New lake house plans needs review please....
B Sharpe
5 years ago
Featured Answer
Comments (24)
cpartist
5 years agoRelated Discussions
Home Plan - Please Review - Pretty Pretty Please :)
Comments (13)You've obviously put a whole lot of thought into your floorplan and how to make it meet the needs of your family. I like it a whole lot but I do have a few questions and concerns. Not sure what you mean by "maximize light coming in from the bathroom off the mudroom." Are you wanting light from that bathroom window to spill into the mudroom and provide natural light there? If so, I don't think there is anyway to get very much light to spill over and still give the bathroom the necessary privacy, You CAN put an interior transom windows up over the bathroom door which will allow some light spillover. And, you could use a frosted glass door for the bathroom door. I'm not a fan of the latter except in masterbedrooms where there is less need for a total "sense" of privacy. You might also consider putting in a light tube to bring natural light into the mudroom. I have another concern about the bathroom by the mudroom tho. Not sure if that is a shower or a dog-shower or a utility sink in the lower right hand corner but with it there, you have no space in front of the vanity sink to stand while washing hands. What is that room between the staircase and the office? I can't read what is says and, at first, assumed it was your pantry but then I found the pantry down next to the dining room. I agree that a larger pantry would be nice. As your kids get older, you're going to have bikes and other sports equipment to store in the garage. It would be nice to have room for the second freezer inside the house so that the garage space could be dedicated to that other stuff. The hallway on the children's side may be too narrow to easily move furniture into their bedrooms. There is an indication that it is 3'4" wide (which would be plenty wide) but based on the grid background, it looks like the wall to wall width may only be about 2'8". Does the 3'4" measurement include the 4" deep walls on both sides? If the actual wall-to-wall hall width isn't at least 3'0", you might want to consider bumping the left exterior wall out another couple of inches. Given the overall size of the house, a few more inches won't make a noticeable difference in the cost to build. But a too narrow hallway will bug you forever! To maintain exterior symmetry, you would probably also want to bump out the exterior wall on the garage/masterbedroom side of the house as well. But, a few extra inches on that side could be useful as well. The only thing about the design that I really really don't like is the powderroom that opens directly into the living room. Guests will be squemish about using a PR that is so centrally located...too much concern that others will hear them as they go about their business or, even worse, if their business tends to create a bit of a stink, the smell will waft out into the living room before the bathroom vent fan can take care of it. And, do you really want to be looking at a toilet when your babies leave the bathroom door open while there are guests in the house. IMHO, that bathroom REALLY needs to be moved to a location further from the center of activity. The closet for bedroom III seems a bit small - especially for a girl who will eventually get to be a teenager! Also, be aware that your dryer needs to vent to the outside. It is easiest to vent a dryer that is on or very near an exterior wall. Given the location of your laundry room, I've linked below to some info that you should probably read regarding venting a clothes dryer. Just a thought but, have you tried putting the playroom in the middle of the left wing then having two short halls leading off of it with two bedrooms at the front, and two bedrooms and the laundry room at the back? And the guest powderroom tucked in to the left of the study so that one must go down a short hallway from the living room to reach it? this is really really rough but may give you some ideas Here is a link that might be useful: dryer vent info....See MoreHouse Plans--Please Review!
Comments (15)Agree that the toilet in the master bath should be switched with the linen closet so the toilet isn't on the master bedroom wall. Same with the W/D. Your master closet is 8' wide. Considering you need 2' of hanging on each side that leaves you 4' in the center. Will that be a large enough turning radius for you? I dislike that your master bedroom only has the two windows and is backing the laundry area. I think it would work a heck of a lot better where the exercise room is. You would have to reconfigure where the other spaces are, but how nice would it be to have a bedroom where you're looking out at your backyard vs just a wall with a fireplace? I also don't like the idea that the bedroom egress window is in your master closet. That doesn't feel very safe to me. You have 6' between counters in the kitchen. The turning radius needed for wheelchair accessibility is 5' not 6' and I agree that the extra foot would be better used between the island and the dining table space. Right now you don't have enough space there. Also switch your dishwasher with your sink so your dishwasher isn't in your prep and work area. This way if the DW is open you can still cook or prep. Will you have any problems maneuvering in bedrooms 2 and 3? Wouldn't you prefer your deck ramp to lead you into the main part of the backyard? Instead of two sinks in the kids bathroom, I'd change it to 1 sink with lots of storage. I don't think anyone will notice the kitchen and family room are "out of alignment". We tend to look at rooms overall. We also considered a courtyard garage, but it stuck out even further. The difference is with a courtyard entry to the garage, you won't be looking straight at two huge garage doors but instead will be looking at a design that is incorporated into the look of the house using windows etc. I would seriously reconsider using a courtyard garage....See MoreNew House Plan Review
Comments (10)Well, you would gain more useable kitchen space and counter length by eliminating the opening for the pantry as shown, and combining the pantry and mud area with access to the pantry from the corridor connecting the garage. There's just too much diverse circulation in the kitchen area, taking up too much space. Your plans are really quite varied spatially and suggest a strong and enlivening experience inside the house. The plans are quite good I think. Unfortunately, the excitement and sophistication of the interior spaces are well hidden behind the rather Plain Jane exteriors, which conceal any sense of design or uniqueness on the interior. My suggestion is start over on the exteriors and let them be a little less "ranchy" and better suggest some of the excitement of the interiors. Good luck on your journey--exciting times ahead....See MoreHouse Plan Review Please - Nelson Design Group 1379
Comments (32)DH had already said he won't close in the storage area in the garage. His work bench and tools from his current garage will go there. In that case, I'd widen it so that it's useful. I described my uncle's similar long, narrow, have to squeeze-into-it storage ... this is the same thing, and it would not at all be suitable for a work bench and tools. Measure it out: Less than 5' wide ... you use 18"-24" for the bench and tool storage ... you have only about 3' of walking space. He'd knock his elbows against the back wall constantly. Opening it makes sense because then he can store tools against the wall and -- when necessary -- pull a car out, and he has all the working space in the world. If he won't open it, expanding it is essential. As it's drawn now, it's good only for storage ... and it's not really good for that. The breakfast nook will become a coffee/beverage bar area. I like that idea. Regarding the shower in the laundry room... that's the only thing DH has really asked for! It's not muddy feet that we deal with... he and DS get absolutely filthy from head to toe. I get that they're dirty all over ... but only their feet are touching the inside of your house before they reach their own bathroom /bedroom. They're not rubbing up against the walls as they walk, are they? The porch (hypothetically) will be a significant cost in the big picture. We tend to think about "the main house" and discount the costs of garages and porches ... but, yeah, they are expensive. Not as expensive as interior rooms, of course, but they aren't an insignificant cost. Regardless of cost, they are integral to "the look" of a house like the one we're describing. If you are unable to find a good architect, maybe have a look at the Moser Design Group website? I think their farmhouse plans tend to be simpler and less McMansion-like.That's a cute farmhouse (whereas the OP's original design isn't a farmhouse). I like the layout of the kitchen/dining and the living room's windows are great! I don't care for the bedrooms at all, though that back bedroom might be good for the office. North Carolina and the College of Architecture at NC State is full of experienced and talented architects. NC State is not known for architecture; their claim to fame is engineering (in all its many forms) and vet science ... and bricks. Seriously, that's all they have: bricks. It's UNC-Charlotte that's the NC powerhouse for that subject. However, I think the architects must move out of state because we are certainly not rife with them. I personally only know one person who works as an architect; well, I knew two, but one died....See Moreopaone
5 years agogalore2112
5 years agoB Sharpe
5 years agoB Sharpe
5 years agoB Sharpe
5 years agorobin0919
5 years agoMark Bischak, Architect
5 years agoMark Bischak, Architect
5 years agolast modified: 5 years agoB Sharpe thanked Mark Bischak, ArchitectB Sharpe
5 years agoB Sharpe
5 years agoB Sharpe
5 years ago
Related Stories
DECORATING GUIDESDesign Dilemma: I Need Lake House Decor Ideas!
How to Update a Lake House With Wood, Views, and Just Enough Accessories
Full StoryVACATION HOMESHouzz Tour: A Peaceful Lake House Rises From the Rubble
Crashing trees left this Vermont home uninhabitable, but a redesign made it better than ever
Full StoryVACATION HOMESHouzz Tour: New Lake House Looks Like It’s Been There 100 Years
Simple detailing and careful design create a classic cottage loaded with charm in Minnesota
Full StoryREMODELING GUIDESHouse Planning: When You Want to Open Up a Space
With a pro's help, you may be able remove a load-bearing wall to turn two small rooms into one bigger one
Full StoryTRADITIONAL HOMESHouzz Tour: New Traditional Home With Lake House Charm
A couple's full-time home on Minnesota's Green Lake offers indoor-outdoor spaces and a comfortable blend of styles
Full StoryKITCHEN OF THE WEEKKitchen of the Week: Fresh Cabin Charm for a Minnesota Lake House
A designer helps a couple find compromises to suit her modern and his rustic tastes
Full StoryHOUZZ TOURSHouzz Tour: Luxurious and Comfortable Lake House
Step Inside a Harmonious Home Rich in Fabrics, Finishes and Craftsmanship
Full StoryUNIVERSAL DESIGNWhat to Look for in a House if You Plan to Age in Place
Look for details like these when designing or shopping for your forever home
Full StoryMODERN ARCHITECTUREHouzz TV: This Amazing Lake House Made a Couple’s Dream Come True
Step inside a dream home on Lake Austin, where architecture celebrating gorgeous views has a striking beauty of its own
Full StoryREMODELING GUIDESGet What You Need From the House You Have
6 ways to rethink your house and get that extra living space you need now
Full Story
bpath