I've never been one for matchy-matchy, be it woods, fabrics, or even clothes. I like similarities in form or texture (the latter I actually prefer very tactile!) or even just style. My dining area table is a solid teak almost Parson's except the legs do taper a tiny bit. It's a darker color. When I had wood cabinets, they were a medium oak. I liked the differences. Oh - my floors are a gorgeous chocolate wide-plank maple. I love the combinations. That said, your cabinets are gorgeous. May I assume you cleaned, stripped & stained? I still have to do my butcher block countertop and haven't decided how to do it. I like a distressed look, but how to achieve it without working on it for 20 years? I love how professionally done your cabinets look.

smallish island...close to table? I am not getting a feel for anything happening style wise with these combinations. I might skip a pendant if it is a small island. Focus on the table then......with canned lights on dimmers above island....do you have some nice detail on the island ? you can dim the cans in the evening for atmosphere. the one table fixture is especially colonial..the other especially Italian. The pendants seem "schoolhouse" vibe. I don't know how you would blend from these selections. I would focus on table area: you may find it easier to find the right selection, without worrying about island area....then go back and see if something crops up by chance for the island, when you look from a different perspective. [it probably will pop out]

Do the island in "Repose" : ) The finish will be different than the rest of the house wall color. Or go peppercorn and darker. Otherwise? II think very pale grayed greens can be a bit dangerous. ....: ) I think your wall color repeated on an island in satin finish? Also very nice.

Coordinating rugs (not identical) under the tables. A runner on the kitchen table that is similar to the fabric on the dining room chairs.