So many options, and so many discussions here on this very topic. Have you done a Houzz search?

If not, look into any porcelain or ceramic tile, in any color, since you have white and white. Or do a Moroccan zeliig tile.

Thank you for your response. I have searched and I am a little overwhelmed. I hadn‘t heard of the Moroccan tile. I will check those out.

Maybe post a photo of your room and state what colors you like.

What happened to the white subway? https://www.houzz.com/discussions/5771799/help-i-m-not-loving-my-new-kitchen-need-help-pulling-this-together

What’s your budget?

I think a soft, subtle color would be nice. I’d look at some of the pretty glazes with a lot of variation, like Fireclay. I’m using Clétile’s zellige in my kitchen, and it’s a pretty option, too. Your kitchen just leans more traditional, to me, which is why I recommended Fireclay.

What color do you like? Not what color do you think is in, but the color that you've loved forever. With white shaker cabinets and super white quartzite, you have a ton of options.

Fireclay tile comes in a ton of colors and could be a great option.

I was going with white because I love the look of a white kitchen. The installation was suppose to happen last week but I postponed it until this weekend because I was second guessing myself But I still keep coming back to white. These are a few I’m looking at. Any thoughts?

Either of the arabesque tiles would look fantastic!

Would you go with white grout as well?

Is that the beveled arabesque by Mission? If so, I’ve used it a couple of times, and I prefer it with a white grout. It keeps the pattern subtle.

In the kitchen in my former house:

And the fireplace surround in my current home:

I know I'm in the minority when I say that I'm not a fan of beveled arabesque (or arabesque tile in general), especially for the kitchen. It always makes me think it belongs in the bathroom not the kitchen.

My vote is for the rectangular (marble) tile in the middle. Subtle enough, but not too much. :)

Never mix two different stones together.

I'm not a fan of the arabesque either.

I also do not like arabesque and mixing stones never works well and either do beveled tiles.IMO keeping it simple is best maybe just a larger format tile . I would be looking at gray tiles IMO you have enough white gray with gray grout that matches is simple and timeless use the same everywhere no fancy stuff behind the stove.

(I still vote for a colored Fireclay.)

Soft blue, or green would be lovely. Fireclay, Heath, Encore all have lovely ceramic tiles. I do not like seeing two different stones together.

how do you like the Super White quartzite? Any issues with etching or stains?