Can't decide on wood look tile or Luxury vinyl planks for Kitchen!
Jackie Lin
4 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (24)
Related Discussions
Hardwood, Luxury Vinyl Tiles/Planks, or Both?
Comments (12)Yes, I have had three experiences with vinyl plank flooring, as follows: My father installed Konecto in his addition- a woodworking shop, bathroom workout room (with treadmill) and wine cellar (including stairs). The floor has been in for over two years and looks fantastic. Any scratches disappear with the same vinyl spray you use on your car's dashboard. I installed Konecto in the bathroom of my home that has now become a rental. The floor was so uneven that the tile installed, most likely just prior to sale, cracked and the grout fell out within a week of my moving in. Wet towels and puddles of water have sat on the year-old vinyl plank, with no problems. My father owns a working farm that he rents; Allure was installed in the kitchen and held up to the mud-and-gravel-encrusted boots that slog through the kitchen. It has been in for almost a year and looks great. These experiences drew me to vinyl plank flooring in the house I "inherited" when I got married; however, I still researched other options such as hardwoods and laminates. While it is a personal choice, I have found the following in my particular case: The house, in its present condition, needs so much work that we are upside down already (purchased from a family member, you know how it goes...) and have major expenses such as plumbing, electric, flooring and a kitchen- the current kitchen is gutted. For my neighborhood, I will never recoup the costs, even at bargain-basement prices. This is something all remodelers should consider- are you creating a $300,000 home in a $150,000 neighborhood? Also, with the way that folks love to remodel these days and put their own stamp on their homes, who is to say that the next owners won't cover your beautiful hardwoods with carpet? Finally, practicality: we have 2 dogs and 3 cats and plan for children soon. In our shotgun house we don't want to break up the visual aesthetic of openness by having different types of flooring in the living room, dining room, kitchen and bath, we wanted a unified, seamless look For water resistance, vinyl is the way to go. Not to mention the logistics of installation- in our situation the thickness of the vinyl works best with our current flooring/trim combination. If my situation were different, I might choose a different floor, but when looking at the whole picture, vinyl seemed the way to go for us! We also plan on staying here for some time, so resale is less of a concern, but it is in our minds (though I have never bought a house I didn't change, so your potential buyer might too!). If you would like pictures of the three aforementioned vinyl plank "experiences" I can ask family members/tenants to send some. Also, check out your local commercial joints. For example, my grocery store has vinyl plank floors that look great after 5 years of squeaky, wobbly cart wheels running over them. Hope this helps and good luck with your remodel!!...See MoreDelima- luxury vinyl wood or porcelain wood look tile?
Comments (14)I was so set on getting wood look tile until my friends told me to check on Luxury Vinyl, and after doing some reading here on GW, I am almost convinced to switch to LVP/LVT. BUT then I see @Season Contreras's beautiful tiles, I am not so sure again! I like the durability of the tiles and that we can drag furniture on it with no problem of scratching it or damaging it, but then I like the LVP for being warm and not so hard on foot. We are doing about 1000 sqft for kitchen plus family room and entry way, (the rest of the house is carpet for bedrooms and a loft). We have two boys and a dog, a pool right outside the family room, got a big yard with lots of dirt, boys will probably bring some of that in all the time.... Houses in my neighborhood worth about a little over a mil (not ours because we bought it a fixer), they mostly are retired so no little kids running around so they mostly use hardwood or engineered wood. We are in our 40s and plan to retire in this house and not selling anytime soon. What should I use, Wood look tiles or Luxury Vinyl? Thank you for your help!...See MoreHome Depot luxury vinyl planks -- I tested the tiles
Comments (19)Salonva, we have Coretec for a year now in our Florida home. You clean it with water and vinegar. For the most part I spray with just water. We have a dog. No scratches from him, pulling chairs on, dropping something hard etc. It never looks dirty because of the grading, knots etc. I think I look at things a bit differently. Does mine look the same as hard wood that I have up north? No. But it looks nice! Yes there are some fake looking products, but I don’t believe Coretec falls into that category. We chose a beachy/ driftwood look. We were lucky to see this is someone’s home. We were going in a whole other direction! In the kitchen....See MoreEngineered Vinyl Plank (EVP) vs. Luxury Vinyl Plank vs Engineered Hard
Comments (23)@jestermom can you share how much per square foot for the sandhill? Also if you have pics of the samples in your house that would be helpful. I am also wondering if you have any concerns about the "hardness" of the floor. I have been going back an forth trying to pick a floor. I thought I wanted the spc (stone rigid core) to avoid dents from furniture but now I am leaning towards a WPC product for a "softer" and I would hope more "quiet" floor....See MoreOmega flooring LLC
4 years agoDragonfly Tile & Stone Works, Inc.
4 years agoJackie Lin thanked Dragonfly Tile & Stone Works, Inc.Jackie Lin
4 years agoHal Braswell Consulting
4 years agoOmega flooring LLC
4 years agoknockebiz
4 years agowilmathecat
4 years agojkbybl
4 years agojkbybl
4 years agoJackie Lin
4 years agoknockebiz
4 years agoCastle Bespoke Flooring
4 years agoSam Davies
4 years agoknockebiz
4 years agowilmathecat
4 years agoknockebiz
4 years agowilmathecat
4 years agoJackson Dean
3 years agoLynn Precourt
3 years agosilken1
3 years ago
Related Stories

KITCHEN DESIGNKitchen Luxuries: The Wood-Fired Pizza Oven
If you love homemade pizza and are (ahem) rolling in dough, a wood-burning oven may be just the right kitchen investment
Full Story
KITCHEN DESIGNKitchen of the Week: Tile Sets the Tone in a Modern Farmhouse Kitchen
A boldly graphic wall and soft blue cabinets create a colorful focal point in this spacious new Washington, D.C.-area kitchen
Full Story
KITCHEN DESIGNWonderful Wood Countertops for Kitchen and Bath
Yes, you can enjoy beautifully warm wood counters near water sans worry (almost), with the right type of wood and sealer
Full Story
KITCHEN OF THE WEEKKitchen of the Week: Rich Wood, Stone and Rustic Warmth
This kitchen on an alpaca ranch in Washington embraces its rural surroundings — and a decidedly not-white palette
Full Story
KITCHEN DESIGN8 Top Tile Types for Your Kitchen Backsplash
Backsplash designs don't have to be set in stone; glass, mirror and mosaic tiles can create kitchen beauty in a range of styles
Full Story
KITCHEN MAKEOVERSWood Kitchen With a Rustic Feel and Modern Appeal
Custom cabinets and subtly patterned terra-cotta backsplash tiles are part of a new kitchen with old-world warmth
Full Story
KITCHEN DESIGNNew This Week: Rustic Wood Beams Wow in 4 Kitchens
These spaces show how rustic wood beams can bring warmth and character to contemporary spaces
Full Story
MATERIALSWhat to Know About Luxury Vinyl Flooring
The flooring material has become increasingly popular. Here’s how to determine its quality and get it installed
Full Story
KITCHEN DESIGNKitchen of the Week: Turquoise Tile and a Dining Nook for 16
Entertaining is a piece of cake in this remodeled beauty with an extra-large stove and seating for a crowd
Full Story
NEW THIS WEEK12 Kitchens That Wow With Wood Cabinets
Consider one of these dynamic kitchen cabinet designs to add warmth, texture and nuance
Full Story
Jackie LinOriginal Author