Need help staining alder dresser

8 years ago

HI, bought beautiful unfinished alder dresser for my spanish colonial place. I've used wood conditioner and gel stains before, but woodworkerssource.com has great pic and recipe for color I want. Any one have experience using Golden Fruitwood dye, then Zinsser Sealcoat and then gel stain?I appreciate any input. Im getting cold feet, afraid I"ll mess up, even though I have sample boards to get my stain right: Here is link to #2 effect: (and text)

http://www.woodworkerssource.com/blog/tips-tricks/6-alder-wood-finishes-for-rustic-reclaimed-weathered-or-distressed-looks/

Alder is a wood that doesn’t accept stains very well, resulting in
blotchy color. Even though we’re going for a rustic or distressed
appearance, a blotchy stain can still look downright ugly. Perhaps try
this finishing method to get nice, even color. For greater effect, fill
the cracks with black epoxy before applying this finish.

Apply a light colored dye. In this sample, that’s Golden Fruitwood, and it makes a light reddish to pink color.
Apply a sealer. Zinsser SealCoat is a fine choice because it’s
universal. One coat is all you need, let it dry, then if it feels like
it needs it, do a quick and light scuff sand to remove dust nibs in the
sealer.
Apply a gel stain to glaze the color. For this sample we used Old
Masters Dark Walnut Gel Stain, which is a very dark brown. Wipe it on to
the surface, then wipe it off. Be careful to be gentle enough that the
gel leaves a good, even coat of color on the board.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (3)

salex
8 years ago
First and foremost: Start with one small piece (e.g., a drawer front). Do all the steps. If you're happy, great; if not, it's only one piece - sand it to bare and start over with a different finishing process.

I have not done this exact series of steps but regularly use a similar process: 1 application of a custom-mixed water-based dye (a mix of 3 TransTint colors, to match all my other wood); 1 coat of SealCoat; and then either several coats of clear, or a coat of gel stain followed by the clear coats. Here are the things I think will be important to know for your first time using this process:

Step 1: The dye. This is when you're most likely to see blotching, especially with soft woods like alder. Start by applying the dye very lightly - you can always apply more to make it darker. Applying dye as a spray is usually less likely to blotch than wiping or brushing.*

Step 2: The SealCoat. I have applied SealCoat with rags, foam, and bristle brushes. The denatured alcohol in the SealCoat can actually lift the dye a bit if you get aggressive in your application, so since you're starting with a dye, I'd recommend using a bristle-brush suited for oil-based finishes. Keep in mind that SealCoat most definitely dries quickly and gets tacky as it dries - work quickly.

Step 3: The gel stain. Easy. Use one rag to apply, and a clean, dry rag to wipe off. If it's not dark enough, repeat (while still wet).

Again, start with just one small piece... and good luck!

*If you get major blotching with just the dye, you can try starting your second attempt -
on clean, sanded wood - with a very thin application of SealCoat or a
50/50 mix of SealCoat/denatured alcohol, then a light high-grit sanding,
and then apply the dye.
casseybug
Original Author
8 years ago
Thank you Salex. Since the pic on recipe looks so much like what I want, I'm going to follow the recipe. I have scrap Alder. Thanks for your technique tips....definitely appreciate it.
Related Discussions
Alder Flooring? I need your help!
Q
Comments (5)
Cherry is harder than alder. I have been in a wonderful log home that used cherry floors. The large windows well illuminated the hundreds of small dents in the floor. The home was in that awkward phase between baby and child and the dents had not yet blended together to form "patina". You could see what it could become in the traffic patterns where the dents and wear was more numerous. The darker color of the cherry only emphasised the areas of wear and tear with the less worn areas like under the piano. I personally could NEVER in a million years live with a floor like that. Alder is even softer and I won't even do cabinetry in it without a customer signing a waiver of understanding. It's up to you, but I think you sound more like a hickory or pecan flooring person than an alder. Maybe just tweak the stain a bit to be more of a color that you like. Don't match anything though! Matching wood floors and wood cabinets isn't a good look at all. They blend in together and you lose the specialness of both.
...See More
Help! Dresser was stained and is not right, what do I do? pic
Q
Comments (24)
From a pure functionality perspective, I don't really much care for that piece. I'd be worried that the baby might get his head bumped against the raised ledge on the right--either by someone changing baby or later by the baby himself if he tried to sit up or was squirming. In addition to the issues that you brought up regarding the stain, it just does not look like a well designed piece of baby furniture. It looks like a piece where they are trying to make it still be useful after the baby stage. Chances are, however, you will invest in a new set of children's furniture in 2-3 years and may want a different coordinated look so just get a simple changing table that works for the next 1-2 years and assume you will either use it for another baby or get rid of it. BTW, for my 3rd child I did not even use a changing table as I had disposed of the one I had after baby #2 and was not about to spend a few hundred on such a temporary piece of furniture. I just used a good quality pad which I slid under her older sister's bed and more often than not I changed her on the bed with a plastic pad below. Diapers I stored in a cloth diaper stacker.
...See More
Staining and Finishing Knotty Alder front door
Q
Comments (8)
In my experience, the exterior of a door is better finished with marine spar varnish over whatever stain is used. Adding UV protector to the spar gives the longest lasting protection. That protection is dependent on weather and how much direct sunlight the door is subject to, however. Full sun in warm climates may necessitate refinishing in less than two years, while finishes with no/very little sun in cooler climates can do fine for years. Using an 'All in One' product seldom gives the look/durability of stain/finish applications. And prevents any further staining/darkening of the piece. Stain used outside will be subject to sun fading---that is why the UV proctectant additive is needed. Stain used on the inside will also be subject to fading if sun hits the piece. UV helpos there also. Take off the hinges---getting finish under them helps with protection. To apply stain---use rubber gloves and a soft cotton(lintless) rag. An old Tshirt is great. A light hand sanding---220 grit paper on a sanding block/held in hand for grooves/etc----will be fine prep for the first finish coat. A coat of spar varnish---let dry for 24 hours. Resand by hand as above---just to knock off any fuzzies, not sand to totally smooth. Apply another coat of varnish. Let dry for 24 hours. Use 0000 steel wool to smooth the surface. Apply one more coat of varnish. I generally tell mif a reapplication is needed by looking at the existing finish closely. Crazing---a network of tiny interconnecting cracks or lines is the first indicator. Fading of the finish is the second. To refinish, simply sand off the top layer of varnish and reapply a coat of new.
...See More
Staining & finishing Alder bookcases--Recommendations?
Q
Comments (2)
Here is a discussion that may be of some help. I highly recommend trying different approaches on scrap, undersides, etc., before you commit to front and center of your project. I don't see a lot of alder here in the midwest. But the last time I used it, I liked the look of a hide glue size the best. A wash coat of shellac or some of the canned pre-conditioners might also work, depending upon your stain. Here is a link that might be useful: Staining alder
...See More
salex
8 years ago
That is a nice-looking finish. Please post photos when you're finished! I don't have many wood-working friends and I love seeing other people's work.

Need help staining alder dresser

Comments (3)

salex

casseybug
Original Author

Related Discussions

salex

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Need help staining alder dresser

Comments (3)

salex

casseybugOriginal Author

Related Discussions

salex

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

casseybug
Original Author