skip to main content

Home Decorating

Identical home decor fabrics, different prices?

6 years ago

I've noticed that some fabrics from different brands seem to be identical except for the color schemes. One brand is more expensive than the other. Is the cheaper one a copycat, or is the more expensive one just charging more? Who actually makes the fabric? Are these brands just putting their name on something made by a different company entirely?

Examples:

Stout Wyoming and Richloom Prescott

Fabricut Astern and Mill Creek Quintell

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (5)

palimpsest
6 years ago
Yes some fabrics are exclusive to the brand and some are not. Some fabrics are made by a mill and purchased by several companies and branded under them.
pippiep thanked palimpsest
pippiep
Original Author
6 years ago
Thanks! So all is not lost if I fall for a more expensive or discontinued fabric... I might be able to still find it under another name.
Related Discussions
'Perfectly' decorated Home verses a Perfect Home for your Family?
Q
Comments (66)
I've enjoyed this thread so much. (Well, except for all those 'annoying' football comments. I mean really, let's get the over hyped Super Bowl out of the way so we can get on to the real sport...BASEBALL! Go Rangers! lol Auntjen, we are neighbors as I, too, live in the same county as Jerry World.) ahem...back to decorating. I'm a new real estate agent and one of my fascinations is seeing the inside of people's homes. I held an open house this weekend at a charming home. Talk about beautifully decorated! I so wish I could have taken photos just to show you guys the decor. (The RE photos don't show the decor like I'd like to show y'all.) After two hours of 'living' in the home, I was ready to go back to my more rumpled and comfortable home. lol I know the owners have 'staged' the home to be very, very nice looking and they are getting the right kinds of comments. I just know that for me and mine...we go for that 'creative' look. lol My goal, an ongoing, ever-ellusive goal, is to create a warm, inviting, and comfortable place to live that still delights my eye and artistic sense. That's possible, not perfect...and when it comes together, it is PERFECT. ;0)
...See More
San Francisco Decorator Showcase: "think different"
Q
Comments (27)
I think there are many interesting ideas in the house. Not many I'd want to recreate but it's fun to see them. It's not really done for everyday living but for impact. How much is changed after the show? I wonder if all the black of the kitchen would feel oppressive while making meals? It's so heavy and depressing to me. I think it would bother me to be surrounded by it, day in and day out, three meals (plus snacks!) a day. And that white floor would be a nightmare to keep clean looking, even if the kitchen was mostly a showpiece and not used much. But I'm a shoes on person. And I do cook and make messes. And my husband isn't the tidiest guy in the world. I didn't care for the subject but I thought the art piece following the stairs was great. What a clever way to deal with art on the stairs. I also liked the other hallway art installations. I, also, thought the chain mail thing was starched gauzy fabric. Truthfully, my first thought was a line from an old Monty Python movie "bring out your dead." It looks like a funeral shroud to me. It would be fun to own and rearrange if it were colorful chain mail.
...See More
Home Decor Auction Items on ebay - Shill Bidding
Q
Comments (41)
nosoccermom, that's kind of a tough one. If the item is unique and you can't buy it elsewhere, you could try contacting the seller and asking for a Buy It Now price. (You're sure it's not that they are just relisting an identical item, right?) Hard to know how they will react but I don't see what it could hurt. I would write the request carefully so they can't really tell if you're accusing them of shill bidding or not; if they think you are going to report them, they'll probably just block you immediately and move on. How is the rest of their feedback? Sometimes you can look at the detailed feedback other buyers have left to figure out if the seller is above board, or not well behaved. If they react negatively (or if you find bad things in their feedback) and you decide it's a lost cause, then I'd probably contact eBay and report the practice. As far as I know eBay still does not look kindly on this practice at all. However, I don't think there is really a way to force the seller to act like he should (to make sure you can buy the item.)
...See More
Mixing different decorating styles in a house
Q
Comments (22)
One possibility would be to exchange the red for a soft coral tending toward faded red...or if you like, a subtle lavender like the fields below Le Baux. I think one way to get the blend you are after is to take the traditional French colors of red, blue, and yellow, and then use paler, sunbleached versions of them. Go further south in France, and think of the Cote d'Azure. Find a big reproduction of one of those fabulous travel posters from the '30s advertising Cannes or St. Tropez and put it in your red (or whatever you decide on) room, to signal your French coastal flavor. What you really need to do is take three or four weeks off, rent a nice little car in Avignon, and head out to St. Remy, along the valley south of the Luberon through Lambesc and down to Aix en Provence, west and north through Dreaguignan to the perfume centers in Grasse, back down to the coast at Cannes, east along the Corniche through Frejus and through St. Tropez to Toulon; pause to get your breath for a few days, and on to the train station at Marseilles where you will board the TGV to Paris. When can we leave???
...See More
One Devoted Dame
6 years ago
As I understand it, fabric manufacturers have different qualities of base fabric. Same prints, same designers, but different quality bases for different price points. Expect to pay more for higher quality weave, threads, etc.

My experience is with quilting and garment fabrics, but I don't think the rules change for home decor fabric. You can tell the difference in quality by how the material looks and feels. The good stuff has a nicer hand, and a tighter weave so that when held up to light, less light comes through the fibers. Color ranges/spectrums (dots representing the different hues used for the print), found on the unprinted edge of the fabric on the bolt, are also longer in higher quality fabric.

The seller of the fabric is an important gauge in determining quality... Bargain bin places that charge $5/yard will not generally have the quality that a source selling $50/yard fabric will have.

If I am mistaken, someone out there PLEASE correct me! lol
pippiep thanked One Devoted Dame
pippiep
Original Author
6 years ago
I wonder if they are different quality if the fabric content is the same?

There is a $5.99 store nearby, but their fabrics seem to be slightly imperfect. I used some fabric where the circles on the selvage showed that it was printed off register, but I couldn't tell from looking at the fabric pattern itself.

I don't think the less expensive brands like Richloom and Mill Creek are cheaper-feeling fabrics. I think the two examples in my original post are truly identical, even by weave.

There are a few cheaper brands that I don't like the feel of, though! Every sample I've gotten from those brands feel terrible to me and I've been avoiding using those fabrics.

I'm starting to think about re-upholstering some things in my house. I've never done it before, but it looks like something I'd really enjoy.
One Devoted Dame
6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago
I wonder if they are different quality if the fabric content is the same?

Yes, the quality can be different, even if the content (cotton, silk, wool, poly, flax, blend, etc.) is the same. If you really want to go down a rabbit hole, lol, google "greige goods fabric quality" and you'll discover a lot.

A note on brands... Wal-mart can sell a certain fabric, and a quilt store can sell the exact brand, exact print, exact designer, but the quality (and price) is obviously different. It's the difference in the run of greige goods used. The company sells the lower quality to discount retailers, and the higher quality to boutique stores.

If you don't intend to make an heirloom that lasts several generations, or if you plan to reupholster regularly, then I think you'll be fine with carefully-selected bargain fabrics. :-)
pippiep thanked One Devoted Dame

Related Stories

WORLD OF DESIGN Meet the Aboriginal Women Forging a New Design Identity for Australia

By Susan Redman

Australia’s indigenous designers are introducing traditional motifs into contemporary lighting, textiles, furniture and ceramics

DECORATING GUIDES Architectural Details Make All the Difference

By Janell Beals - House of Fifty

Are you missing an opportunity to enhance your home with brackets, cabinet feet and moldings?

WALL TREATMENTS Fabric: The Unsung Wall-Decorating Hero

By Becky Dietrich, Interior Designer

Rich, unexpected and full of stories, textiles as wall art are a wonderful addition to a design toolbox

ARCHITECTURE Modern or Contemporary: What's the Difference?

10 homes illustrate the essence of modern and contemporary home design styles

DECORATING GUIDES Staging vs. Decorating: What's the Difference?

By Kristie Barnett, The Decorologist

Unlike decorating, staging your home isn't about personal style — it's about creating ambiance and appeal for buyers

UPHOLSTERY Fabric Focus: 6 Ways to Bring Ticking Stripe Fabric Home

By Karen Egly-Thompson

From window treatments to upholstery and more, here are ways you can decorate with this decorative workhorse of a fabric

REMODELING GUIDES Carrara vs. Calacatta Marble: What Is the Difference?

By Debbie Snider

The answer is in the color and veining of these popular Italian marbles

UPHOLSTERY Fabric Focus: Make Your Interiors More Durable With Outdoor Fabric

By Karen Egly-Thompson

Indoor-outdoor fabric is strong and beautiful, whether in the backyard or the living room

RUGS Kilim, Flokati, Beni Ourain, Boucherouite: What’s the Difference?

By Laura Gaskill

Get the global story you want for your floors by learning the origins and characteristics of rugs from around the world

COLORFUL HOMES Houzz Tour: A Home of a Different Color

By Mary Jo Bowling

An interior designer infuses a Colorado home with daring and drama

More Discussions

HOUSE TOUR: Rose is on Tap in this Beautiful Atlanta Bungalow

10

Wanted! Design guidance for projects, inside and out!

93

Please help me optimize my living room!

25

Guest room sheets - what would you choose?

21

Crown moulding for bedroom

1