Are you committed to 2 Pendants? I would probably do a greater number of micro/mini pendants bunched together over the center of the island. I think this would make it less obvious that the Island and range don't line up.

Something like this is what I mean by many small pendants close together http://www.potterybarn.com/m/products/rustic-glass-multi-cluster-pendant/?pkey=e%7Cpendant%7C148%7Cbest%7C0%7C1%7C15%7C%7C2&cm_src=PRODUCTSEARCH

I would do either a single statement light that is elongated and has a multitude of clear glass balls/bells/etc, so that it fades into the back ground.

Or (and this is what I would do) you could still just do two pendants and make them really stand out so that they are the focus and not the stove. Your stove hood looks to be plain and blending in with everything (unless something is changing?) so I think you could get away with it.

Here is an example https://www.decorpad.com/photo.htm?photoId=112439

Agree with above. Really attention seeking pendants to rule the show. Or, nothing and just small, bright, can task lights. If I were to go with can lights, I would paint the hood something spectacular. If statement pendants, keep the hood the same as all the other cabinets. We have an uncentered island with 3 pendants, but the whole kitchen - while balanced - is not symmetrical. It works for us. Some of the decision will depend on your need for symmetry.

First it is going to be a beautiful kitchen. Symmetry is absolutely not essential to a well functioning and attractive kitchen. In fact strict adherence to symmetry often leads to a less functional kitchen.

The island is large and the ceiling is high. I like huntingflowers idea of a large single fixture with many bulbs.

Something like this fixture:

Golf Club Renovation · More Info

Do a google search for "linear chandelier"

didn't want to suggest anything particular, b/c I don't know what kind of finish you are going with.

You can still do a pendant/drum light in your dining area.

Thanks everyone for your advice... Was really freaking out about this. I like the idea of statement pendants

Honestly, I don't think anyone will notice that it's off center. Frankly, I'm going to have the same problem in my kitchen and I'm not worrying about it at all.

Agree, I think with the statement lights it will look great, especially since your hood is white and will fade into the background. Or an elongated light like http://www.circalighting.com/linear-branched-chandelier-sl5863/ or the linear Darlana would be awesome!

What did you go with? I found this searching the same question!!