Insulation in a new flat ceiling under an old vaulted ceiling?

3 years ago

We are in the middle of an addition on the back of our house and have run into a question about insulation in the existing portion of the house. We currently have a vaulted ceiling covering the front room and the back kitchen (separated by a wall and an opening with the peak of the vault mostly overtop the separating wall). The new addition has 8' walls with a 12" stepped tray ceiling in the middle. To tie all the rooms together, we have furred down and built a flat/stepped tray ceiling below our vault in both the kitchen and the front room. It honestly looks fantastic We are very happy with this change and the way it makes the front room feel more formal/intimate, and combines the new kitchen with the new living room into an 'open concept' space

The problem comes in what to do about insulation. We left the vaulted ceiling where it was to maintain the insulation value, but after putting up the flat ceiling, I note that there is a lot of heat seemingly trapped between the new flat ceiling and the old vaulted ceiling (a 'dead space'). That dead space is closed in with no venting and I'm wondering if this is going to be a problem?

On one hand, the blown in insulation in the attic should provide the needed R-Value. On the other hand, the 'trapped' heat up there could possibly cause problems with warping the drywall, or even possibly retain moisture that could then become a problem later.

SO - the question is: Can I leave the existing insulation above the vaulted ceiling and close in the new 'dead space' with no worries, or do I need to vent that dead space add insulation? Assuming the first, then we are good to go. Assuming the 2nd, then I'll need to vent that new dead space out into the existing attic by cutting holes through the vault, and call the insulation company to come back and add into that dead space.

Thoughts?

Comments (2)

formulaross20
3 years ago
The dead space either needs to be treated as living space with circulating conditioned air or as an attic space with appropriate attention to air and vapor barriers and insulation. An enclosed dead space that is neither is asking for trouble in the long run.
Bruce in Northern Virginia
3 years ago
Attic insulation usually falls into two categories - (most common) leave as unconditioned space, where the attic is vented outside and insulation is installed in the room ceiling below, or create conditioned space, where the attic vents are sealed, the roof deck is insulated and the room ceiling below usually does not have insulation. In your new attic area it sounds like you have conditioned space.

If you want to leave it as conditioned space, most contractors will recommend venting it to the rest of the house to maintain a moderate level of air flow through the area. This could be something as simple as an HVAC grill in each end of the area to allow air flow, or you could also install a circulating fan.

I have a conditioned attic and I chose to leave it unvented. It is a relatively high volume area (full attic), and during hot weather it seems to stay within about 10 degrees of the temp set in the house. My A/C unit is also located there, so I probably get some residual cooling effect from the duct runs, even though they are insulated.

Bruce
Related Discussions
Curved Vaulted Ceiling - Need Light Ideas
Q
Comments (7)
LED strip lights that come in a roll are typically low voltage DC. Some may not be bright enough to provide sufficient indirect lighting. The more powerful strips will need to dissipate heat through the the PCB they're attached to. That in turn means that the PCB becomes less flexible and potentially more fragile. In addition, you'll need extensive wiring, multiple power supplies and planning - to account for line current loss and voltage drop. All of which will need to meet electrical code. If I were to do it, I'd go with the Philips Powercore lighting system which uses AC power instead and is probably more practical for large scale deployment in homes. Here is a link that might be useful: PowerCore lighting
...See More
insulating vaulted ceiling
Q
Comments (1)
Yes, we have a couple of areas in our current house with vaulted ceilings. One area has a couple of inches of high-R rigid foam under the shingles (they are nailed through it). Another general approach is to put in sleepers on top of your roof decking and put in fiberglass batts and then roof decking on top of that with shingles. That's essentially what we have in the other vaulted ceiling area, although it was built that way, not added on. Neither roof has had any leakage problems in the time that we've lived here (about 15 years now). In another house, we had beautiful low-pitch rough red roof decking vaulted ceiling with the redwood showing on the inside. The house came with roll composition roofing on it, but really needed insulation in the roof. Due to the lower pitch, we had a couple of layers of rigid foam hot-mopped onto the roof decking, and then a tar and gravel roof hot mopped onto the top layer of rigid foam. This worked extremely well, and also did not have any leakage problems. -Roger
...See More
Advice on Replacing Vaulted Ceiling with Flat
Q
Comments (3)
You could leave the drywall, but you should have access to the newly created attic over the kitchen, so at least a hatch or opening in the wall would be necessary. Also don't forget about ventilation of your new attic space! In that regard, opening more of the drywall would help, especially up high, (assuming adjacent existing attic is properly vented). Otherwise you'll need to add venting to outside.
...See More
New Construction ?$$? Vault vs. Raised ceiling
Q
Comments (22)
I like to give some idea of costs even if it is a guess. We were quoted $1000 a foot a few years ago for ceiling height increases. On a 2000 sqft per floor house. Relatively low cost of building area. Framing is cheap upcharge. Cladding varies - brick more expensive than siding. Drywall and paint aren't much. Windows need to be bigger which is variable based on window quality. Cheap windows might be $50 more each or it might be $200 more each. So the number of windows and quality matter a decent amount. Now - you are talking varying ceiling heights. Ranch? We had it with a 2 story so then we had an extra few steps upstairs. That costs some money but it wasn't bad. HVAC load increases a bit. Insulation costs a bit. Here is the thing - most cheap new construction has high ceilings which shows you it doesn't cost that much. Or people really like it. Take your pick. Personally - in that size room - don't go over 10. 10 feet from 9 everywhere else is a subtle change and may not get really noticed. We had 11 in great room and 10 in others. It was subtle and I doubt people noticed but it gave the room a grander feeling. It was 20x24 or something in that area. This time we are doing a type of vault - flat peaked I would call it. The ceiling is split in 3 equal parts. 2 are sloped and the middle is flat. 13-14 feet at the flat part. Nothing above it. Not seen that often around here which we liked.
...See More

Insulation in a new flat ceiling under an old vaulted ceiling?

Comments (2)

formulaross20

Bruce in Northern Virginia

Related Discussions

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US