Experience with Renewal by Andersen windows?
KWS
5 years ago
Featured Answer
Comments (63)
samondragon
5 years agoHU-516850748
5 years agoRelated Discussions
Windows -Renewal by Andersen?
Comments (9)I just purchased Andersen Woodwright Insert windows - installation starts today. So I've been through all the decisions. These are the "400 Series" - I thought that Renewal by Andersen windows were the lesser "200 Series" - but I'm not sure. I assume that you are looking at "insert" replacement windows and not sash replacements nor new construction windows. I looked at Pella, Marvin, Harvey (a regional brand?), and Andersen - I didn't look at Renewal by Andersen because I just didn't want to deal with any pushy, franchise salesperson. For looks, build-quality it came down to this for me - Marvin, Andersen, Pella, and then Harvey. Harvey was a lot cheaper but I just didn't like the look/quality. I didn't get a price from Pella - seemed like they wanted to send a sales person to the house. Marvin - of course - turned out to be the most expensive - about $150/window more than Andersen. I just couldn't justify the extra expense for something I only liked marginally better. But you should compare prices since they vary by size and options. I would start by going to a good window/door distributor - who should have sample units on display. You can price installation separately. Andersen "Sun" glass is just darker - lets in less light as far as I know. "Terratone" is just a color - brown. TruScene is just a more transparent screen - nice but expensive - for me it was about $50/window. Hope that helps!...See MoreAndersen Renewal vs. Marvin Infinity casements
Comments (1)My experience with both products favors the Renewal window. The performance numbers are rather similar however the aesthetics of the Fibrex window looks more authentic and resembles a painted wood window even though is has a vinyl PermaShield coating. The only downside to the fiberglass is that it is a paint and sometimes doesnt have the most even coverage. I have found that some installations i have gone back on with fiberglass windows, had some "missed" or unpainted spots especially in the corners. This could develop mold and of course could lead to bigger problems down the road. Good luck and no matter who you choose, make sure the installation is done by a certified professional. Renewal is and can only be installed by certified, trained installers....See MoreAndersen Renewal vs. Andersen Woodwright
Comments (4)I'm not sure on the price comparison, but Anderson owns a company named Eagle, and I think it is Anderson's "luxury home" product line. However, we've had clients request pricing from Anderson in the past, and we didn't notice a big difference. However, this was only on a few occasions in the past 5 years, so things may have changed. Eagle, Kolbe and Marvin all build fairly comparable products in their upper-end product lines. Unless I'm mistaken, they all utilize extruded aluminum in their construction. This differs substantially from Anderson's vinyl extrusion and Pella's roll-formed aluminum. Remember, this cladding material is designed to protect the wood beneath it and is therefore very important. It is my opinion that unless it is extruded aluminum and using proper extrusion joinery, you'd be better off with an all wood window and keeping up on the maintenance....See MoreRenewal by Andersen or Marvin Integrity or Starmark Windows
Comments (18)There is quite a bit of misinformation that you have been given Mr Jones, I'd definitely take some extra time to sort through it all and make sure that you have accurate facts. I'll go through some, all of which are easily verifiable: Manufacturer and material : All three are very reputable, with Andersen and Marvin having a longer history. That said, Okna has indeed been in business since the early 90's and is a top 100 manufacturer as well. The 3 materials have similar histories as well, as none have been used commonly in a residential window application for more than 20 yrs. All three have their merits, although all three do represent a small "niche" . Vinyl and wood are FAR more common. There is no clear winner here IMO. All are suitable with no decisive pros or cons, particularly considering that each individual product is designed and engineered to exploit the respective materials' inherent strengths, and mitigate its weaknesses. If there is one that I'd put slightly behind the others it would be the Renewal, as adding wood flour/sawdust to vinyl really doesn't add much. Appearance: This depends of course on what areas are examined, however the Marvin all ultrex integrity is by far the slimmest. The Renewal and Starmark are both somewhat bulky by comparison, although neither is very bulky compared to some other products. Despite the slim lines, the all ultrex Integrity is actually the least attractive based on the feedback that I hear. The wood/ultrex on the other hand is bulkier. This category is in the eye of the beholder. Each has its own strengths and weaknesses. Interior appearance: well stated. Some folks would prefer the rich, real wood interior (Integrity) with only a 10 year warranty, others would prefer the synthetic stainable with lifetime warranty and no maintenance (Starmark). Winner again depends on the individual and their needs/wants. Hardware: The Renewal and Starmark both have more attractive hardware options than the Integrity IMO. Both are all metal, both have multiple finishes available. Performance: Here's a big one. To accurately compare, it is necessary to look at apples to apples glass packages. At .25 for a standard double pane package, and .19 for triple pane argon, the Starmark runs away with the win here. With equivalent glass (surface 2 low e, argon fill), the the Renewal and Integrity are .29 or higher. You can switch to any other glass package across the board, and apples to apples the Starmark will be multiple points better. This can be verified via CPD number (certified products directory) at nfrc.org Air Infiltration: Another big one. The reps that you have spoken to are either flat out lying, or being highly manipulative. The only window of the 3 that sees that .05 AI number is the Starmark. The other two are in the teens at best, if not .2+. I would request a structural test data sheet for reference. If renewal or Marvin will provide it, make sure to compare the size of the window and configuration. It is highly likely that your rep(s) are using casement or picture window ratings to compare to the starmark double hung. The starmark is .01 as a casement. Patio doors: Since this was mentioned, the differences as stated for windows continue for patio doors. If the real wood interior is preferred at the expense of performance, then the Marvin or renewal options are better. The Starmark will be a much better performer, but without the real wood interior. Installation and durability: On durability, this is another area that would trend toward Starmark based on containing no organic parts that can rot, and also on the lifetime warranty. Renewal and Integrity are each 10 years (20 on glass). Installation itself will vary by dealer, and should be given proper weight. One cannot speculate on the quality of installation based only on material however. The only thing that could possibly be considered on that line of thinking would be availability to contractors I suppose. Integrity can be purchased by anyone, whereas Renewal and Starmark are exclusive products where dealers are regulated by the manufacturer. One important thing to note, is that comapanies that install Renewal windows are NOT owned by Andersen. They are a dealer that exclusively carries that line and meets Andersen requirements, however they are not actually part of Andersen. Price: This again will vary by dealer and area. Renewal has a reputation as having the highest price, using high pressure sales, and also of posting thinly veiled, inaccurate info where THEY talk poorly about competitors (not to say that is the case here, of course). That said, I'm sure that there are some great Renewal operations across the country, just as there great Starmark and Intergity dealers. Ultimately, these are three windows that are solid to excellent, and each have their own pros and cons. You are unlikely to go wrong with any of the three, it really depends on which options most closely aligns with your goals for the project. It sounds like that is the Renewal at this point, I'd only recommend getting the accurate performance information, and then perhaps that would (or not) impact your decision....See MoreBeth H. :
5 years agolast modified: 5 years agosamondragon
5 years agoSimply Great Windows, LLC
5 years agoKWS
5 years agosamondragon
5 years agoSimply Great Windows, LLC
5 years agoWill Rand
5 years agoKWS
5 years agoTherese R
5 years agoSimply Great Windows, LLC
5 years agoSimply Great Windows, LLC
5 years agoKWS
5 years agosamondragon
5 years agoSimply Great Windows, LLC
5 years agosamondragon
5 years agoSimply Great Windows, LLC
5 years agoWill Rand
5 years agoKWS
5 years agoToni McCormick
5 years agoToni McCormick
5 years agoTherese R
5 years agoSimply Great Windows, LLC
5 years agoTherese R
5 years agoTerri Glanger Photography
5 years agoG&F Home Service
5 years agowinston1man
5 years agoHU-516850748
5 years agomillworkman
5 years agoKWS
5 years agofriedajune
5 years agolast modified: 5 years agoKaren
5 years agotoddinmn
5 years agomillworkman
5 years agofriedajune
5 years agolast modified: 5 years agoKaren
5 years agolast modified: 5 years agoKWS
5 years agotoddinmn
5 years agoKWS
5 years agoLaraine
7 months agooberon476
7 months agoKWS
7 months agoLaraine
7 months agoLaraine
7 months agomillworkman
7 months agoLaraine
7 months agomillworkman
7 months agoUser
7 months agoLaraine
7 months ago
Related Stories
ARCHITECTUREWorld of Design: A Tokyo Exhibit Experiments With the Future of ‘Home’
Japan’s architects and housing industry explore new ideas for dwellings that respond to changes in society, tech and the natural world
Full StoryWINDOW TREATMENTSHow to Choose the Right Window Blinds
Get the privacy, light filtering and look you want with this breakdown of blind options
Full StoryHOUZZ TOURSHouzz Tour: Modern Renewal for a Tired Texas Ranch
This major makeover involved additions, layout changes and a new facade. See the stunning results here
Full StoryGREAT HOME PROJECTSUpdate Your Windows for Good Looks, Efficiency and a Better View
Great home project: Replace your windows for enhanced style and function. Learn the types, materials and relative costs here
Full StoryHOUZZ TOURSMy Houzz: From Destruction to Renewal After Hurricane Katrina
After losing almost everything home related, a couple rebounds with a new, contemporary build on the same site
Full StoryGREAT HOME PROJECTSUpgrade Your Windows for Beauty, Comfort and Big Energy Savings
Bid drafts or stuffiness farewell and say hello to lower utility bills with new, energy-efficient windows
Full StoryHEALTHY HOMEBath Design: Renew Body and Mind With Colorful Light
Take one tired, stressed-out self. Rinse in a shower bathed in blue light (or any color you like). Repeat
Full StoryHOUZZ TOURSMy Houzz: Peek Into a Renewed 13th-Century Cave Dwelling in Italy
A life coach mixes styles in her renovated house in Sassi di Matera, a UNESCO World Heritage Site
Full StoryReplace Your Windows and Save Money — a How-to Guide
Reduce drafts to lower heating bills by swapping out old panes for new, in this DIY project for handy homeowners
Full StoryREMODELING GUIDESRenovation Detail: The Casement Window
If heaving open your windows leaves you winded, let the cranks or cam handles of casement windows bring in an easier breeze
Full Story
millworkman