at the two together, wondering if I made a mistake pairing “cool” walls with “warm” floors, but I really dislike beige paint colors, and I didn’t want white walls! I asked a designer, who said both the floor and walls were neutrals, and looked fine together. Warm toned wood flooring really is neutral.

I would check a sample of any gray you choose in your kitchen, because some grays can appear blue in certain lighting conditions, which you may not like.

My preference would be the mindful gray

I guess that cabinet is actually in your kitchen- I didn’t realize that when I first looked at your photos, whoops

Honestly, I don't think either of them go very well with the floor. But, if you need to go with one of those two, the warmer Amazing Gray looks better - better but not great.

Mindful Gray has my vote.

I prefer mindful grey or even a more greenish grey.

amazing grey looks like it has a warm pinkish tone that doesn't harmonize with the floors, to me.

Another vote for Mindful Gray here. It provides a little more contrast to the flooring, which I like.

Amazing Gray. I'd also encourage you to keep them on opposite sides of the room if you aren't already. Sometimes it's easy to start to turn on one color because you're comparing it to the hue in another when in reality you're only picking one of them so you'll never see it next to the other color to think "That color has more green undertones because it's next to the one with red undertones" or whatever. Better to see how it be just next to things that will stay in the room like the floors and walls.

I like the Mindful Gray, its sharp and clean looking and helps the cabinet "pop" more. That "Amazing" Gray couldn't be more boring, IMO. It makes that door almost disappear.

I vote for Amazing gray, going good with floor and warmer. They are very close, both Amazing Gray and Mindful Gray are a medium light shades of brown.

Amazing gray is much better.

I think either really works and you can't go wrong. Go with your gut feeling; whichever you like just a tiny bit more.

Also, I would really be interested in your process for painting your cabinets as it looks very well done. If you don't mind sharing?

I vote for Mindful Gray.

I too would be interested in your process for painting your cabinets. It looks professional! Did you use a paint sprayer or brush?

To me the contrast with Mindful Gray flatters your floors more.

what color are your walls with the mindful gray?

@Manana what color are your walls?