Remove the bathroom to fix the floorplan?

6 years ago

last modified: 6 years ago

We bought our 1950's cottage and are trying to figure out how to make the floorplan to as functional as possible. Our issue is with the only bathroom. It juts out between the living and kitchen making for a bit of bottlenecking whenever more than 3 of us are trying to move around the house.

Should we move it to the laundry room and make our space open concept? Or would it be too weird having a full bathroom on the back of the kitchen? Would it be better just to fix up the bathroom and kitchen and leave the placement as is?

Eventually we will add a master bath off our room (taking up some of the back porch) but with kids we'd like to have a second separate bath.

View from the living room to the kitchen

View from the hall to the bathroom

View from the kitchen facing the living room. Sorry about the paint job, I ran out half way through. Thanks for your thoughts!

Featured Answer

PRO

Deb Bayless - Design for Keeps

6 years ago

I agree . . . I would leave the bath where it is. By relocating to the utility area, you only create another bottleneck with everyone trying to get through the kitchen to use the bathroom. Not good. And, yes, a 5'x8' bath is very common and could work well. Try an enameled steel tub (Kaldwei has some narrow versions that are fantastic!) and you'd have 30" for a tub, 30-36" for the toilet and still have a 30-36" vanity. The bath door also looks like it is offset which allows you to have that wall shelf but makes entering the bath claustrophobic. I'd get creative with the vanity area (build a ledge above for supplies or "banjo" countertop). Storage could also go above the toilet (see wall mount bar from CB2) and a train rack for towels can be in the tub area opposite the shower head.

In future, building a master bath using a portion of the back porch would work well, I think.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (10)

katinparadise
6 years ago
I would leave it where it is. It would be really inconvenient to have the bathroom so far from the bedroom. As is, it serves as a guest bath for company and the bath for the bedroom. A standard hall bath is 5x8 so you could gain a couple of feet if you changed it from a 5x10.
eld6161
6 years ago
Take this over to Home Decorating. There is a lot more traffic there.
Related Discussions
Did I break my bathroom? (Floor plan)
Q
Comments (2)
Well, I don't know about better or worse, exactly, but have you considered switching the toilet and shower? If the toilet is against the wall, you can keep your larger window, and then the toilet is only hemmed in on one side, instead of squeezed in between the two fixtures. I've seen other bathrooms here where the vanity ran into a half wall at the shower, which looked fine.
...See More
Basement Renovation: Layout/Floor Plan Needed (Including Bathroom)
Q
Comments (11)
We just finished the layout stage of our basement renovation. Our basement is almost exact the same size as yours so I'm very interested in seeing your progress! We chewed on plans and ideas for more than a year. We only came up with a layout we both feel good with once we finally figured out what we really want to use the basement for and what should be possible in the future. Our house is one bedroom short for our family so we really need a bedroom or sleeping area in the basement. Our house only has one bathroom (one toilet) for 5 people so we need an extra bathroom too. We have an exit to the garden in the basement so we wanted to have some kind of mudroom, laundry and mechanical room needed to stay downstairs too. First we thought of making a bedroom for or oldest son. But the square footage we have to work with is not big and making a bedroom, bathroom, mudroom and mechanical room would divide the space in a lot of little rooms and a hallway which takes in space as well. Furthermore, in this area basements are typically used for recreational functions. So we fear the resale value of our house might decrease with no obvious recreational space down there. We decided to turn the basement into an open concept bedroom/office for ourselves and have the bathroom for ourselves too. This way the basement will be our own little studio, the kids will each have a bedroom and one bathroom upstairs. When the time comes that our kids move out, we can simply take our bed out of the basement and replace it with a couch or two to turn it into a recreation room. I hope this can help in some way! Maybe you too can combine the functions of the rooms you want, like: bathroom/laundry or recreation room/guestroom ? This is roughly the new layout of our basement, the dimensions of stairs and doors are a bit off but you'll get the idea :)
...See More
Ideas for master bathroom floor plan
Q
Comments (30)
@berlinrl, I‘m so glad you reminded me about the elevator... I had it on my list to discuss with the builder today and then forgot all about it! 🤭 The builder showed me an elevator he did for someone else and I told him to copy it. The owner had upgraded the elevator interior to match her foyer... drywall with the wood trim. Just by coincidence, her house was very similar to mine. I hadn’t thought about the wheelchair bumping into walls then. The elevator is not installed yet, so I can still make a change. BTW, the owner of the house was so gracious and her house was so beautiful. We’ve since become very good friends! In our first floor study bath, we put shiplap on the wall behind the pedestal sink and toilet— it goes up to about 5 feet.. It was installed when I went to the house today! Today, we decided to shiplap the opposite wall 3’ high, to deal with the wheelchair. In the master bath, we decided to add extra trim - in addition to the normal baseboard. Next time I go to the house, if it’s done, I’ll take photos and post them. Have you had any problems with the wheelchair on wood floors. My DH got a motorized wheelchair — it repositions him etc — allows him to stand in it. It weighs a lot (at least 200 pounds) and he weighs a lot. He’ll only use it on the main floor (the elevator has a 500 pound limit and I don’t want to get near the limit). I’m thinking of engineered 7” white oak. .. I liked one product from a local mill that would be finished by my builder on site and one floor that is pre-finished by Shaw. The Shaw Floor has an aluminum oxide top coat. The flooring consultant was concerned about putting that much weight on the Shaw floor and was concerned about the finish holding up. She told me she contacted Shaw to see if they would stand behind their product for such use. I understand it is really a problem to re-finish a floor with an aluminum oxide top coat. If I get the locally milled floors and have the builder put a strong Bona finish on them, I guess they can be sanded and refinished if they get scratched up.
...See More
Bathroom Floor Plan Help!
Q
Comments (26)
Just a suggestion for re-arranging so you have a full wall in the dining that is not broken up by the entry into a bedroom. You can have the entry from the mudroom or from across the peninsula. I'd also consider moving the door for the master down more towards the corner for more privacy from the living room. The other thing I would consider for your kitchen is an island to create a walkway from the mudroom into the house so people doesn't spread into the kitchen and then remove the peninsula part. You'll get more use out of your cabinets this way too and it will feel less tight against the dining room.
...See More
auntthelma
6 years ago
Kind of radical - but if you switch the M Bedroom with the living room, you could have kitchen/living in the back of the house and bedrooms in the front.

That means turning a window into a front door and taking out at least part of the wall where the kitchen table is.

Just a suggestion to get you thinking.

As it stands, I think I would leave the bathroom where it is and simple have a separate kitchen. You can make the kitchen more social if you replace the table with an island you and your family can sit at. But that leaves you with no dining table.
Judy Mishkin
6 years ago
i had the same thought as auntthelma, switch the master bedroom and living room and go from there. you will improve your kitchen to living room floor plan immensely.

give it a couple minutes thought.
whatevermannn
6 years ago
I agree auntthelma. Matter of fact, close off kitchen from the entire bedroom suites.
Maria Privat
6 years ago
Hey Bella, you put up kind of the same post? Fun to read that you get the same suggestions all over again: switching the family room with the master bedroom... Three more people see it as an option now.

But we still do not know if that can be an option for the way your house is situated.
caroline94535
6 years ago
If you switch the LR and MBR locations, turn one of the “Now BR” windows into the new front door, and close off the bottle neck between the kitchen and hallway...

Would you really want to shorten the bathroom to 5x8?

Switching the two rooms will eliminate the bottleneck, and most everyone (that I know) would love to have any measurable extra space in the bathroom.

I love your floors, doors, and “feel” of your house! How many munchkins do you have?
writersblock (9b/10a)
6 years ago
I would leave it alone.
Quinn Eskimo
6 years ago
Another idea - if you plan a remodel in the future that moves some of your master into the back porch, you could also "flip" the existing bathroom to the other side of the house, where your master closet is now. The bathroom would be between the two bedrooms, your living room and/or kitchen would gain some extra space, and your house would be more "open concept" as you mentioned. I wouldn't consider it until you do the other remodel, though, because you'll lose some space in your master (as well as losing your closet, of course).

Remove the bathroom to fix the floorplan?

Deb Bayless - Design for Keeps

Comments (10)

katinparadise

eld6161

Related Discussions

auntthelma

Judy Mishkin

whatevermannn

Maria Privat

caroline94535

writersblock (9b/10a)

Quinn Eskimo

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US