Most successful try at Live oak in zone 6 Pa
poaky1
8 years ago
Featured Answer
Comments (488)
miketropic
7 years agojoeinmo 6b-7a
7 years agolast modified: 7 years agoRelated Discussions
Number 3 Thread- Most successful try @ Live oak
Comments (138)Yeah Joe, I hope that it isn't like last winter, but I did plant a Hybrid of Q. V and Overcup oak near the "late drop" live oak that came up from the roots after last years Real, we'll say WITCH of a winter. I don't want to move it in case the "late drop" dies, but, I want that Hybrid (Compton's oak) to establish there if the "late drop" will not make it in the long run. The "late drop" has several trunks now, but, I don't want to make just one, in case a couple die back this winter, I want the tree to have "options" in a bad situation, I know sounds dumb, but, you know what I mean. If the "late drop" does well this winter, I will still keep the "Compton's oak" where it is. I think the Live Oak "L.D." would possibly croak, at least the top again. But it may increase in hardiness instead, not likely but possible. If the top dies back again, I am done hoping. I know unless it puts out some vigorous growth, the Compton's will overgrow it, and shade it quickly. As far as the L.O. from you Joe, it looks nice and green still. I have stuck a Sycamore seed ball near it, in case it gets frozen to oblivion. I hope that it gets a chance to grow some, and does well this year, though. If so, the Sycamore babies will die easy from some roundup or whatever. I chose Sycamore cause if I can't have Live oak the Sycamore colors will match the tan and brown brick of the house, love the bark also. I am hoping the live oak does well mostly though. The house is about 35 ft from the Live oak, providing some extra warmth, even if it's a few degrees. WE had about 38 F today, but the last 4-5 days, it's been 20's and 30's. Today would have been warmish, if not for the wind. Okay for now. Poaky1...See MoreAnyone in zone 6 having success with Holm oak?
Comments (3)As I posted earlier I don't think this will survive long term for you. The coldest parts of their native range are zn 8; some clones could possibly make it in zn 7. But not in zn 6 when you actually have a zn 6 winter up there. Which can easily go to -10F, rarely to -15F or even lower. I bet the record lows in most of NE PA are Of course if they are acorns from cultivated trees they could always be hybrids. I happened to be looking through my old pictures from trips to the UK and found this scan. Holm Oak tree in a courtyard at St. Andrews, Scotland, 1996. They are very dark. This post was edited by davidrt28 on Wed, May 8, 13 at 23:36...See MoreNUMBER 2- Most successful try @ Live oak_poaky
Comments (85)Hi Poaky, The mac's I grew were all from river basin origin and do very well in all ranges of soil. It's easy for me to remember because I grew only (2) types: one a big & round acorn, and the other an egg-shaped & very large acorn. If you sift thru the soil you should be able to find which of the types you have. As to suckering, no worries. Just remove any lower growth spurts from the trunk as the graft scion matures. I see growth from the wood at the base of seedlings but never from below the soil. If you do see any from below the soil, remove them and soon enough you'll not deal with those anymore. You guys are talking about black root emergence and slow germination. No need be concerned. The root will regenerate (actually a more fibrous set of roots) as a result. I sowed 1000+ seeds this winter and maybe 1%-2% are up. Just wait before you throw in the towel. Dax Photo of large-round mac's;...See MoreZone 6b SE PA north facing front porch, red clay soil - help please
Comments (6)Thanks for the replies, everyone. I should have included a bit of back information that would better give orientation about my overall objectives. This first year or two, my main objective is to define the borders of the porch for my two large dogs. Until now, we had a pad and grass up to the pad (pad is the same pre- and post- porch construction) and they could exit the pad anywhere. Now, I want them to get used to exiting the pad onto the sidewalk in the center, because elsewhere will now be beds (and mud and mess and plants to be stomped). That's why I've bombed the front with the cinnamon ferns, to make a sort of visual railing while the dogs re-learn their exit, and while the beds age in with better soil and I get some other plants going (hostas, etc.). For the first year or two. It will be no problem to move the ferns around the corner when that time comes. I've always wanted a mass of ferns on this eastern facing side: My second objective is to create a streamlined mow line. The grass is maintained with a 60 inch deck mower so whatever bed edge I develop needs to allow the mower to move along it easily (I guess rather than undulating what I was trying to get to was smooth curves rather than corners, for mowing purposes). Third objective is LEAST maintenance from a hand weeding perspective. I know it won't be zero, but I'd like to have it controllable without being consuming. Fourth objective is "pretty." I'm not bothered with "curb appeal" in general as the only viewers are anyone coming up the driveway; this is not seen from the street. Eventually, I would like to grow and develop in a pretty foundation border. I got the ferns cheap and they will help my first objective. As I can, I will add more plants and soil amendments, so that is what I'm asking for - where do I EVENTUALLY want to go with this, etc. I appreciate all your inputs! Please add as you have thoughts!...See Moremiketropic
7 years agopoaky1
7 years agopoaky1
7 years agomiketropic
7 years agopoaky1
7 years agopoaky1
7 years agomiketropic
7 years agojoeinmo 6b-7a
7 years agomiketropic
7 years agopoaky1
7 years agopoaky1
7 years agojoeinmo 6b-7a
7 years agolast modified: 7 years agopoaky1
7 years agorickl144
7 years agomiketropic
7 years agomiketropic
7 years agopoaky1
7 years agopoaky1
7 years agopoaky1
7 years agojoeinmo 6b-7a
7 years agopoaky1
7 years agopoaky1
7 years agopoaky1
7 years agojoeinmo 6b-7a
7 years agomiketropic
7 years agopoaky1
7 years agojoeinmo 6b-7a
7 years agopoaky1
7 years agojoeinmo 6b-7a
7 years agopoaky1
7 years agopoaky1
7 years agojoeinmo 6b-7a
7 years agopoaky1
7 years agojoeinmo 6b-7a
7 years agopoaky1
7 years agolast modified: 7 years agojoeinmo 6b-7a
7 years agopoaky1
7 years agojoeinmo 6b-7a
7 years agolast modified: 7 years agopoaky1
7 years agopoaky1
7 years agopoaky1
7 years agojoeinmo 6b-7a
7 years agolast modified: 7 years agopoaky1
7 years agomiketropic
7 years agopoaky1
7 years agojoeinmo 6b-7a
7 years agolast modified: 7 years agojoeinmo 6b-7a
7 years agolast modified: 7 years agopoaky1
7 years ago
Related Stories
REMODELING GUIDES6 Steps to Planning a Successful Building Project
Put in time on the front end to ensure that your home will match your vision in the end
Full StoryDINING ROOMSNew This Week: 6 Modern Dining Zones in Homes Big and Small
Look to splashy accent walls, right-sized tables and indoor slides to make the most of your open layout
Full StorySALVAGEDIY: Secrets of Successful Upcycling
Learn how to find and customize salvaged pieces and materials to create one-of-a-kind furniture and accessories you love
Full StoryARCHITECTUREHave It Your Way — What Makes Architecture Successful
Universal appeal doesn't exist in design. The real beauty of any home lies in individualization and imagination
Full StoryFURNITURE10 Secrets of Successful Secondhand Furniture Shopping
Design professionals offer tips on how, where and what to buy
Full StoryINSIDE HOUZZTell Us Your Houzz Success Story
Have you used the site to connect with professionals, browse photos and more to make your project run smoother? We want to hear your story
Full StoryCLOSETSThe 15 Most Popular Closet Luxuries on Houzz
Turn distressing disarray into streamlined perfection with closet organizers and amenities like these
Full StoryFARMHOUSESPhotos of 2013: The Most Popular Farmhouse Spaces
These comfy, bright spaces churned up a lot of attention over the past year. See why
Full StoryBATHROOM DESIGN7 Reasons to Give Your Bath Zone a Living Room Vibe
With a few living room–like touches, you can transform your bathroom into a practical, relaxing retreat that’s overflowing with personality
Full StoryMOST POPULARKitchen Evolution: Work Zones Replace the Triangle
Want maximum efficiency in your kitchen? Consider forgoing the old-fashioned triangle in favor of task-specific zones
Full Story
rickl144