In SW florida with bronze trim and a deep blue pool...how would you feel about a light blue house with tan doors and tan shingles? I would also remove the shutters, which are too small for the window, and do wider trim around the window instead. This is about the color of blue I'm thinking. Or cream stucco could be really nice as well with tan doors and would look great with the blue at the back (I know this likely is NOT florida based on the cacti!). You could restain your driveway a bit warmer to work with the cream. Blue stucco with tan and white accents (on a very elaborate house)

Still no definitive answer on the house color. I've been playing around with an online color program and have been able to eliminate some colors. Grays don't look right, Darker Tans and Dark Beiges blend too much with the roof. Blues didn't look right. Not going with stone, but shutters are an option. What is the opinion on this option? Kilim Beige Exterior, Alabaster Trim and Shutters in a shade of blue (Slate Tile pictured)? Open to different shutter colors too (seal skin, . Am I on the right track?? ANOTHER option that I just put together is Downing Straw, Alabaster Trim with Studio Blue Green Shutters (or a similar look). Only problems I see with going this route is the house diagonal from us is very similar to this color (minus the shutters) and husband is saying no to yellow again (2 of our previous houses were yellow).

You need to consider the roof color, and neither of those are working with it for me. If you want to keep the white trim, maybe a light tan/beige siding to provide some contrast. Another option is a soft white for the entire exterior that can be nice with your home's style and roof color.

I am not sure of color but that awning needs to go use solar shades for light and heat control, what are all those wires around that window? IMO gray and Florida do not work in my head . Why not just match the white from the new gables and then please do some landscaping to bring this house to life . I would use this for inspiration since the front of the home is very MCM frond oor and garage door would be abig improvement too.Similar to the pic.