Downdraft vent in island or Vent hood in front of window?

3 years ago

I know neither of these is optimal, but it looks like I have two choices as to how to vent my cooktop: I can put the cooktop on my island and use a downdraft vent like Best Cattura or Wolf. Or, I can move the cooktop so that the stove is directly in front of a window and use an island vent above it. Which would you choose? I cook all the time, though I rarely fry and I rarely cook meat or chicken or fish on the stove. I will go with either a Wolf cooktop or if it is in front of the window, a 48 inch Wolf rangetop. My initial plan was to have the cooktop on the island, but then I started reading how deeply Houzzers hate downdrafts....

Featured Answer

chiflipper

3 years ago

Personal experience; natural gas cooktop with non-operable window behind it, tempered glass, pop-up downdraft vent. Weekly window cleaning was easy, the downdraft unit was virtually useless. After one year removed the downdraft and installed "chimney-style" hood. Up and out venting is SO much better...even if installing same looks odd. Function over form.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (10)

chiflipper
3 years ago
Photos please.
bessiegranddaughter thanked chiflipper
delray33483
3 years ago
I don't think a downdraft would have the power for a 30 inch let alone a 48. who is redesigning your kitchen?
bessiegranddaughter thanked delray33483
Related Discussions
Can I route a vent hood through a down-draft vent?
Q
Comments (20)
>>It's interesting that there's crown molding on the columns and a lot of detail on the wall, but no crown in the kitchen. Is there crown molding elsewhere in the house?Oh my, have you hit on a sore subject. Crown molding was only included in the formal areas and master bedroom. They also crowned no sloped ceilings. Adding crown to other areas was $250 per "room". $250 now, not so much. 20yrs ago when we're building a house and running out out money, it was. Crowning just that hallway and the adjoining family room cost $500 because it counted as 2 "rooms" even though it was only as much crown as a bedroom; the exterior wall is sloped so the family room is really only 1/2 crowned (one wall not crowned and open on one side). I didn't crown the kitchen because the only wall that would have received crown is that single wall (because again, the outside wall is sloped), and it would have cost me $250. Don't think so. I did the crown in my office myself (come on -- a box) along with the sloped ceilings in the formal living room. If *I* can do it, why in the heck couldn't a carpenter? New cabinets will go up to the ceiling in the kitchen. They put tile crown where I cared in the master bath when it was remodeled. What I should have done was made them crown the hallway to the bedrooms just to punish them. It has so many compound angles it would make any carpenter cry.
...See More
Wanting to switch from downdraft of island vent
Q
Comments (13)
Forget flush-mounted Jenn-Airs and telescoping backsplashes. This is the only downdraft exhaust vent that matters: Normally it nestles between your cooktops (or grill or other countertop appliances) smooth and flush with the countertop. But turn on the fan and it raises to well above your cookware, after which you can rotate the head so it's almost directly above the pot or pan you're working with. As such, it doesn't force your cooking fumes to make a U-turn into a Jenn-Air grille, or a rear telescopic downdraft to reach your tall front pots (both will fail at these respective endevours). When you're done using it, turn the knob to the off position and the exhaust head will automatically straighten out and then lower itself until it's flush with the countertop again. It's the Gaggenau VL 051. It has, you'll soon find out, been recently discontinued. Fortunately, there are still several new ones in the pipeline if you look around. It's worth the effort, unless you're ok with a large permanent hood over the island that vents downward, or make a new plenum that runs overhead below the ceiling and outwards and do your best to disguise it (this solution, whilst often not attractive, still works the best. Steam wants to go up, and nothing catches it like a big overhead hood with a strong fan.
...See More
Vent hoods that don't have to be vented outside? do they exist?
Q
Comments (20)
Your situation regarding a vent hood mirrors exactly what we had to deal with. Load bearing wall, finished upstairs bathroom, all the plumbing for the bathroom was exactly where we thought we could run the duct work for the vent hood and 8' ceilings. What we did was run 3X10 duct work above the 36" cabinets, vented horizontally to the outside and then covered up the duct work with moldings. We did have to drop the vent hood from 30" above the stove to 27". I was worried about having the vent hood 27" above the stove, but we were in the parameters of what the installation instructions required. The only thing I would have changed was to have a 9" vent hood instead of an 18" vent hood, then I could have had the vent hood 30" above the range, but you know what, it works like a champ. My vent hood is extremely quiet on low and medium low, but does get louder on med high and high. Whatever you choose to do, good luck. I always tell my DH, if they can put a man on the moon, then something is always doable, with some thought, and a woman!!!! Here is a picture of our install. Here is a picture of the finished product.
...See More
Recessed Ceiling Mounted Vent or Downdraft Vent?
Q
Comments (10)
We have an induction with the tallest downdraft we could find. It works great on the back burners so if you know you're using a downdraft, maybe choose your cooktop while thinking through how you will use it. For example, we do little sauteeing but tend to use a larger pan when we do, and that hob is at the front in ours, which is not ideal. We also have large windows that we can crack even in winter but they won't disperse grease. (I also chose sub-optimal venting so that I could face where I wanted while I was at the stove. I have never accepted the 70% prep time versus 30% stove time statistic; but whatever percentage of my time that I'm actually standing at the stove, I don't want to face our wall.) My understanding of ceiling vents is that they're not much better than downdraft but it's been awhile since I researched. I hear good things about the Cattura Best downdraft but it wasn't available when we were renovating.
...See More
susan49417
3 years ago
Wow, tough call. I absolutely hate cook tops in the island but in front of a window....what a mess!
bessiegranddaughter thanked susan49417
PRO
Sabrina Alfin Interiors
3 years ago
You can only put a cooktop in front of a window if that window is not operable. It's a fire hazard and will not meet code in most places. I've done pop-up downdraft vents in an island before. It works fine as long as you're not doing a ton of frying. Wolf and Thermador both make good options.
bessiegranddaughter thanked Sabrina Alfin Interiors
calidesign
3 years ago
last modified: 3 years ago
I had a gas stovetop with a downdraft on as island, and I thought it was great. My island was large enough to still have a wide area behind the stove for countertop use. I liked that the vent was unnoticeable most of the time with a clear view outdoors. I cooked dinner almost daily, and it worked perfectly fine for the infrequent times I needed the vent. I also had a large window and French doors that were often open nearby. I think a a lot has to do with your particular space, and what types of things you cook. Mine was a downdraft for 4 large burners plus a center griddle.
suezbell
3 years ago
No stove or vent by the window. A sink should be by the window.
bessiegranddaughter thanked suezbell
suezbell
3 years ago
Photos and floor plan (to scale on graph paper) would get you more help.
bessiegranddaughter thanked suezbell
live_wire_oak
3 years ago
last modified: 3 years ago
Get a better Kitchen Designer. If you can afford the too large for a normal suburban kitchen 48” range, you can afford the better kitchen that surrounds it. Don’t shove something like that into an awkward bad layout. Which any layout like you’ve proposed IS. It’s bad. Do better. Hire a real Kitchen Designer to start.
bessiegranddaughter thanked live_wire_oak
eandhl2
3 years ago
Years ago I had a JenAir range. The downdraft didn't do much. They we did a tall telescope downdraft, big improvement. Now I have an over the range hood bigger improvement.
bessiegranddaughter thanked eandhl2

Downdraft vent in island or Vent hood in front of window?

chiflipper

Comments (10)

chiflipper

delray33483

Related Discussions

susan49417

Sabrina Alfin Interiors

calidesign

suezbell

suezbell

live_wire_oak

eandhl2

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US