bathroom counter - undermount sink?

7 years ago

For our new build we can get formica counters with drop in sinks. OR we can pay $1600 more (for all the bathrooms combined) to get solid surface counters.

I really wanted to not have a lip around the sink edge for crud to catch but I don't know if I want it for $1600. Do they make undermount sinks for the bathroom that work with a formica counter?

Featured Answer

wilson853

7 years ago

I recommend going with a granite, as it holds up better against cosmetics, nail polish remover, acne medicines, hot flat irons, etc. You can't always depend on children/teens to be careful.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (17)

zorroslw1
7 years ago
My advice is to get the solid surface with the under mount like you want or you will kick yourself later. Ask me how I know...........
tammyte
Original Author
7 years ago
LOL Yeah, if there's no other option I will do it. But if there is a cheaper way to make it work .... :)
Related Discussions
Undermount Bathroom Sinks - What size are your sinks?
Q
Comments (13)
We are doing an 88 inch double vanity with towers (the towers are 14" wide and 9" deep). Our two oval undermount sinks are the Kohler Verticyl 17 x 14 which is the same size as the mid-size Caxton. I think that should be enough elbow room both between the sinks and on the outer ends. By the way, has anyone used any of the Verticyl sinks, either oval, round or rectangle? They are straight-sided and flat-bottomed. I worry a bit about how well the water will drain but they are so sharp looking......
...See More
Vanity top help!! Vessel, counter+undermount sink, all in one?
Q
Comments (5)
I haven't bought it yet (the bathroom is just gutted at the moment), so I can't comment on quality. It says it is tempered glass though, so it should be pretty tough, and I think Pegasus is a reasonable brand overall. I have seen it at Expo (by the way, it was cheaper at Expo than at Home Depot!) and it looked solid enough. There are also some similar tops at this webpage, but they are wider. I just found this by googling though, and have never heard of this site before so I dont know anything about their quality. Here is a link that might be useful: more integral sinks
...See More
undermount bathroom sink gap
Q
Comments (6)
The problem is that the sink has an eased inside edge and not perfectly angled flat to fit against the underside of the stone. The fabricator should have cut the sink hole larger, to give more of a reveal of the sink edge, so that it contacted the stone where it is flat. This could be exacerbated by it not being a true undermount sink that is attempting to be undermounted. Or, it could be a hand made sink that isn't flat and can't be properly mounted without a gap. It's difficult to say exactly without viewing the installation in person.
...See More
Kohler Verticyl Oval under-mount bathroom sink
Q
Comments (6)
Thanks Jules8 for your feedback. I'm not too picky about spotting. This will be a bathroom used daily. I am glad to hear that there isn't splashing. I will be using a single hole Hansgrohe faucet. Thanks for the info about the slope, and as you've indicated it seems too shallow. I have a limited space for the sink in my vanity and this one provides a lot of interior space within the confines of my cabinet. If I decide to get another sink I will have to call the cabinet maker to double check the tolerance I have. The look of this sink is really nice though and I probably will stay with it.
...See More
mrspete
7 years ago
No, Formica and undermount don't go together. Why? Because Formica looks like plywood on the inside, and it'd show once the sink was installed.

Keep looking. Unless your sink is quite large, I think you can do better.

If you really want your sink to be easy to clean, look into a molded solid surface countertop -- it's all one piece, and it's the easiest possible item to clean. I have it all my bathrooms -- original to the house, which was built in 1973, and they're all in perfect condition. I hate that they're so shallow that they splash the user, but that's a different story.
tammyte
Original Author
7 years ago
The only solid piece counter he has available is "marbled granite" which is the $1600 upgrade.

Another note: In my kitchen it was going to be $5000 or so to upgrade from formica to solid surface. He said he could do an undermount stainless steel sink with the formica for about $400. So will that not work either? He said he has done it before but I have never seen it.
mrspete
7 years ago
Here's an undermount sink -- note that you can see the edge of the granite around the sink:

This is a piece of laminate:
Maybe I'm missing something, but it seems that the plywood-inside stuff would show around the edge of the sink.
tammyte
Original Author
7 years ago
http://www.formica.com/en/us/homeowner-knowledge/kitchen/kitchen-things-to-know/laminate-countertops-love-undermount-sinks

Here's what the formica website says about it.

I don't know what brand of sink he is planning to use. He says he has done it before but of course I don't know how well it's held up. ugh.
lookintomyeyes83
7 years ago
they've been making undermountable laminate counters for awhile now that don't show the particleboard...id look into that as a 3rd option (check w/your laminate co's). That said, solid surface counters are awesome.

not a fan of undermount tho - they get a grunge lip too, its just harder to see/clean compared to drop-in.
tammyte thanked lookintomyeyes83
cpartist
7 years ago
last modified: 7 years ago
I don't know how wide your vanity is but have you looked into Kohler Impressions vanity tops? I've seen them in person and they really are beautiful. They come in different sizes too and when you consider it's all in one, it's still cheaper than a separate sink and countertop..

Kohler Impressions

Another solution would be to do a vessel sink instead of an undermount.
whaas_5a
7 years ago
How many bathrooms do you have and how large are they? $1600 is a pretty steep upgrade to go to solid surface for just the bathrooms.

The integrated solid surface and stainless steel sinks with laminate can eliminate the gap painpoint and keep you on budget. I'v seen these holding up in commercial applications for at least 7 years now.

http://karran.com/images/pdf/Gallery.pdf
User
7 years ago
The new p lam details are impressive but it makes me cringe to think of using them as a substitute for granite. Look at the other p lam options for a more elegant design.
chellefnp
7 years ago
We went with a pre-fab granite/undermount sink topper that we got at a local building supply store. We did 5 vanities (3 48", 3 36") for under $1000. I have always had laminate topped vanities with drop in sinks, so hard to clean. I will never go back--love the undermount sinks.
tammyte
Original Author
7 years ago
We have three bathrooms. Master has about 9' of counter with one sink, hall bath has two 5' counters, one with a sink. Then another 2' wide counter with a sink. Powder room has a 3' counter with sink.

This is through a mod home builder so I'm not sure if I have other options. I wonder if I should just go with the basic counter with drop in and replace later as we can. Of course then, it will probably never get replaced....sigh.
cpartist
7 years ago
What if you purchase your own vessel sinks and do the formica?
tammyte thanked cpartist
tammyte
Original Author
7 years ago
I need to check with the builder and see if we can get them with no sink. Then there might be issues with plumbing and such. I don't know. Also not sure if husband wants to mess with it. I think he would be capable though.
tammyte
Original Author
7 years ago
true
autumn.4
7 years ago
If your sizes are 'standard' you should be able to do a lot better with the prefab that chellefnp shows above. We used one in our last house bath remodel and I really liked it. It would be worth asking the builder if your could supply your own sink/counter for the baths.
tammyte thanked autumn.4