Years ago I grew Liv Tyler, and it was very fragrant with a fruity scent with a melon note. Sweet Mademoiselle has similar color and is quite fragrant.

I've seen Yves Piaget in bloom, and as I recall it is very fragrant.

I haven't grown any of these, but I recall Strawchicago raved about Dee-lish's fragrance. and I recall it being healthy for her.

The times I’ve smelled All Dressed Up and Pink Enchantment, they were at best moderately scented. So if I were picking a list of good roses with fragrance being a top criteria, they wouldn’t be on it.

I've grown Wild Blue Yonder since 2006 and have never noticed it being fragrant at all. It's an extremely vigorous, upright growing, big grandiflora. Its blooms are produced in clusters and they fade easily, so often the flush appears almost multicolored. WBY is the only rose on your list that I grow. Here's a photo. Diane

Thank you all. Diane, l Love your pictures of WBY, even if it’s not fragrant

I grow only 2 of the list :

Pink Enchantment blooms a lot and is a huge bush but with no fragrance for me .

Princess Charlene de Monaco , a tall bush but doesn't bloom much ,has a wonderful strong fragrance .

Sara Ann, I've only grown 3 out of the list.

Wild Blue Yonder did not survive here, a zone colder than you. Diane's is to-die-for gorgeous and I would LOVE to be able to grow it like that. I've taken out two of mine, and giving the third, very small one, a last chance.

Pink Enchantment - same story. Grew backward from the get go. Her few blooms were so pretty, I was sad to lose her.

Princess Charlene de Monaco is new this year, and so far I am impressed with the amount of growth and blooms. Appears to be vigorous and healthy.

I grow 2 on the list, and have seen two in person.

Dee-lish is a strong grower for me. Blooms through the summer, and has a moderately strong fragrance, like Starburst Fruit Chews or grapefruit depending on its mood. Yes, mouthwatering. Like all roses, strength of fragrance depends on weather, humidity and time of day. The color is a rather strident coral and I've debated eliminating it a few times (but when I was on the verge, I found I was very sad, so it is staying). The sun here can burn the petals. Blooms nod a bit, which to my eye adds to the attraction. It makes a nice cut flower, and is of course much more fragrant indoors. Fragrance 7, plant 8, Flower beauty 8, Vigor 9, Heat tolerance 8-9.

I also grow Princesse Charlene de Monaco. This one is getting donated. It is a very strong lanky grower, and blooms are extremely variable, at the ends of long cutting stems. The fragrance is strong and delicious, similar to Abraham Darby. The reason I'm getting rid of it is because the flowers fade very quickly (within 1-2 days) to a color I don't like. I have not even taken photos of it in that color because I dislike it so much. Flowers do make good cut flowers. This one could be one for a cutting garden, but not worth growing in my garden.

This is what I WISH it looked like all the time:

Color at its BEST can range from this:

To this:

Keep in mind these are the photos of her at her very best. 1-2 days later it is a dingy dirty diaper buff. Fragrance 8. plant 4, Flower beauty 8 going to 1 in a day, Vigor 9, Heat tolerance 3 (for color, but flowers actually last 4-5 days, which is a long time here).

Wild Blue Yonder at the public rose garden is vigorous and blooms throughout the summer heat here. Fragrance is citrusy and strong. In the public garden it is not a huge plant, but gets minimal care. Flowers fade quite a bit as Nanadoll has said. The plant is standard modern rose form. Personally, I love the flower form and I've been trying to find a place for this one in my garden, but it just doesn't fit in.

Fragrance 6, plant 8, Flower beauty 9, Vigor 9, Heat tolerance 8.

I'm not going to say much about Yves Piaget, which is the only other one I've seen. Growing in my mother's neighbor's front yard in coastal San Francisco bay area, and grown as a standard, it is a huge plant, with enormous flowers (easily 5") and decadent fragrance. Another one I'd love to grow.

Beautiful pictures noseometer! Dee-Lish must be a good rose, I’m very impressed with what I’ve seen and read, not sure why I haven’t paid closer attention to that one sooner! Really do think Princesse Charlene de Monaco is a beauty too, and Yves Piaget looks lovely to me. Would love to learn more about them all. I appreciate you all contributing.

Pink Enchantment; Big, upright bush that repeats quickly on LONG stems. Not much scent. Thorns are very nasty.

Sunny Sky; A medium size bush that puts on a great spring show, then very little until fall. Not a lot of scent but the blooms are very beautiful.

Thank you Ken, I think I would consider Sunny Sky, even without much scent, I would like another good yellow.

I remember picking up my roses from k and m from the Nashville rose society sale , and seeing Nicole carol in person . It’s fragrance was outstanding!! It was so beautiful too .

Lilyfinch seems like I’ve read some good things about NCM, it looks lovely. Can’t recall who has grown it it, but would love to learn more. It‘s encouraging that it has a nice fragrance.