Lovely apartment with beautiful arts and crafts style details. If budget is not an issue and you want something consistent with the style of the apartment, I would take a look at the Stickley website for furnishings and rugs. They have some beautiful things but they are not inexpensive. You could purchase a few stand out pieces, such as case goods and rugs, to give more contemporary upholstered pieces a bit of arts and crafts style.

If budget is no concern, I would hire a professional designer to help assemble pieces that are worthy of that incredible space.

mild boho allows for a lot of flexibility, both in style and color.

Hire a designer. And buy things you would love in any home. Decorating for just one place is very wasteful.

Wow, what a great space! Personally, I like a mix of simple antiques and modern, but as the pictures above show, you can take quite a few directions.

I don't think that's a Craftsman house, though I can understand why one would think so. Those columns are Neoclassical; Craftsman columns tended to be square or angled. My guess? Edwardian, Italian Renaissance Revival style, circa 1910. I know, very precise guess, but it looks a lot like my house would have before the woodwork was painted. (I would love to see an exterior pic to see if my guess is in the ballpark).

I do think you have a lot of flexibility in the interior. Craftsman furnishing would look good and are appropriate to the era of the house (even if the house isn't Craftsman). Probably any period-appropriate furniture would look great. But I think it could look good with other styles as well (like the pic above of the kids at the dining table, with mid-century modern elements). I think it would look fine with contemporary furniture (say, Pottery Barn), but I don't think it would show off the apartment to its best potential.

What a wonderful place to rent. May I add in addition to the furniture/rug suggestions: lots of green plants! I am horrible at indoor plant maintenance, but if you are good at it, it would be nice here. Portable and inexpensive too!

I also second the idea of modern with simple antique.

Please post pictures when done (well, we are never really done are we? Okay when you get a reasonable amount finished!).

Wow, that is one gorgeous apartment! Congratulations.

I love the photos above, but I would suggest that you stay AWAY from wide striped, herringbone patterned rugs. It fights with the ceiling beams. And the looks are 2 different.

so lets get the party started! rugs rugs rugs rugs....

5 x 8 Rugs : Outdoor & Oushak Rugs at Neiman Marcus Horchow · More Info

Just to confuse you , I will add a contrasting opinion about the stripe and herringbone rugs :)

I like the visual weight of strong, more modern rugs because I feel they balance the visual weight of the beams. I also like them because they look fresh and not expected. I think you have to have some respect for the room's architecture but I don't think it has to dictate all your choices.

i just don't want any more trellis, done way too much.