Houzz Logo Print
sushipup1

Amazon Echo advice

8 years ago

I need a new bedroom clock radio. The one I have loses time, and the analog tuning seems to wander, giving a poor signal, so I am always adjusting the tuning.

In real life, I have the local NPR station on all day, never turning the TV on until the evening unless something extraordinary is happening. I have a radio in my office, in the kitchen and upstairs in the bedroom. I have them on from 6 AM until about 5 PM. No music unless we have a party, and I want background music, once or twice a year.

So, what about an Amazon echo instead of the clock radio upstairs? Any real-life experience with this scenario? I don't think I need most/all other functions of the echo, since I am used to using my phone and/or desktop computer to check weather, etc. Or I look out the window. ;-)

Comments (31)

  • 8 years ago

    We have several, used for alarms, music, news, weather, trivia games. My favorite function is bedtime music, usually classical set on a timer.

    sushipup1 thanked terilyn
  • 8 years ago

    I use it like that but it doesn't give you a time of day that you *see*. You'd ask 'her' the time. She does alarms well.

    The Dot version is less money and works fine with "radio" such as NPR. It's not bad for low volume music.

    sushipup1 thanked Ziemia
  • Related Discussions

    Need advice on Eucharis (Amazon Lily)

    Q

    Comments (1)
    I'm trying to give my Eucharis better care this fall and see if I can bloom it. I've been told, by people who actually do it, that if you take proper care of them you can get them to bloom two or even more times a year. What I've been trying to remember to do is water regularly and feed lightly until they bloom, then after they bloom slow down the watering and feeding for a period but not 'til the leaves fall off (that's important, I think--they're supposed to be evergreen.) Until this fall I've given them pretty spotty care and they haven't bloomed. I'll wish us both luck!
    ...See More

    Amazon lily (eucharis) - need advice

    Q

    Comments (2)
    Hi That looks like good advice. I grow them in the shadehouse under the other stuff but have no luck in the yard.. They remain evergreen as it says so reduce but don't stop water . Treating it like the Clivia should be good. Cooler temps would be good also but avoid frost. They seem to bloom after heavy rains without regard to the seasons. at least for me. In your case when new growth started i'd increase the water and light which would probably be easiest in spring?? gary
    ...See More

    Connecting an Echo Dot in the Car w/ FoxFi

    Q

    Comments (6)
    Well I'm having no luck connecting the Dot to my phone's mobile hotspot. I can't follow the directions as written. According to my phone, you can't have wifi and mobile hotspot on at the same time so if you try to turn on mobile hotspot, wifi disconnects. When there is no wifi connection, Dot can't talk to my phone to establish a connection with the mobile hotspot. Apparently others are making it work so I'll chalk it down to user error :(
    ...See More

    Echo PB 2100 blower new carb issue

    Q

    Comments (53)
    no sorry my bad I was just mentioning that I had a similar issue with my old old old Toro mower where by when it got hot if I stopped it and tried to restart it I'd have to wait for it to cool down before it would restart. The dealer let me try a coil that wasn't the issue and I just bought myself a new mower... sorry. Second issue I'm talking about is my string trimmer that seems like when it gets hot it does not run well it becomes difficult to keep. I have a carb that I never put on but it sounded like you were insinuating that perhaps the carb is not the answer it's a coil or some kind of gasket and I have no idea where are the coil or gasket would even be.. I'm not a mechanic... I sort of know enough from this forum to get by and try things and generally they work. it's fine for now I don't want to hijack this guy's question. I will say though the thought of a mulching blower sounds rather enticing!
    ...See More
  • 8 years ago

    I use my Dot as my bedside alarm. It's great for that. I do worry about power outages and wifi outages because the Dot doesn't work during either of those, so if I have a really important alarm, I also set my iPad.

    sushipup1 thanked Fun2BHere
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    If you've looked at the functions and find few would be useful, then maybe you should stick with a conventional clock radio? I've looked at the Amazon and other devices and find little of interest for myself. I think the novelty of talking to it would wear off pretty quickly. I almost never use that capability with devices I already have.

    Android and Apple phones and tablets all allow setting alarms with a vocal command if that's what you want to do. And are much easier and faster to set than using an alarm on a clock radio. Such alarms are reliable and aren't affected by power outages.

    sushipup1 thanked Elmer J Fudd
  • 8 years ago

    Elmer, that may serve as an alarm but not as an all-day radio. I wake up at the same time regardless of alarm, but I want my radio to come on at 630.

  • 8 years ago

    Oh, and the Dot doesn't have a visible clock. I'm not going to wake up in the middle of the night as talk to Alexa and wake up my husband just to see what time it is.

  • 8 years ago

    The Echo "Spot" has a clock face. (It also has a camera you may want to cover.) We are happy with the speakers on our Echo devices.

    sushipup1 thanked maddielee
  • 8 years ago

    Your phone can function as an alarm/radio - there are settings in the various radio/music apps such as Pandora, iHeartRadio, and the Public Radio App. Perhaps those, plus a nice, cheap clock would work for you?

    sushipup1 thanked User
  • 8 years ago

    Why would I want to leave my phone in the bedroom? I don't want my phone on to play the radio all day. How would I charge it as I move around the house?

    Besides, no phones in the bedroom, that's a rule.

  • 8 years ago

    I'm usually up on technology, but the less "internet of things" items I have in the house, the better. A clock radio seems to be the perfect solution to your scenario. My trusty old Sony digital clock radio wakes me up with whatever preset station is set to the alarm time Monday - Friday. I do have the iPad and iPhone upstairs (because my family seems to have forgotten the house phone number) in case of emergency calls at night.

    sushipup1 thanked diane_nj 6b/7a
  • 8 years ago

    Back to the original question, which has nothing to do with cell phones. Has anyone used an Echo device as a bedside clock radio?

    Thanks for all the advice on questions I never had! ;-)

  • 8 years ago

    I have never used an Echo device for anything, and I won't have one in my house. But good luck in your quest. :)

    sushipup1 thanked User
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    My comment was intended to mention simple alternatives with equipment you likely already have, if you wanted a voice activated alarm that was easier to set than a clock radio. Along with having a clock radio for your all day sound.

    Android phones, maybe iPhones too, have a "Do Not Disturb" function that silences all sounds (except an alarm) during the hours you can set. My smartphones is on my nightstand overnight (for my own convenience) and it's completely silent (except for alarms I've set).

    sushipup1 thanked Elmer J Fudd
  • 8 years ago

    As I mentioned upthread, yes, I use my Echo Dot as a bedside alarm clock.

    sushipup1 thanked Fun2BHere
  • 8 years ago

    Back to the original question, which has nothing to do with cell phones.
    Has anyone used an Echo device as a bedside clock radio?

    Yes. As an alarm and radio, but Dot isn't a visual clock, she needs to be asked what time it is, unless you change her name to "Spot", then she'll display the time and weather, but I know you don't want weather, so I think you can remove that skill.

    Looking out the window isn't a good weather forecast. :) It may be sunny right now, but we're expecting heavy rain accompanied by high winds this afternoon, (according to Alexa). :)


    sushipup1 thanked Michael
  • 8 years ago

    Elmer, as I said, I need to replace the current clock radio because of wonky analog tuning, poor sound quality, and poor time keeping (it's a Sony). There is no other equipment that I currently have. I won't use my phone for that purpose, to stay on in the bedroom all day.

  • 8 years ago

    There is another Echo device with a clock face and there is also an adapter for the Dot with a clock face.

  • 8 years ago

    Modern clock radios are much better than the one you apparently have. The one I have is at least 6 years old. It loses 2 minutes per year, but the cool thing is it changes automatically for daylight savings time. Now think about your phone from 6 years ago. Technology is improving everything all the time.

    Not sure why you choose to not use your phone for this. That seems a little eccentric. The phone is perfect for what you want to do and will not drain the battery. I wear wireless Bluetooth headphones connected to the phone, which rides around in my pocket. The phone battery doesn't seem to drain at all. If you want better sound quality than the radio in other rooms you can get relatively inexpensive Bluetooth speakers for that.

    sushipup1 thanked dchall_san_antonio
  • 8 years ago

    I have direct tv which has a nice selection of music options. I have a TV in the living room and bedroom. When I want to hear music I can use those.

    I wanted a clock that was big enough to see at night from the top of my dresser. It is an alarm clock but I use my phone if I need an alarm. I got a nice size atomic clock so I don't have to deal with setting it. It works for me.

    We don't have any of the devices that talk to us other than the one on the phones.

    Good luck with your quest!

    sushipup1 thanked ravencajun Zone 8b TX
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Yikes, I was simply referring to your mobile phone, nothing more. Agree with dchall's comment.

    sushipup1 thanked Elmer J Fudd
  • 8 years ago

    Hmmm, my Sony clock radio is less than 2 yrs old and changes to DST automatically. It still loses time and sounds like crap.

  • 8 years ago

    Why not just get another clock radio that's up to date? You said you don't feel you'd use most of the features of the echo. Like someone mentioned above you can even get yourself a nice speaker so you can hear the radio throughout the house. I'm sorry I don't have any of those amazon devices so I can't tell you much about them. Is there a reason you want the Echo over a clock radio or do you think it seems like a neat device?

    If the Echo has all the features you want and you don't mind paying what they cost go for it. :)

    sushipup1 thanked Hareball
  • 8 years ago

    If I understand correctly, sushipup wants radio in the bedroom. If she used her cell phone then the phone would have to stay in the bedroom.

    sushipup1 thanked moonie_57 (8 NC)
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I was talking only about using the phone for an alarm, nothing else. I must have not explained myself well, I don't get the confusion. Lots and lots of people use their phones for an alarm, it's not like doing so is a burden or impacts daytime use of the phone wherever and whenever.

    sushipup1 thanked Elmer J Fudd
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Our condo BR has an iHome with great sound, but I wanted a little clock radio on my side table. It's only two months old, but it has much better sound than I had expected from something so small -- about a 3" cube. It was about $20 at Target. It's a Capello 'Sleep Easy'. It has battery backup -- 2 AAA's.

    sushipup1 thanked chisue
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    It seems the Spot can keep the clock face lit all the time (don't have one, though).

    I am nearly in the same situation as you though I use a clock to show the time. I use my phone for my alarm (you can use the Dot for this). I use it to listen to the radio. Haven't yet set up talking to others in the house via other Echo devices we have.

    We also have a 'smart' plug and use it to turn on a table top lamp in the room.

    Here's the points about the Spot (a Dot with a screen): from Amazon

    • #Echo Spot is designed to fit anywhere in your home. Use 2nd generation far-field voice recognition to watch video flash briefings, see music lyrics, weather forecasts, to-do and shopping lists, browse and listen to Audible audiobooks, and more. All hands-free—just ask.
    • #Echo Spot connects to Alexa, a cloud-based voice service to play music, read the news, answer questions, set music alarms, control smart home, and more
    • #Just ask to play a song, artist, or genre, and see lyrics with Amazon Music. Also, stream music and books from Pandora, Spotify, TuneIn, iHeartRadio, and Audible.
    • #Use the built-in speaker or connect to speakers through Bluetooth or 3.5 mm stereo cable. With multi-room music, you can play music on your Echo devices in different rooms.
    • #Ask Alexa to turn on your lights, show baby monitors and front door cameras, and lock your doors. Plus, control your thermostats, garage doors, sprinklers, and more.
    • #Call almost anyone hands-free, or make video calls to family and friends with an Echo Spot, Echo Show, or the Alexa App. Instantly connect to other Echo devices around your home.
    sushipup1 thanked Ziemia
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    My old clock radio, sitting on the bedside table, has red numbers, (but doesn't reset for Daylight Saving), I can set it for music or buzzer to wake me (but, being retired, I seldom use that feature).

    There's a bar near the top left that, when I punch it, turns on my choice of radio station ... for an hour. There's a bar near the top right that I can use to turn the radio off at any time.

    And I can choose to turn on the radio for ongoing listening, if I choose.

    Maybe you could find one like it at a garage/yard sale

    Or, maybe, an estate sale?

    At about two bucks (or five?) - one time fee.

    ole joyfuelled ... fuelled also by music, talk radio, news, current affairs

    ... prior to sleep ... when wakeful during the night ... and in the morning

    sushipup1 thanked joyfulguy
  • 8 years ago

    Here's an update. Thanks to all. I only wanted a radio that would go on at a preset time every morning and include a clock. I bought an Echo Spot (the ball-shaped one with a face to it) and spent the afternoon playing with it.

    It goes back to the store tomorrow. Seems that Alexa cna't do two things at once. When I ask it to play the radio, I get a screen with the station name. Ask for the time to show, and the time comes up, but then reverts to the radio station name after maybe 30 seconds. Turn the radio off, and I get the clock. I wanted it to tell the time (without asking every time) and play the radio at the same time. I think I'll look for Chisue's Target bargain radio.

    Maybe Alexa just needs some refinements, maybe in a couple more years.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    After you started this discussion, I read a few reviews of the Spot and there were a bunch of complaints that the alarm feature didn't work. I was thinking about one for myself, but I don't think the devices are quite at the level of functionality and reliability that we need.

    I'm glad you posted about your experience because that result would be a deal killer for me, too.

    sushipup1 thanked Fun2BHere
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I'm not surprised. A lot of gizmos on the market are tech products for people who want "cool" but don't want to spend much time to learn how to use them. Something you talk to that mostly understands but has use limitations fits that description. And of course for someone who wants a clock radio, nothing fills the bill better than a clock radio.

    Apple products are like that in my mind. They convince customers, for example, that iPhones have capabilities Androids don't, which is mostly not the case. But the Kool Aid is drunk all the same.


    Nothing is more slick than Apple's products and they can charge a premium price. It's true that everything works simply and easily right out of the box. So long as you're happy to accept doing things as they think things should be done. Because oftentimes there are no alternatives.

    sushipup1 thanked Elmer J Fudd