I would paint the walls white. Blue and white looks so clean.

I think you need a third color. I’d do grey floor tile, darker grey granite countertop, white cabinet and white walls, chrome hardware and plumbing. The grayness would make a wonderful background for that blue border tile and tub. The white would keep it clean and crisp.

The Corian probably is newer, so if it went in later, it should be able to come out. You might get some samples of plain square tiles from a few places and see if you are lucky and get a good match just in case a tile breaks. Retro-renovation web site sometimes has resources for matching older surfaces should you not be able to find a good color match, but I should think you could get a close match on the white.

Cute bathroom!

https://retrorenovation.com/

I think once you paint the walls and the vanity cabinet white and put in the new floor with blue accents the counter will seem much less of an issue. Get some multi colored blue towels/accessories/art.

Thanks for sharing those photos, Rawket Grl. The tile I'm interested in looks a little like the pattern on the accessories you posted. I think I will go forward with painting the walls and cabinet and changing the floor and then just see how it all looks. I think adding accessories with yellow, gray, or just different blues will help.

jhmarie-- I love Retro Renovation! I've gotten some great ideas for floor tile from that site. You're right, I'm sure I could find replacement 4x4 white tiles if necessary.

Here is the tile I'm interested in:

https://www.overstock.com/Home-Garden/SomerTile-11.75x11.75-inch-Scholar-Blue-Porcelain-Mosaic-Floor-and-Wall-Tile-Case-of-10/10335526/product.html?refccid=THIAMAB5YMLYIZKJAS2DBK7S4Q&searchidx=0&keywords=somertile%20scholar%20blue&refinement=

It looks horrid as it is. It does not look fine. You need to rethink your plans and come up with a new one for that bathroom. The only things that you could possibly decorate around are the floor tiles and the vanity that could be repainted. Everything else must go.

I love the vintage tile. Try to stay true to the period.

Arolik, I ADORE the tile you’re considering. Notice it has grey, your third color.

The vintage blue & white tile is the nicest thing in there; by all means preserve that. White for the walls, I would try to replace the corian countertop, even the color is “off”.

I would leave the counter as is, but stay away from blue walls and would suggest the same color as the creamy/white tiles on both the vanity and walls and change the hardware. Once you have made your other changes, then reconsider if you want to change it (would suggest a professional if you aren't handy). I think once you have added really great floor tiles, the room will all come together and the counter will only add to the look or not even be noticed. You could replace the medicine cabinet per the idea below and add sconces for a nice look.

I'd be curious to see if the wall tile goes all the way around the vanity alcove, behind the medicine cabinet and on the sides of the vanity alcove? Like maybe it was all tiled and there was a pedestal sink originally? Does it look like the side splash material is inset into the tile or on top of it and caulked around the edges? If the vanity, counter, and backsplash is on top of wall tile then you can remove the counter and splashes. It's tedious and you have to be patient and careful, but it's do-able.

If you paint the walls above the tile sand off that bubbly stuff first! I think painting out the darker blue walls above the tlle, like you are planning on doing, would be a step forward.