If it is a wood finish now, have it refinished in a similar brown to keep the original look.

Thanks but I’m not sure the original brown matches anymore now that we painted the rest of the house to a new color scheme.

What color are the windows? brown or black?

Is the gray the new paint or the old?

Doors on Tudors don't get painted. They get stained. Perhaps a lighter stain like this will work.

Windows are Pella Brown - really dark dark brown, almost black.

Gray is new paint.

I think a sage green would still be in keeping with a Tudor style and help to bring the door out of the shadows.

For inspiration - a color something like this....or, the second one is not a Tudor, but shows a nice gray green color.

I agree, would do a greyed green that looks subtle and natural.
I might consider changing your lanterns to ones in a darker metal like your fencing.
Beautiful house!

Love the dark stain.