SHOP PRODUCTS
Houzz Logo Print
ophoenix

How old is your oldest cookbook? Still using it?

ophoenix
4 years ago

I decided to make a pecan pie for dinner and went to my old and trusty Better Homes and Gardens New Cook Book, it is the one with the red and white checkered cover. I have many cook books and a 3 inch binder - held together with duct tape - chock full of printed recipes from the internet and yet went to this old one for the recipe. Made me wonder how old it is? Looked - through all the grunge - and it was copyrighted as a First Edition, 1953! How old is your oldest?

Pecan pie looks delicious and we will eat it in about one hour. I made the same recipe for Thanksgiving and it was a winner. Tonight is the first night of Hanukkah, so we will have latkes and pecan pie! works for the guys at my house. Happy Holidays to all.

Comments (42)

  • functionthenlook
    4 years ago

    I have a cook book that doesn't use oven temps. It just has low to high fire. I don't remember the date, if it had one, and it is packed away for safe keeping. It is a wild read. Not only does it have recipes, but everyday help for a housewife. How to make beds from straw or feathers. To chew on a burnt broom handle to cure bad breath. An onion in a bowl will rid a room of all germs.


    I have one of those Better Homes and Garden red and white checked, but mine says De Luxe edition. The last date in the book is 1946.

    ophoenix thanked functionthenlook
  • hallngarden
    4 years ago

    I have Mothers first cook book. It was dated 1940. I didn't climb up to my cabinet to check the name. You can tell it was used daily.

    ophoenix thanked hallngarden
  • Related Discussions

    How old is your oldest Austin?

    Q

    Comments (8)
    Graham Thomas is at least 16. It's withstood my son falling into the middle of it when both he and the plant were young (I was more worried about the rose than the little boy, he still reminds me), and being dug up and kept in a pot for a year during my remodel. It grows on an east wall, and I wonder if it would do better with more sun. Very little rebloom - very long, gangly growth - have learned to wrap it around a pillar (very carefully, since its canes break very easily) and keep it under control. Every year I think about replacing it with something that blooms better, but have to admit when it's covered in yellow, cup-shaped flowers, it's glorious. The Prince and Fair Bianca are both a couple of years younger. They withstood the dug-up-in-a-pot treatment, too, and look wonderful. The Prince gets a lot of criticism from others, but not from me - it's a nice, upright, medium-sized plant with lots of crimson-purple fragrant flowers - it's on its third bloom cycle already this year, and is covered with blossom. Anita
    ...See More

    What's the Oldest Kitchen Utensile in Your Kitchen?

    Q

    Comments (48)
    Hmm, I am not "first owner" of anything too old. A French Press I've had since about 1980, is the oldest thing I suppose. As far as "previously owned" stuff, I use a slicer that my father-in-law used when he was a butcher shortly after WW2. It is about 18" long, slim flexible carbon steel, gets very sharp, I think of him when I take it out.
    ...See More

    Old cookbook ... unique cookbooks ...

    Q

    Comments (25)
    I have a copy of, "the NEW Fannie Farmer-Boston Cooking-School COOK BOOK", 1953. My father, in his retirement, took on the care of several Summer homes in Southern Maine. He would check on them during the winter, board up windows against storms, uncover rose gardens when the time was right, deal with emergencies...that kind of thing. During the Summer, when people were in residence, he was sort of a general, all around handyman. His largest client was old money...there was a beach named after the family, a road named after the family, and a huge home, loaded with antiques that had been the original furnishings. An elderly Black woman came up every summer from South Carolina to be their cook for the season. Little bittie thing, set in her ways and stubborn as heck, but since she'd been cooking for the family for decades, she knew what they liked and how to manage them. I had been separated from my father at age 5, and when I found him again in my early 30's, I went out to stay with him and my stepmother for a year to get to know them. He took me down to meet Marguerite. She was a kick, and we got along...several years later, when she knew that she wouldn't be able to make it up again the next season (or ever), she gave my father her Fannie Farmer for me. It still has a bunch of book marks in it, some with shopping lists, some with her name, some with cryptic notes I can't decipher, all in the same, slanted hand. I actually use the book quite a bit, but I don't disturb the bookmarks. I sometimes puzzle over the marked pages, wondering which recipe she had marked... I also have my mother's copy of "The Complete American-Jewish Cookbook",1952. It has a separate section of Passover recipes. There are no pork recipes, naturally. Generally, the cookies and bread recipes are good. As for unique...I have an Ethiopian cookbook...the only one I've been able to find. "Exotic Ethiopian Cooking-Society, Culture, Hospitality, & Traditions. I've only made a couple of dishes out of it. I love Ethiopian food, and when I found out how much Nit'ir Qibe (purified herb & spice butter) is used in most of the dishes I love, I realized why I love them. For example, in dishes made from 1 pound of ground beef, it is not unusual that they contain a cup of butter. A typical lentil dish pairs 2 cups of lentils with 2 cups of butter. No wonder I love it!
    ...See More

    What is the oldest item you still have from childhood?

    Q

    Comments (54)
    Have my first bib that was handmade with tatting in 1938. My slip that I wore home from the hospital, first shoes, several items from my school years. One item that is still on display, back in the early fifties glass containers with powder were popular, have one that is amber colored with shape of deer in glass on top. Received this at Christmas at a church party. I can still remember the smell of the powder that came in this container.
    ...See More
  • pudgeder
    4 years ago

    I have my Grandmother's 1st recipe book. It was a gift she received at her bridal shower, in Aug. 1930. It's more of a "scrapbook" for recipes, as there are none printed inside. There are hand written recipes from then (1930) and some newspaper clipped recipes up to the late 1980's.

    Most of the oldest recipes don't have any specific measurements, i.e. "cups, tsps" etc. Most all of them are hand written, and she's credited the recipe to whomever she got it from. There are a few there that are credited to my great-grandmothers! The book is in horrible condition, literally falling to pieces, but it's something I dearly treasure.

    ophoenix thanked pudgeder
  • functionthenlook
    4 years ago

    Curiosity got the better of me. I dug up the old cookbook. Mrs. Owen's cookbook & useful household hints. Date is 1892. The copyright is 1884.

  • PRO
    Anglophilia
    4 years ago

    I have my mother's handwritten cookbook but I transcribed the recipes and put them on my computer - her handwriting was not easy to read and the paper had become very fragile (she died at age 85 in 1993).


    My oldest cookbook is my Joy of Cooking from 1966.

    ophoenix thanked Anglophilia
  • wanda_va
    4 years ago

    My favorite cookbook is my 1953 "Joy of Cooking"...held together with masking tape, with lots of handwritten comments. I inherited it from my aunt (an excellent cook) when she passed away in 1970. When I am gone, it will go to her great-granddaughter.


    ophoenix thanked wanda_va
  • bpath
    4 years ago

    I just sent my grandmother’s Joy of Cooking to one of her other grandchildren. I think it’s from 1947, I’m not sure. But I do know it has a recipe for preparing woodchuck!

    I have my mom’s 1967 Mastering the Art of French Cooking. I gave a current edition to a friend a couple of years ago. My friend was asking me about a recipe in the book, and referenced the page. Mine was on a different page, and titled a tad differently. And, the ingredients and process were different, but the end dish was pretty much the same. We looked at the introductions to our books, and hers explained that the means of creating some ingredients, the type of material used in some tools, and etc, had changed over the decades, and several recipes had been adapted to modern ingredients. For example, cocoa is processed differently now that when the book was written.

    Have you found that you need to make adjustments, when you use the older recipes?

    ophoenix thanked bpath
  • peacockbleau
    4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    For as long as I can remember my mother used a Watkins Cook book copyrighted in 1936. They were sold by the Watkins salesmen who pedaled Watkins products door to door. Price $1.00. The books are hardback orange color. Mother's was well used and falling apart when she died. At a resale shop I was fortunate to find an identical one that is in much better shape. I wonder how that family could/would let it go. Edited to say that I still use the recipe for buterscotch pie.


    ophoenix thanked peacockbleau
  • OklaMoni
    4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago


    I have one soooo old, it has the old style alphabet from Germany. Yes, I still use it now and then.

    It's actually a baking book. I put it in this ring binder about 20 years ago. So far, that's been holding up, even so the plastic has yellowed.

    Marmorkuchen, my favorite as a child, of course, my kids got it often too. :)

    the rest of my books are on two shelves, according on how much I use them, some on the upper, and the rest behind a door at the bottom.


    ophoenix thanked OklaMoni
  • morz8 - Washington Coast
    4 years ago

    The oldest cookbook I have is a 'Searchlight' 1946. I think it was the only cookbook in the house when I was growing up - cooking wasn't one of my mothers strong interests. And the book wasn't all that helpful trying to teach myself to cook - we did have a minimum of kitchen techniques shown us in Jr. Hi. home ec.

    I don't cook from it, there are no old family favs there. It's in a closet with some keepsakes.

    I have dozens of cookbooks though, some I haven't looked at for years. I really should whittle them down, get rid of a few. Too many times, I'd become interested in a chef and buy their book, sit and read it like a novel. Result is I have scads of books with maybe 2 recipes in each I've tried and we've enjoyed.

    ophoenix thanked morz8 - Washington Coast
  • glenda_al
    4 years ago

    Have a 1957 Good Housekeeping cookbook. Worn out from use, no spine, no book cover, pages show worn from use. But I'm discarding, as I know son will not use. Maybe someone will enjoy and use it.

    ophoenix thanked glenda_al
  • Zalco/bring back Sophie!
    4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Mine is pretty unimpressive by these standards, my mother's early 1980s Fannie Farmer, followed by her similar vintage Silver Palate books. Of books I bought myself, it is Julia Child's 1994 The Way to Cook. And yes, I still use the Fannie Farmer, quite a bit.

    ophoenix thanked Zalco/bring back Sophie!
  • Alisande
    4 years ago

    This thread inspired me to look at a couple of bookshelves that haven't gotten my attention in some time. I have the Lily Wallace New American Cook Book (1944), The Scottish Cookery Book (1956), and The United States Regional Cook Book (1947). All belonged to family members.

    ophoenix thanked Alisande
  • lily316
    4 years ago

    I have my mother's which is in a lined notebook and handwritten. I never look at it because we eat simple meals that don't require recipes. I could never in this lifetime ever measure up to her wonderful cooking.

    ophoenix thanked lily316
  • User
    4 years ago

    Since I inherited many old cookbooks from my MIL I haven't a clue which one is the oldest. But she gave me a 1963 edition of Good Housekeeping when we first got married. A very basic and useful one for a young novice.

    ophoenix thanked User
  • arcy_gw
    4 years ago

    My oldest is one I hand wrote. It was a look alike "betty crocker" type binder for recipes that back in the day went on cards. I had graduated from the University preparing to leave for my first School Speech Therapist job 5 hours away from everyone I knew. I spent HOURS copying down my favorite of my mother's recipes. That was looong before computers or printers. I use it weekly and the duct tape job that has been keeping it together needs to be redone!! Now when my girls want those recipes I just take pictures and text them to them!! My handwriting is sooo bad I hope they are retyping them on their computers so when I am gone and the inevitable follow up text/call needs to come 'mom what does that sentence say' they have it!!

    ophoenix thanked arcy_gw
  • Lars
    4 years ago

    The oldest one I have is Das große Taschenbuch vom Kochen by Ludwig Schmidseder, 1964, but I did not get it until 1970, I think. It is paperback, and so it is coming apart, somewhat. After I bought it, I decided that I did not like German food, and so I very seldom use it. The recipes are very short and not very detailed, but there are a lot of them. I have another German cookbook that I got more recently, and I use that one a lot more. Its recipes are very detailed and there are pictures, which is helpful.

    ophoenix thanked Lars
  • Elizabeth
    4 years ago

    My oldest is a Victory cookbook from WWII. I learned to cook from that book as a teen in the 1960's. I thought some of the paragraphs were confusing, talking about shortages of foods etc. I did learn the basics there. I took it with me when I had to settle the family estate.

    I also still have ( and use) the Better Homes and Gardens New Cook Book circa 1965. The cookies and pies are very good. It is odd to see how old and brittle the pages are. Surely, it cannot be that ancient!

    ophoenix thanked Elizabeth
  • gardengal48 (PNW Z8/9)
    4 years ago

    My oldest cookbook is also a plaid BHG I inherited from my mom, dated 1947. She only learned how to cook in her 30's as she grew up and lived in the far east and had servants. It wasn't until she moved here right before the war that she learned how to do anything more than boil water :-)

    It was the only cookbook she ever owned. It is now 2-3 times its normal size as it is stuffed with handwritten recipes and newspaper and magazine clippings she gathered over the years, many from friends. I can always tell the ones she got from any of her bridge groups as they are often written on a bridge score pad !! I seldom use any of the BHG recipes printed in the book but it is a treasure trove of recipes for dishes mom prepared that I grew up with and loved.

    When I downsized and moved, I got rid of a lot of my own cookbooks. No longer had a family I needed to cook for and other than baking, I don't use many recipes. And now with the Internet, you can find any recipe you want online!! I did keep my Joy of Cooking, received as a wedding present in 1980, 2 Silver Palates, a British cookbook (with amazing photos) and a couple of junior league cookbooks gifted to me by my SIL (Pasadena Prefers). And my mom's venerable old BHG :-) I also have a big file folder of recipes I've collected myself over the years, most from family and friends.

    ophoenix thanked gardengal48 (PNW Z8/9)
  • Elizabeth
    4 years ago

    I have taken a page with favorite recipes from my BHG and scanned and printed them for fear of losing the crackling old pages. I think my pages dried out a bit because we had a house fire that did not affect the kitchen but there was heat and smoke throughout.

    ophoenix thanked Elizabeth
  • Lars
    4 years ago

    My Joy of Cooking cookbook is from 1984, and I bought it as a general cookbook. I did find that most of the recipes had too much salt in them, and so I learned to reduce the salt by half in many of them, especially the vegetable recipes.

    I bought Diet For a Small Planet in 1972 and used it for a few years. I also have Cooking with Gourmet Grains from the Orowheat Bakery, 1972, and I used this book extensively when I was a baker at a restaurant in San Francisco in the 1970s. I had to multiply the recipes by six to make large enough quantities for the restaurant.

    ophoenix thanked Lars
  • marilyn_c
    4 years ago

    I have several versions of the Better Homes cookbook, the oldest, a ring binder, I finally had to let go after the flood. I had gotten it at a yard sale, and it originally had belonged to a lady who did a lot of entertaining and she had included many pages where she copied down menus that she had served to guests, with notes, etc. It reminded me of our neighbor, Mrs. Laycock, who had kept a journal of every meal she had served for many years. She had been married to a commander in the Navy and while he was away, she went to cooking school. The food she cooked was very exotic compared to what I was used to. When my parents went away for a trip, I stayed at their house, and while I loved her dearly, I had a very hard time eating her cooking.

    However, my favorite cookbook is a 1952 Quaker cookbook, from the Quaker Yearly Meeting. It belonged to my mother, and growing up, it was the first cookbook I ever used. I loved it. It had my mother's hand written notes, and mine too, added recipes, and splattered with cake batter. I had the cookbook after my mother died, but it disappeared during a time my sister was staying at our place in Liverpool. I paid $55 for one I found on Amazon. Lost it in the flood, and bought another one on Ebay. It is not the same without my mother's notes, but nostalgic to me, just the same. I have a lot of cookbooks....not as many as pre-flood, but a lot. I seldom use them for recipes, however, I just re-bought a Betty Crocker cookbook from 1980 that I liked for cookie recipes, lost it and bought it again.

    There are other cookbooks that I have bought again that were favorites.

    ophoenix thanked marilyn_c
  • Uptown Gal
    4 years ago

    I have an old Better Homes & Gardens Red/white book too...dated 1959..it

    was my Mom's. Not sure when she got it. I also have a paper backed one with some really strange

    recipes...with lots of eggs, milk, and everything fattening recipes. LOL It

    is marked "Best Recipes from the Farms of Michigan". Not sure who had it,

    not sure it is old enough to be my Grandma's, but too old to be my Mom's.

    ophoenix thanked Uptown Gal
  • nickel_kg
    4 years ago

    Oldest I purchased: Doubleday Cookbook, copyright 1975. Bought in 1982 for my first apartment. I liked it because it covered the whole gamut of cooking and baking. I have a dozen pages marked with favorite recipes, and I still consult it periodically when trying new things.

    Oldest by publication date: Anyone Can Bake - Royal Baking Power Co, 1928. My grandparents had this book tucked away in the bottom of their pantry. I don't know where that copy is now, the one I own came from a used book store ten or so years ago. The recipes are still good (Hot Molasses Cake is one of my very favorite desserts, ever). It's fun to see how baking methods have changed over the years.

    ophoenix thanked nickel_kg
  • Lukki Irish
    4 years ago

    My oldest cookbook is the Betty Crocker book my mother gave me when I was in my early 20’s. It replaced the one she’d given me when I was 17 because I lost it along with everything else during a flood we had. I still use it and now that she’s gone I treasure it even more. I’m amazed at some of the posts and how old the books you have are. What treasures.

    ophoenix thanked Lukki Irish
  • socks
    4 years ago

    I have my mother’s cookbook from 1946.

    It has information in the front about how to set and decorate the table for various events, brunches, dinner party etc. placement of the silverware and additional plates. I don’t know why but as a girl I used to enjoy looking at that part of the cookbook.

    ophoenix thanked socks
  • patriciae_gw
    4 years ago

    OklaMoni, DH tells me Fraktur, the printing in your cookbook, was done away with at the beginning of WWll so it predates 1939 but yours looks way older. I looked it up and the first cookbook was published in 1912.

    I have a cookbook from the early 1700's in my Kindle. I will have to look it up. I used to own a very old cook book from that era but it burned with my house. No organization to recipes and no standardized measurements. All teacups and lumps the size of.

    ophoenix thanked patriciae_gw
  • Rudebekia
    4 years ago

    My oldest is The Vegetarian Epicure, from my 1970s-80s vegetarian phase, and I still use some of its recipes. They are all excellent!

    ophoenix thanked Rudebekia
  • sheilajoyce_gw
    4 years ago

    My mother married in 1935 and used only one cookbook- The Settlement Cookbook: The Way to a Man's Heart. I was so surprised to see an early 1940s version on my friend's bookshelf and commented that it was the one my mother had. She gave it to me to take home as she had bought it in a resale shop just because it looked old. That cookbook has wonderful recipes in it. I received the red check cover Betty Crocker cookbook as a gift from my aunt about 1957 since I was now my father's chief cook. When I married in 1965, I bought Fannie Farmer's cookbook and Joy of Cooking.

    ophoenix thanked sheilajoyce_gw
  • Chi
    4 years ago

    My oldest cookbook is called "The Cookie Jar" and my grandma gave it to me when I was a child in 1995. She wrote me a note in it and it's a prized possession! I'll have to ask her to see if she remembers!

    ophoenix thanked Chi
  • ophoenix
    Original Author
    4 years ago

    Thank you everyone for all the loving emails. They have brought me to tears and so many remembrances of cooking and family meals and treats. I found another one that had belonged to my mother from the Sisterhood of a synagogue in Vancouver, BC, The cover is gone, but it has to be from 1940 or later. Many of the recipes name the country of origin and reflect the various countries of the refugees that settled in the Pacific North West in 1900 - 1930's.

    My mother and her sister-in-law would do a day trip from Seattle to Vancouver to shop for English china - tea cups, plates and chochkees (nick-nacks) for their homes and gifts. They also brought home delicious fancy pastries from the Bon Ton Bakery - that we would snitch out of the boxes in the old chest freezer. Mom would have company and go to serve the pastries and find only one or two left in the box. It never occurred to us that she would figure out who took them. lol I still have and use many of her tea cups and have shared others with the younger generations.

    I never realized that our old cookbooks serve as a personal history of our families.

  • jupidupi
    4 years ago

    My mom had The Settlement Cookbook, AKA, The Way to a Man's Heart. Her's was the 1950 version and I think every Jewish bride, if they lived anywhere near Milwaukee, received it as a wedding gift. I loved using it, and when I found a 1928 version at a tag sale, I bought it for my own. Besides the great recipes, there were tips about housekeeping. In the back are ads from companies that helped to sponsor the book. Mine has an ad for a stove, the latest thing, that uses gas -- so you don't have to stoke it with coal or wood.

    ophoenix thanked jupidupi
  • marilyn_c
    4 years ago

    Another old cookbook that belonged to my mother, and got ruined in the flood, was a paperback called The Southern Cookbook by Marion Brown. It had my favorite waffle recipe. I intend to buy that one again, too. I believe it was from the '50's.

    ophoenix thanked marilyn_c
  • dees_1
    4 years ago

    Socks, I also have that book. Picked it up at a flea market for $1. I also have a first edition Betty Crocker from 1950 and a first edition BGH also from 1950. I have several different versions of each of these books and reference them often.

    I have a lot of cookbooks and would have to look through to see which is the oldest.

    ophoenix thanked dees_1
  • wanda_va
    4 years ago

    I previously posted about my 1953 "Joy of Cooking" cookbook, but just realized my oldest cookbook is the "American Woman's Cookbook", published by Sears in 1950. It is a two-volume set.

    ophoenix thanked wanda_va
  • ophoenix
    Original Author
    4 years ago

    Wanda, I have an edition of the Vincent Price Cookbook, brown cover with gold printing, published in 1965. I came as a freebie with an appliance from Sears! Not sure which one but used it for years. Maybe I will come across it when I clean out two boxes of old books.

  • dees_1
    4 years ago

    ophoenix, it’s called A Treasury of Great Recipes By Vincent and Mary Price. It’s a fabulous book! I can’t believe you got it free! I also have the 1965 edition. There was a 50th anniversary re-release.

    ophoenix thanked dees_1
  • ophoenix
    Original Author
    4 years ago

    dees, now I will have to search all the places it might be. I never throw out a book, but do donate them - tomorrow I will start the search. Thanks for the heads up - I did use it but at the time was sort of busy with three boys under 6 years! Cooking was for survival, not culinary adventure! lol

  • dees_1
    4 years ago

    ophoenix, I do hope you find it as you will see it with a different set of eyes now. I've not cooked from it yet but am taking my time reading it.

  • beesneeds
    4 years ago

    I think it might be grandma's 1944 Settlement Cookbook.

  • jupidupi
    4 years ago

    I also have the paperback of Erma Bombeck's I Hate to Cook Book, which I bought back when I was in school. But truth be told, I almost never use cookbooks now. I just google the word "recipe" with whatever I want to make, or sometimes, whatever I have on hand.