Have you looked at Alabaster? Different rooms are going to show differently with lighting by day then by night. Best thing to do is select a couple of the colors you favor and get a couple of poster board cut in to 4's and leave the outer edge of the poster board white so your eyes don't play tricks on you. That is really the only way you will know if it turns green, blue or other in your particular space. I do love Shoji White. Shoji White is the perfect warm white with a gray undertone; it looks beautiful with wood or metal finishes. Yet, you need to see how it looks in your space even though it's under construction. If you have lighting in then you can see your picks placed on a few different walls so you know they don't change AM to PM lights on and off. Modern Gray is very pretty and if you find it a hint too dark given SW sells larger sample cans you can have them lighten it 25% (25% will be a very, very little bit lighter or you can do 50%) after testing it by taking the can back to them and telling them to lighten it. Concerned it might be cold, but do love the color. If you google Modern Gray by SW you will see it changes a lot in different rooms.

You all were SO helpful, and I deeply appreciate all of your comments and suggestions! I wanted to update in case there were others struggling as much as I did with color choices. The downstairs is painted. I still see a tiny hint of pink/taupe undertone but the trim really keeps it from being too much, so I’m keeping it. It is truly beautiful with the trim. SW Natural Linen on walls and SW Alabaster on trim. It totally brightened it up and looks so clean and crisp, open, airy, and beautiful. This is all natural lighting, I will be changing my bulbs to a lighter warm soon. Again, thank you all!! I love Houzz!!

You are on the right track as far as pulling a color from the brick for the front door area. Use the same color on the garage doors. While you will need to sample, I think you're going to find the best color to be the color of your siding. The front door is perfect. The shutters would look good in a sage green similar to the color shown in the picture Patricia posted. You could probably go darker if you like a darker color. We used BM Nantucket Gray on our previous house. It is more green than gray, contrary to the name, and also looks more green than the blob below. Sunlight brighens up colors on exteriors. Also look at SW Evergreen Fog which is very popular.

found a color combo that should work w/your brick. also added some other elements. I don't think you realize how much of a difference garage doors would make. before replacing, try painting it and adding windows/hardware Ignore these colors. Just look at the door style At the very least, I'd look into adding a row of windows, like this, and maybe some carriage hardware two diff garage doors w/carriage hardware. diff address signs, Here is a similar garage door to yours painted a darker color. you can see how they combined the dark trim w/the darker tan colors. do you like that look? This garge door actually looks like the color Anonymous These 3 could work Or, maybe this combo? I actually like the Rojo Marron color for an accent. maybe the front door? Cultured Pearl is a white that leans on the red side which will go well w/your brick. Try it or some of the other whites I listed below. some whites and lighter greiges