Do you mean length? the width of 12 is fine. But I dont think you have enough finish work to pick out pendants yet.

12” might look wimpy on an island that length. Your pictures make it look like your ceilings are higher than 8’. Are your doors only 6’? Asking because you have what lookalikes foot aboutyour door? My island is a bit shorter than yours but my lights are 16” width. My ceilings are 10’4”. Your ceilings look higher than 8’.

2 would be too small IMO- go larger or do 3 as suggested. Our island is 104 & we did 3, here is a photo>>

[houzz=https://www.houzz.com/photos/new-build-gabe-phvw-vp~126230138]

My island is the same size, we have 7.5' ceilings... did 3 pendants.

dimensions according to Pottery barn (they're the large textured glass pendant) are

• Top Diameter: 2"
• Bottom Diameter: 10"
• Height: 9"
  

Those look great.

Also I chose clear because I was afraid of visual clutter with the low ceilings. Seeing them up I think I would have been fine with something like the ones you posted. I think yours will look nice as long as you tie in the ORB color elsewhere like cabinet hardware.

Have you ever thought of doing a flush mount that has some vertical length to it? Something like this

Or one single light that extends horizontally

Or even something like this. Larger circumstance but shorter height

These or one like them might be a consideration since you have plenty of horizontal room to work with it’s your vertical space that’s a challenge due to your 8’ ceilings.

https://www.houzz.com/user/sandra-grimsley

Livex Lighting Milford Outdoor Hanging Lanterns, Brushed Nickel · [More Info[(https://www.houzz.com/products/livex-lighting-milford-outdoor-hanging-lanterns-brushed-nickel-prvw-vr~32938552)

I think this is the one>>> if it is it is from Houzz....click on more information

Sandra if you click on the info for that photo it will link you to the light. It’s here on Houzz. It is called The Milford and it does come in different finishes. Several web sites sell it and the price is excellent.

Well the photo didn’t show up trying again

Sandra , you can do two but you need to make sure the height circumstance ratio is proportioned to your ceiling height and island size. So in a nut shell search for something that is short in height but has a large circumstance:width. Also a rod bs a chain will be more forgiving visually in a shorter length. Also don’t be afraid to put something up that wouldnt come up in an island light or pendant light search. You’re more likely to find what you need doing a chandelier search because because you want something large around. If two us what you want then make your Choice bold and intentional. Don’t hang two small scale lantern type lights up and expect them to work. Moving electrical and patching drywall etc. Is not cheap so really take your time until you find what is right. you could even do two of something like this for a Wow statement.

Rohan Collection Chandelier, 36"x19", 6-Light, Matte Black Finish · More Info

look and see if you can find something in Exterior lights that also may work... love the chandy that pink posted :)