Engineered vs. solid 5" white oak floors/select vs. character
sunflowerbk
5 years ago
last modified: 5 years ago
Featured Answer
Comments (10)
PROUptown Floors
5 years agolast modified: 5 years agoI've never heard rift and quartered as being 'stronger' but in this day and age everyone has an opinion. Perhaps you're referring to being harder. If there is a difference, you won't recognize it.
"Feel fake." Sure a cheap floating floor can feel fake when walking on it, but that's more to do with no floor preparation.
R+Q look fake? It's unique. Some love the look while others don't.
5 1/4" Rift & Qtrd White Oak Character
4 1/4" Plain Sawn Character White Oak
sunflowerbk thanked Uptown Floors
sunflowerbk
5 years agolast modified: 5 years agoRelated Discussions
Solid Hickory vs Red Oak hardwood floors
Comments (5)Houses14 = I too thought about using Hickory as I like a lot of variation in color and was interested in having floors with character... What changed my mind was when we cleared the trees to build our house we had a truck load of saw logs and I couldn't bear to see them go to waste. I thought the least I could do for imposing on them was to give them a place in my home. I had a mill cut them into rough boards then finished them out at a local kiln. They were planed, cut, and milled. I had them cut to yield, which gave me 3" - 4" and 5" planks. I asked them to leave in the knots and sawmarks. The first picture is a close up of the floor boards and the second is a picture of the room. These are site finished natural with a touch of brown in them to make the knots pop... The floors just had the final coat put on them and look even better than these pictures... We are very happy with our red oak... I'm sure whatever you choose will be great... Good luck. Saftgeek-...See MoreSap Hickory Flooring vs. White Oak Flooring
Comments (10)I have done a little Hickory and have seen lots of Hickory floors. I've never seen one with acclimation issues. If it's dried and acclimated properly I see no reason why you should have stability issues with it but it seems like a lot of trouble to use it instead of Red Oak. Red Oak is more consistent than White Oak or Hickory and could easily be stained to a medium dark brown with a slight reddish tone. To get it dark without being overly grainy you might have to water-pop it before staining. You would need three coats of poly to get a nice smooth finish after water popping but the first two coats can be tinted with stain to richen or fine tune the color. White Oak and Hickory both have lots of color variation and are more of a nutty brown or taupe tone. Walnut is not only soft but is generally fairly expensive. If you're going dark enough you could use Santos Mahogany. It stains well. Clear grade Santos is reasonably uniform, has a red tone, is hard and has interesting grain....See MoreShaw Engineered Maple vs. Bruce Solid Maple flooring
Comments (3)My subfloor is not slab so I can do either. I had originally thought of doing solid, so I could refinish them, but I have a budget of $5/SF and this Bruce solid is the only one in my budget that is 5 inches wide. Alas, reviews of their solid floors seem quite poor, although I have not read any reviews specifically of their Kennedale line, which the store salesman tells me is very high quality. I have read that the engineered is better for wider planks. So that is one consideration. I also read that the Shaw finish is very durable and scratch resistant. I am hoping to buy a Roomba and have that sweep up every day, keeping dust to a minimum. The darker wood really sets off my white cabinetry well, somI prefer to go as dark as I can allow. Doesmany one own a Roomba and can speak to how well those work?...See MoreEngineered vs. Solid Hardwood
Comments (19)"Some worked, some didn't." It happens. Unfortunately what happens in new construction is framers don't put enough pressure on where they're fastening, especially with the use of pneumatic nailers today. They may spread enough construction adhesive on the floor joists, but once the plywood is laid, they run like heck to nail it home. IE: the adhesive isn't squeezed down in any consistent matter, creating voids that cause squeaks. I learned this while working on a job ten years ago. It was actually a warranty claim. The builder was found at fault because the framers didn't install the ply the right way. Not many do really. To them it's about getting the job done. Most don't even think about problems it can cause. The customer naturally wanted it done right. Hence, all flooring and sub flooring was removed and re-installed. Ken Fisher...See More
PROOak & Broad
5 years ago5" and wider needs to glued and nailed if its solid. Here are some of our own photos of Rift & Quartered in Character Grade and also Select Grade. The solution to your problem is to still go with Rift & Quartered but an Unfinished engineered so you can still finish it on site. It sounds like a site finished floor is important to you. :-)
Educational Plank Flooring Examples · More Infosunflowerbk thanked Oak & Broadsunflowerbk
5 years agodan1888
5 years ago
Related Stories
REMODELING GUIDESYour Floor: An Introduction to Solid-Plank Wood Floors
Get the Pros and Cons of Oak, Ash, Pine, Maple and Solid Bamboo
Full Story
WOODWoodipedia: Make a Solid Choice With Oak
Forget those low-end products of old. Red and white oak today are beautiful, versatile and relatively inexpensive
Full Story
REMODELING GUIDESWhen to Use Engineered Wood Floors
See why an engineered wood floor could be your best choice (and no one will know but you)
Full Story
MOST POPULARPros and Cons of 5 Popular Kitchen Flooring Materials
Which kitchen flooring is right for you? An expert gives us the rundown
Full Story
REMODELING GUIDESAre You Gutsy Enough to Paint Your Floor White?
Sleek and glossy or softened by wear, white floors charm
Full Story
REMODELING GUIDESWhat to Know About Engineered Wood Floors
Engineered wood flooring offers classic looks and durability. It can work with a range of subfloors, including concrete
Full Story
KITCHEN CABINETSNew This Week: 4 Not-White Kitchens With Character
See how cabinets in gray, pale green, light wood and inky blue bring character and dimension to their spaces
Full Story
KITCHEN MAKEOVERSKitchen of the Week: White and Wood for a Busy Family of 5
A designer helps a New Jersey couple create a brighter and more efficient space for their active lifestyle
Full Story
FLOORSHow to Care for Engineered Wood Flooring
Keep your wood floor looking its best with these tips and tricks from the experts
Full Story
REMODELING GUIDES5 Innovative Wood Floors
Natural Forms? Wine Barrels? Peach Pits? Take a Look at Some New Ideas for a Warm Wood Floor
Full Story
sprink1es