Once the shutters are down and the door is installed, it will look a lot different. I would paint the fascia a dark color to emphasis the horizontal line.

My laptop does weird things to colors, so I can't really tell what color your house is. Maybe my eyes aren't much better. I like a sage green house, and there are so many greens that fit that description. With that you can can have white trim or off white trim. Is that cream or ecru or whatever you call that. (Clearly I am not one of those gals that agonize over the 50 different shades of white, I can't even discern the diff between 'em. When I want white, I like the primer's white white! There are some advantages of age :) As for a door color, you can choose a lighter tint of the sage or a burgundy or lipstick-y pinky-wine or even a pumpkin or a teal. I love a dark glossy green door.

Thanks very much! I accidentally included pictures that showed the front of the house before we replaced the kitchen window and added a window to the left of the front door. The quick background is we renovated the kitchen during quarantine (because that is a fun project to take on with working remotely full time in IT and having kids at home 24/7 :)) and as part of that project we replaced the double casement kitchen window with one that has a larger, fixed center flanked by casement windows on each side. We took the old kitchen window and added it to the bedroom that is to the left of the front door. Previously, there was no window on that wall. This seemed like a no brainer at the time because the wall to the left of the door was begging for a window. We also ended up adding a 4 ft. by 5 ft. double casement window to a wall in the master bedroom that looks out onto the backyard. Against my better judgement I ordered the same window for a smaller bedroom that has the same orientation to the backyard as the master bedroom. My hesitation in ordering it was that this bedroom is smaller and has french doors that open onto our back patio, and I suspected the window was going to be too large for the room. Once it arrived, it was clear that I had made a mistake. However, I had an aha moment when I realized it would be perfect in the front bedroom (to the left of the front door). If you are reading along at home and shaking your head, I UNDERSTAND! SO! The window by the front door will be replaced with the new window. May I claim quarantine craziness?! I swear I'm usually much better at executing on projects.

The white window issue is a pet peace for me. Why the window makers charge so much more for colors drives me crazy. But thankfully the rest of the world can hack it. Still, I like certain colors of siding with white windows… like white. Nothing wrong with white and stone. A near white, as also was suggested ("warm white or taupe") may work well too. How close are you to replacing the windows? Then you can get the colors you really want for both windows and siding. While you are at it, don't forget about insulation. And yes, plan for the roof color. I know it sounds like I am turning a minor thing into a major one. And you can ignore me comply. I've experienced the price approach only to have the roofers damage the window screens and not want to replace them. I had much better luck with a contractor re-skinning the entire exterior. Any damage obviously was on him. Just a thought if you can afford it. Understand if it's not for you...