I think the gray on those houses is attractive, as is ceezee's. I like colors that set off the landscape colors, including various shades of green, and gray is one that does. You can also find a house in real life you like and try to get the paint color name from the owners. SW can color match if it's a different brand.

Thanks, it is true that the sun in Florida influences the color palette! We live in the city of St Pete a few blocks from a lake, so it doesn't necessarily need to be beachy, and the houses on each side of us are yellow brick and light khaki. We do want to find a green-blue-gray for the body of the house, but a shade that is lighter than Restorative may be better given the heft of the house as you say. We are thinking the Sherwin Williams color "Valiant Blue" might be a better option. We don't want all of the window trim to be white, but instead want to find a color that will go well with the white sashes and grilles. We do like the haint blue porch ceilings, and if there is a way to incorporate this without it becoming too busy that would be great. Thanks again!

What about Iron Gray? Would it be too dark for our wooded setting?

Skies the limit to be honest. Obviously the window frames are going to be white based on the last picture so you are going to be somewhat relegated to the softer parts of the color spectrum. Is the roof changing color?