I normally lurk once in a great while but thought I'd chime in here. I agree with the others. I like the craftsman style door the best with your house and also think your door hardware and light fixtures are too ornante for craftsman style. We just got the occupancy permit on our house which is also craftsman-inspired. We used a fiberglass craftsman style door from ThermaTru (model CCA230). We plan to use the gel stain on it (once the weather is nicer) so that it looks like wood but it can be painted, too. The door is available without the dentil shelf or with one of two dentil options. You can also get different kinds of glass to go in the 3 windows or keep the plain. The door is my second favorite part of our house and I highly recommend it. It would look great with your house. You can Google the model number and manufacture to find pictures of it. For the lights, we used a very simple jelly jar light by the door and double bullet-style lights for the sitting area of the porch, both with a black finish. I would have loved to use more square craftsman style lights for those areas but we were on a tight budget and figured they'd be easy to change later if we wanted. For the door hardware, we went with a simple lever style with a rectangle backplate and a separate deadbolt, all in a matte black finish.

The yellow is pretty. Another option that works well with the gray and black is a raspberry color like SW Cerise. A dusty plum can be pretty as well. This is SW Plum Dandy.

If you are talking about real wood think about maintenance. We had a stained mahogany door at our previous house. The sun did a number on it and it had to be redone yearly. It was even under a covered porch but the front of the house faced east and the sun still came under the porch and torched half of the door. Went with a painted door in current house and the front faces west and the door still looks good. It is under a porch as well. As beautiful as wood doors are I would not do one again.

Thank you all very much for your input - especially those who went to the effort of making "renderings," how kind of you. Those were very useful, and helped me to realize that black is the right option, given my general risk-adverseness. The shutters and front door will be SW Tricorn Black. I'll post a pic when everything is done. I never even thought of painting the garage doors but you guys are right, I think black would look really good. We're not going to have the painters do it (given they JUST painted them white) but that seems like a job my husband and I can easily tackle ourselves down the line.