Thank you, I appreciate your input! What about the dining table lights? These chandeliers work well as the main/central lights, still need something that would hang much lower, just above the dining table.

I like #2 of your originals -- would add a bit of modern flare. No antlers!!

That was the reason I put those asymmetric lights in the list. The cabin is not really rustic, even though it's all wood. I'm no fan of the antlers either, it is too traditional for me. The other suggestion is nice, but somehow quite similar to what I have now?

you can get a plate or have one made to pull through various single pendants at differing heights - I like that idea with your loft as it can provide height above and below and will update. I liked the antler idea but if that doesnt fit the decor than this will. (doesn't need to be this modern, just the multiple grouping idea) https://www.houzz.com/photos/lucerne-contemporary-living-room-auckland-phvw-vp~2471106

How about something like this? I made this fixture for a client in Texas, feel free to message me for more details here:

Via Etsy

Via Houzz

Etsy Shop

Instagram Feed

Facebook

Note: All the lights in this fixture are adjustable, they can hang a different heights too.

yes, but in my mind I thought more random and non matching? This is lovely though.

I like the idea of random lights, think it would make the loft really special, I’m just unsure of the details. I’ve been reading/searching so much on this topic that I’ve ended up cancelling my order for the dining table lights, thinking that the vintage beam is too old/dark, compared to the wood in the rest of the house. This is getting more complicated than I thought it would be, but your input does help!
Thank you
The cancelled order:

Just so I understand correctly, you need task AND ambient lighting: a chandelier over the dining table (task) and something to replace the two chandeliers (ambient). Is that right? Are the two chandeliers the only means of ambient lighting in this space (which is great, by the way!)? Will you be hanging the new dining room fixture from that beam that appears to be directly over the table?

Yes, I need both types, task and ambient lights. Besides the existing 2 chandeliers, there are 6 wall lights too, so these will have to be replaced to match the new style.
The beam is not exactly above the dining table, it’s one meter to the left. I’m thinking about hanging the dining table lights from another higher beam, I’ll take a picture and post it here.

The space above the dining table

I'm not sure you want dangling wires competing with the already complex and busy woodwork in here. that is why I went with a round shape that is not too busy. I am assuming you plan to add power over the table in which case i would hang something linear with the same vibe as the two you replace above. IMO.

For your general lighting, you could install a cable lighting system. And, actually, you can hang pendants from the cable system for things like the dining table. I happen to think your home would look amazing with this type of lighting. The first photo is one I go back to time and time again because the lights just seem to float as if they were stars or something. Imagine how beautiful that would look at night in your chalet with those windows and cavernous ceiling!

If these interest you, check out Tech Lighting.