Houzz Logo Print
anoukq

Non-yellowing finish for latex-painted vinyl floor--affordability key!

6 years ago

I've seen so many contradictory suggestions and done so much research on this, with no clear consensus. And big NB: I'm trying to do this on a budget.


BACKGROUND:


I bought a cheap vinyl remnant, and am following instructions on transforming it into a "floor cloth" (not canvas) to cover my very ugly brown kitchen apartment flooring. Per most recs, I should use the reverse side, clean well w/ TSP, sand lightly, use good binding primer; but from there, opinions differ.


Some insist one use only floor/porch paint (for obvious reasons); others suggest chalk paint w/ Annie Sloane's varnish, and many say just latex paint with several layers of simple polycrylic.


I ended up buying a gallon of white, latex floor paint, and since I'm doing this on a budget, I plan to find samples of regular latex paint that are actual paint (not just pigment w/ a little binder). to stencil over the white in 3-4 colors--since floor paint generally just comes by the gallon, I can't really afford to buy that many colors of floor paint (although if doing so would eliminate the need for an expensive sealant, it might be an option...).


THE FINISH:


Two things I am certain of is that whatever finish I use should be 1) water-based for a non-yellowing finish; and 2) matte or satin.


I was going to go the polycrylic route, but my friend in the paint department at Ace was apoplectic at the suggestion. He said that he would do nothing less than Rustoleum Varathane Crystal Clear Floor FInish; that using a polycrylic or even regular polyurethane would make the finish prone to cracking under foot traffic. I was apoplectic at the price: at Ace, at least, $60+ for a gallon, with four coats recommended. No smaller sizes available--I only really need a quart, but checked the product page and Rustoleum doesn't make it.


So trying to find something cheaper. Here are some alternatives I'm considering. Would love feedback as to 1) durability as a floor finish; 2) suitability for use over latex (non-yellowing and no problems with binding); and 3) water-resistance and ability to be cleaned over the years with a mild cleanser (dawn+water+little vinegar, probably).

  • Found a great deal on Varathane Ultimate Spar Water-Based Urethane. Not designed for floors per se, but water-resistant, fast drying, and per what I've read, much more liquid/easier to apply than traditional spar urethane. One concern about which I've read here and there hints that spar urethane as a class might attract/collect dirt . . . but I'm not sure why or whether this would be true for this water-based version. If not, and given the price, this would be the best option by far: is there any reason not to jump on this?
  • Polyurethane like General Finishes High Performance Waterbased Topcoat (which seems to get the best reviews) or Varathane Ultimate Polyurethane Waterbased (much cheaper): both are available in quart and even pint size. But the paint guy at Ace would kill me :). Would it really be that much worse than the Floor Finish or a poly designed for floors, in practice?
  • Just breaking out the cash for a floor paint in three additional colors, and not sealing it (as some blogs recommend)? Or is there a paint of similar quality in terms of durability available in very small sizes that I don't know of?
  • Or something else that's I haven't mentioned that's affordable? I'm open to anything, so long as it is durable, plays well with a latex finish, and is non-yellowing.


Thank you! Let me know if you need more info lol.

Comments (5)