Ask this question on the New England forum also. Your part of MA has winter moths that can defoliate some kinds of trees more than others. There are a number of folks from zone 5 MA who visit the New England forum regularly and will chip in. I'd include a question about winter moth and other pest susceptibility in your post. There aren't winter moths in my area so I can't help with them, but I know that cherry trees around here are susceptible to a wide variety of pests and tend to be short-lived. There was a similar question there recently that might give you some ideas even though her size range started smaller than yours. You might want to consider whether you will want a mix of trees which will give you a longer period of interest and some protection from losing your entire shelter belt if there are disease or insect issues vs. having a more uniform look to your row of trees. You are making a good choice not to look at callery pears. They don't do well with the wet snows that often happen in New England. This is from last fall's Thanksgiving storm and the homeowner had to remove about half of 6 trees.

Callicarpa for the shrub. I would recommend posting id questions on the Name the Plant Forum where there's a wider audience of people specifically interested in identification. https://www.gardenweb.com/discussions/namegal

Thank you both. I plan to start ripping them out tomorrow. Unfortunately, the prior owner of this home, and my neighbors to both sides, seemingly love invasive plants. I have more gout weed coming through my fence that my neighbor has said were placed purposefully. Both neighbors also have English ivy, honeysuckle vines and wild grape vines I’m constantly battling

It’s not Geum allepicum which does not have spikes of multiple flowers. Look at the rows of fruits along the stem. Completely unlike the Geum. It’s an Agrimony. The only question is which species. Did you look at Agrimonias? Here is one species which grows in N America https://www.florafinder.org/Species/Agrimonia_gryposepala.php