We went through the same turmoil trying to make the trim decision. Our cabs are SW paint matched to BM White Dove which is similar to Alabaster. We are bright white gloss trim people. We painted scrap trim with white and some with White Dove in all the sheen options available (could have had a whole room painted for the cost of paint we bought to make this decision). Cabinets are satin sheen White Dove. In the end we went with Oil based semigloss White Dove trim for all crown/baseboards, and casing for doors and windows. We even went with White Dove ceiling paint. We like how it turned out. The white made our cabinets look yellowish or grayish depending on the lighting. For our White Dove choice, I just like how it all flows together. The different sheens provide the contrast for me. Good luck! Won't you be glad when all this is done? Remodel/new build decisions are not for the faint at heart!

Hey thanks for responding! I guess I’m also concerned about a pure white colored trim making the AW look more yellow. Was thinking about trying something in between the AW and pure white window. Anyone ever use Snowbound? It’s a little whiter than AW.

This is the combo I have thru out my house - Alabaster walls and Extra White trim. I love it in every room.

Hello, we moved into our newly constructed house a few months ago. The walls and trim are in different sheens of SW Alabaster. The ceiling is a mix of Alabaster and regular white ceiling paint.