Suggestion - post over at the Home Decorating site and, if possible, post a picture along with your post. In the meantime, try this site for experimentation. You can choose house colors, shingle colors, door, trim etc. in a mix and match way. http://exteriorfx.owenscorning.com/exteriorfx/Welcome.do

What a wonderful project. And how nice that the house is set back so that different areas of transition can be created. Will you be growing tall trees so the home is eventually sheltered in dappled shade? Lower landscaping so the house rises above washed with sunshine? Do you want a rather mysterious look with a narrow area of accented house intriguing and drawing the eye in , making people going by try to see more? Do you want an open look with the property lushly foliaged but the house very much on display, serenely or exuberantly? If you have a image in mind of what you want, style, mood and light included, you could then drive around both creative older and expensively landscaped neighborhoods looking for ideas to realize it. Color choices made then? These mostly lack the rich color you want, but I was mostly thinking first of how it might be dressed with garden. :) Lush elsewhere, perhaps, but close in as open and airy as the interior? I'm really not crazy about brown in general, but even I think a brown reminiscent of wet tree trunks works wonderfully to accent and tie inside, transition areas, garden together. The previous property uses it also.

Really attractive home. Liking the front porch as is. Would NOT paint or whitewash the brick; however, if you do you do want a more solid color, consider staining it, keeping the grout/brick look. Unless the garage door needs to be repainted, and if you like the garage door color as is, then you might consider staining the brick the same light gray color as the garage door, keeping the grout / brick look in place. Alternately, stain the brick a color you want to act as a frame to your front door. https://www.google.com/search?q=brick+stain&client=firefox-b-1-d&tbm=isch&source=lnms&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiggr2-4PfpAhXamXIEHWDxBtcQ_AUIoAIoAQ&biw=1366&bih=654 You could literally then paint all the painted surfaces, except the door, the same color -- whichever one appeals to you -- add white board trim around the white window frames and have a good look for your home and make choosing your roofing easier. A medium/dark mixed shades of gray roof would work with most exterior siding colors -- white, grays, blues -- and the mix of roof colors will have a more clean look than a solid color with splotches of bird poo on it. Fascia and gutter could be gray or black or white, with downspouts painted to visually disappear against your choice of siding color. A medium/dark shingles mix of shades of brown and tan would also look good, with either white or black fascia and gutter, again painting the downspouts, of course. This would work with brown or tan or green siding. Would not put a contrasting trim color around the garage door -- would keep the color around the door itself all one (siding) color. You should decide on all colors as a combination: roofing, fascia/gutter, brick (stain), siding/downspouts, window trim, -- you want them to work together. Too many different colors could have a cluttered vibe. Last time I looked the gutter choices in stock at the local big box building stores were either white or brown but there are others available. https://www.milehighgutter.com/gutter-color-options/ Since the siding color will be dominant, my suggestion would be to pick out your favorite siding colors -- just a few -- and consider what other colors you'd want with each of those, then decide from those few groups. I also suggest you drive through some neighborhoods in your area and consider the color combinations others have used, paying attention to the difference in how the colors give off the vibe you want - do you smile or have a negative response or are you indifferent to those combinations: what reaction do you want as you approach your own home. Exterior natural wood finish boards can be a great look and worth considering in a protected place but they don't really weather well, including/especially where they're getting direct sun, so, unless you're considering covering the brick and using that natural wood board look for the entire indented / weather protected front porch niche and that space doesn't get any direct sun, there is no obvious place to add those. Keeping/staining the brick either to match the garage door or to create a desired frame color for your front entry door likely would be a better option.

The ones you have look pretty good. What direction were you wanting to go with the replacements?