Yes, #3.

Go with the lightest one.....it will darken overtime. Keep your home light.

I like it

#3

I like #2 and #3

I like all of them EXCEPT #1. Given what you say you like, #3 seems like a great choice.

Great choice. Trust your gut.

Agree with 3 as well.

All except #1, it has too much red in it. I actually prefer #4 the best. A true brown, but I like darker floors.

I like #4 but my monitor is making 3 read a little pinkish.

#3!!!!

I like #3. Looks like a good choice for a more neutral, not too dark floor.

I like 2 or 3. Is your unstained flooring red or white oak?

Best choice, go for it.

I like #1 the best.

I like 1 the best. Is your woodwork stained or painted? If stained, you need to coordinate/match the flooring to it.

Thanks everyone, we're going to go with #3. The floors are red oak. Rest of woodwork is painted.

I hope you'll post after pics. Would love to see how your floors came out. :-)

Just make sure they mix it exactly if it's red oak since the red in the red oak will tend to bring out any pink tones present. Doesn't look like you have anything to worry about in the stains chosen.

4 best 3 next according to your numbers .

Your floors are beautiful! (And so are your other finishes)

Stunning! You must be so happy.

Looks great with your cabinets and counter!

Really nice!

Your floors came out gorgeous.

Looks beautiful! We chose that same shade of color for our hardwood a couple of years back and I love it!